Research Article |
Corresponding author: Geo Coppens d’Eeckenbrugge ( geo.coppens@cirad.fr ) Academic editor: Alexander Sennikov
© 2019 Maxime Rome, Geo Coppens d’Eeckenbrugge.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Rome M, Coppens d’Eeckenbrugge G (2019) Imprecise descriptions of Passiflora riparia Martius ex Masters led to redundant descriptions as P. emiliae Sacco, P. crenata Feuillet & Cremers, P. pergrandis Holm-Nielsen & Lawesson and P. fernandezii Escobar. PhytoKeys 117: 1-27. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.117.30672
|
Passiflora riparia was incompletely described by Masters, who cited specimens of Martius and Spruce. While Spruce 2191, the unique syntype with an observable corona, exhibits a reduced outermost series of filaments, the accompanying iconography represents two equal outer series. Later descriptions have neither added significant information nor corrected the inconsistency in the corona description, so that four closely related species have been distinguished on the basis of traits not properly documented for P. riparia: P. emiliae (unequal outer series of filaments), P. crenata (bract color), P. pergrandis (flower size and sepal awn length), and P. fernandezii (hypanthium pubescence and shape). The present study compares (i) the descriptions of the above-mentioned taxa and (ii) 43 associated vouchers, as well as live specimens from two associated P. crenata populations. These and other specimens were georeferenced for a comparison of their distribution and habitat. Of the five P. riparia descriptions found in floras, only that of the Flora of Ecuador appears clearly divergent, corresponding in fact to P. tolimana. Those of the four other taxa only differ by unequal corona filaments (except for P. crenata) and the pubescence of floral parts. However, 22 vouchers associated with all these descriptions (including 16 for P. riparia), as well as the live specimens, share both these traits; the other 21 vouchers were uninformative and/or could not be assigned to any of the five species. The wider sample of 62 specimens indicates no significant differences in either geographic or in climatic distribution (lowlands of the Amazon basin), and a marked preference for riparian habitats. Thus, their very close morphology and ecology justify the placement of P. emiliae, P. crenata, P. pergrandis and P. fernandezii as synonyms of P. riparia, designating Spruce 2191 as epitype. The most similar species, P. ambigua (20 specimens mapped), differs in corolla and bract color, as well as a distribution centered along the tropical Andes of South America and in Central America, in more diverse habitats.
Passifloraceae , subgenus Passiflora, series Laurifoliae
Five subgenera are currently recognized in the genus Passiflora L.: Passiflora, Astrophea (DC.) Mast., Decaloba (DC.) Rchb., Deidamioides (Harms) Killip and Tetrapathea (DC.) P. S. Green. Subgenus Passiflora, rich with more than 250 species, is characterized by large flowers with a corona made of several rows of filaments. Its supersection Laurifoliae (Cervi) Feuillet & J. M. MacDougal includes several series, organized around a clear morphological pattern (
According to
Martius’ specimen consists of two samples with much deteriorated flowers, which do not allow assessing the length of filament series. However, one of them holds a brief note in Latin handwritten by Martius, with incomplete information about the filaments: “Corona exterior serie simplici constat filorum alborum quae vittis quadratis violaceis picta sunt atque compressa; interior similis crassior”. This indicates the existence of two outer series, the inner one with stronger filaments, but gives no direct information on their relative length. The flower of Spruce 2191, the specimen examined by Masters, has two very unequal series of external filaments, the outermost being reduced, with few short filaments. Thus, the illustration accompanying Masters’ description of Passiflora riparia reflects misinterpretation of the syntypes concerning an important diagnostic trait in the series. However, this anomaly was not corrected in the successive re-descriptions of the species (
Thus, in 1966, Sacco described Passiflora emiliae Sacco in the Boletim do Nacional Museum (Rio de Janeiro), from two Kuhlmann specimens that had been first determined as P. riparia. Indeed, as in Spruce 2191, the Kuhlmann specimens correspond to Masters’ drawing of P. riparia, with the exception of their two unequal outer series of filaments. This is why
Passiflora crenata
In the Flora of Ecuador,
In 1989, Escobar described Passiflora fernandezii Escobar as a close Bolivian relative of P. riparia: “P. fernandezii most closely ressembles P. riparia […], but differs from it by the pubescence and shape of the hypanthium. Both of these characters are variable in collections ascribed to that species […] so that further study of the Passiflora riparia complex is needed.”
Here, we revise the different treatments of P. riparia and compare them with the descriptions and types of P. emiliae, P. crenata, P. pergrandis, and P. fernandezii, and re-examine the other vouchers associated to them by the different authors of these species. Thus, we can demonstrate that, based on the textual descriptions of P. riparia by Martius and Masters and the observation of both syntypes, Martius 3228 and Spruce 2191, as well as the polymorphism observed on the reference vouchers mentioned in the different treatments, there is no ground for differentiating these five species. We also verify that none of these five taxa can be differentiated by its adaptation, using label information and a multivariate analysis of climates in their respective ranges, while observing that P. ambigua is marginally sympatric with them, less strongly related to riparian habitats, and adapted to a wider range of climates, particularly in tropical highlands. Consequently, we place P. emiliae, P. crenata, P. pergrandis and P. fernandezii in synonymy of P. riparia, and provide a more complete and precise description that takes into account the pan-Amazonian geographical distribution of this species and its attendant polymorphism.
A first comparison confronts the descriptions of P. riparia by
A second comparison bears on all available vouchers (43 specimens; see Table
Other 94 herbarium specimens have been observed and determined, for a comparative study of the habitat of the same taxa. Some sheets were studied from scans provided by the host herbaria. The complete list, comprising 137 materials initially classified under P. riparia or one of its four presumed synonyms or under P. ambigua, is listed in the appendix. For the distribution study, only fertile samples allowing unambiguous determination were retained, as well as other good quality reports (including photographs); the P. crenata sample from French Guiana was reduced to 11 specimens, to avoid an excessive weight for this taxon. When label information allowed, geographic coordinates were assigned to the voucher using Google Earth and gazetteers, the collecting sites were mapped and a distribution model was developed, using the MAXENT software and 19 bioclimatic variable layers from the Worldclim database at a 2'30" grid resolution (corresponding roughly to 4.4 × 4.6 km at Equator; http://www.worldclim.org/current) (
Furthermore, 19 bioclimatic variables corresponding to the collection sites were extracted from the Worldclim database (
Table
Comparison of descriptions of P. riparia, P. emiliae, P. crenata, P. fernandezii, P. pergrandis and P. ambigua, with additional information from related iconography (*). Traits diverging from the original description of Masters are highlighted in bold font.
P. riparia (Master, 1872) | P. riparia (Killip, 1938) | P. riparia (Cervi, 1997) | P. riparia (Tillett, 2003) | P. riparia (Holm-Nielsen et al., 1988) | P. emiliae (Sacco, 1966) | P. crenata (Feuillet & Cremers, 1984) | P. fernandezii (Escobar, 1989) | P. pergrandis (Holm-Nielsen & Lawesson, 1987) | P. ambigua (Hemsley, 1922) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stem | shape | terete to striate | terete | terete | – | – | terete, subangular or striate | terete to angular | angular to striate | terete to striate | terete to angular |
pubescence | glabrous | glabrous | glabrous | – | glabrous | glabrous | glabrous | sparingly pubescent | glabrous | glabrous | |
Stipules | shape | setaceous* | linear | linear | linear | setaceous | linear, acute | linear | linear | absent from the type | very slender |
pubescence | glabrous* | glabrous | glabrous | – | glabrous | glabrous | glabrous | – | glabrous | glabrous | |
size (cm) | – | 0.3 to 0.4 long | 0.3 to 0.4 long | 0.4 long | 0.5 cm | ca. 1 | 1.5–2.0 | ca 1 × 0.05 | – | 0.5–1.6 × 0.04–0.1 | |
Petiole | length (cm) | 1.35–2.25 | 1.5–2 | 1.5–2 | until 4.5 | 3 | 1.5–2 | 1.5–2 | 1.2–1.8 | 2–3 | 2–6 |
gland position | below middle | at middle | at middle | at middle | above middle | below middle | proximal half | at middle | below middle | at middle | |
Leaves | base | cordate to rounded | rounded, retuse or narrowed | rounded to retuse | rounded, retuse or narrowed | truncate to obtuse | rounded | rounded, obtuse or slightly cuneate | rounded | obtuse to truncate | rounded or cuneate |
apex | slightly acuminate | abruptly acuminate | abruptly acuminate | abruptly acuminate | acuminate | acuminate, mucronate | acuminate, sometimes mucronate | abruptly acuminate | acuminate | cuspidately acuminate | |
margin | entire to serrate | entire to minutely serrulate | entire to minutely serrulate | – | entire | entire | entire | entire | entire | entire to serrulate | |
pubescence | glabrous* | glabrous | glabrous | glabrous | glabrous | glabrous | glabrous | glabrous except for a few scattered trichomes at base on abaxial surface | glabrous | glabrous | |
size (Lxl, cm) | 10.8–13.5 × 5.4–8.1 | 10–15 × 4.5–8 | 10–15 × 4.5–8 | 19 × 9 | 15–17 × 8–9 | 10.5–14.5 × 5.5–6.5 | 6–13 × 2.5–7 | 5–9.4 × 2.5–4.2 | 15–20 × 9–10 | 14–23 × 7.2–12 | |
Inflorescence | type | axillary racemes | on short axillary branches, with no or reduced leaves | – | in axillary branches with or without reduced leaves, occasionally axillary to normal leaves | solitary | axillary, solitary or pseudoracemes* | axillary, aggregated at the end of stems | – | a distal bud developing to a short shoot, forming a conspicuous indeterminate inflorescence | solitary, axillary or in pseudoracemes |
Bracts | color | colored | reddish | – | reddish | – | – | white | – | – | green |
size (Lxl, cm) | large | 3–4 × 1.5–2 | 3–4 × 1.5–2 | 3–5 × 2–3 | 4.5 × 1 | 2.5–3.5 × 1.4–2.2 | 4–5 × 2–3 | 1.9–2.4 × 1–1.4 | 5 × 4 | 3–6 × 3–4 | |
pubescence | glabrous* | glabrous | glabrous | – | glabrous | pubescent | pubescent | pubescent | pubescent | pubescent | |
Hypanthium | pubescence | pubescent | glabrous | glabrous | – | glabrous | pubescent | – | – | pubescent | pubescent |
shape/size | cylindric campanulate* | cylindric-campanulate | cylindric-campanulate | broadly funnelform | 1–1.5 × 2 cm, broadly campanulate | cylindric-campanulate, 1.3 cm long | 1 cm long | funnelform, 1.6–2 cm long, 2.4–2.9 cm wide at apex, 1–1.3 cm wide at base | campanulate, 1 × 2 cm | oblate, deeply intruded | |
Sepals | size (Lxl, cm) | 3.75 × 1.8–2.3 | 4–5 × 2 | 4–5 × 2 | 4–5 × 2 cm | 4 × 1.5 | 3.5–4 × 1.3–1.8 | 6 × 3 | 2.6–3.1 × 1.5–2.1 | 6 × 3.5–4 | 4–5 × 1.5–1.8 |
pubescence | – | glabrous | glabrous | – | glabrous | pubescent | pubescent | – | pubescent | pubescent | |
color | – | – | – | pinkish white | lilac | white | greenish white | – | – | white outside pink to dark purple inside | |
Petals | size (Lxl, cm) | shorter than sepals | 4 × 0.8 | 4 × 0.8 | shorter than sepals | 2.5 × 0.5–1 | 3–3.5 × 0.8–1 | 5 × 1–1.5 | ca 1.4 × 0.7 | 5.5–6 × 2 | 3–4 × 1 |
color | – | – | white | pinkish white | lilac | white | white | – | white | white strongly spotted with rose-purple | |
Outermost series of filaments | number | 2? * | 2 | 2 | 2 (rarely 1) | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 |
shape | thicker than the inner filaments | filamentose, carnose, ca. 2 mm thick | filamentose, carnose, ca. 2 mm thick | the inner to 2 mm thick, filamentous, fleshy, forming a spherical cage around the androgynoecium, outer series more slender | filiform | the outermost filiform, the second serie ligulate | large and erected, enlarged at base | filamentous | outer series minutely setaceous, filaments of second series stout, ligulate | the outermost filiform, the second thicker | |
color | red striped | white banded with blue or violet | banded with blue or violet and white | banded red to purplish | _ | white and red stripped | white and purple stripped | banded with purple | white and dark violet | white banded with red or purple | |
relative length | same length* | same length (4–5 cm) | subequal (4–5 cm) | same length (4–5 cm) | same length (6–7 cm) | outer series (1–1.3 cm) shorter than next one (2.5–3.5 cm) | both as long as sepals | the outer filaments ca 0.6 cm long, ca 0.4 mm wide, the inner ones 2.3–2.5 cm long, ca 1 mm wide | outer series 0.2 cm, second series 5 cm | the outermost shorter than the second series (sometimes atrophied) | |
Inner series | number | many | many | many | 2 or more series within the floral tube | 5–6 series | many | 4 (more or less distinct) | many | many | many |
length | shorter than outer series, with intermediate series atrophied and the innermost slightly longer | irregular mass of tubercles covering about 6 mm of the height of the tube, the innermost filaments about 2 mm long | irregular mass of tubercles covering about 6 mm of the height of the tube, the innermost series filaments about 2 mm long | 2 mm long | third series 0.5 cm, filiform, then 2 or 3 series 0.2–0.3 cm, filiform, irregularly arranged. The innermost 1 cm, erect, entire, borne just below corona. | shorter than outer series, with intermediate series atrophied and the innermost slightly longer | short | irregular rows of filaments 0.5–2 mm long in lower half of inner surface | third series close to operculum, minutely tuberculate 1–2 mm | intermediate series atrophied and the innermost slightly longer | |
Operculum | shape | membranous, horizontal, margin recurved, fimbriate | membranous, horizontal, margin recurved, crenulate | membranous, horizontal, margin recurved, crenulate | horizontal, recurved margin with short, capitellate filaments | 0.5 cm, recurved, margin minutely sinuate to lobulate | membranous, horizontal, with margin recurved, crenulate | horizontal | horizontal, membranaceous, nonplicate | menbranaceous, recurved, the margin with short fimbriate filaments | membranous, horizontal, with margin recurved, crenulate |
Andro-gynophore | length (cm) | slightly longer than the flower tube. | – | – | – | – | 1.5 cm | 1 cm | – | – | 1.5–2 cm |
Ovary | pubescence | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Fruit | shape | globose | ovoid to globose | ovoid to globose | ovoid or globose | ovoid | – | ovoid | – | – | ovoid to oblong |
size (Lxl, cm) | larger than a cherry | 3–4 × 2.5–3.5 | 3–4 × 2.5–3.5 cm | 10 × 2.5–5 | 6 × 2.5 | – | 6 × 4 | – | – | 10–12 × 6–7 |
As
Based on Peruvian and Brazilian herbarium specimens, the description by
The description of P. riparia by
In 1966, Sacco described P. emiliae from Brazilian herbarium specimens hitherto classified under P. riparia.
The description of P. fernandezii (Escobar, 1989), from one herbarium specimen, differs from that of P. riparia by two unequal outer series of filaments, a scattered pubescence on stems, leaf abaxial surfaces, and the funnelform hypanthium. It seems to have smaller leaves, bracts and perianth, as compared to the other species in Table
The description of P. pergrandis, only based on the Ecuadorian type specimen, is closely similar to those of P. crenata and P. emiliae. The qualitative criteria, as leaf shape, the petiole gland position, the pubescence of different parts, the petal color, the hypanthium shape, and the disposition of inner filaments series are identical. The two outer series of filaments are very unequal, the outer elements being 2 mm long (vs. 50 mm for the second series). The description does not mention the color of bracts and sepals. Flowers, leaves and bracts seem to be larger than in P. crenata and P. emiliae, but comparable with the observations of
As compared to all species descriptions mentioned above, that of P. ambigua is only differentiated by the color of the bracts, petals and sepals.
Table
Comparison of herbarium materials referenced in the descriptions of P. riparia, P. emiliae, P. crenata, P. fernandezii, P. pergrandis and P. ambigua. Two specimens of P. crenata from French Guiana have been replaced by field observations on populations at the collecting site. Question marks indicate that the trait could not be determined with confidence (e.g. pubescence on voucher scans). Dashes indicate that it could not be observed on the voucher (e.g. floral traits on sterile vouchers).
Specimen | Origin | Authors' determination | Petiolar gland position | Pseudo-raceme | Pubescence | Bracts size | Bract color | Perianth color | Outer series of filaments | Observations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Master (1872): P. riparia | ||||||||||
Spruce2191 (ST) | Brazil | P. riparia | middle | yes | peduncle - bracts - hypanthium - exterior of sepals | 3 × 2 cm | reddish | white | Unequal, the outermost filiform and short, next one thicker and longer | |
Martius 3228 (LT, IT) | Brazil | P. riparia | below middle | yes | bracts - ovary - fruit | 3 × 2 cm | reddish pink | pink inside, white outside | "the outermost filiform, the second one thicker" (Latin handnote from Martius) | |
|
||||||||||
Ducke 17338 | Brazil, Para | P. riparia | middle | yes | ? | 4 × 2 cm | reddish | white | One, the outermost being completely atrophied | corona banded white and violet, androgynophore white |
Ducke 24044 | Brazil, Amazonas | P. cf. laurifolia | apex | no | ? | – | green | violet | Two unequal | no inner filaments, fruit acuminate |
Killip 26307 | Peru | impossible | middle | – | – | – | – | – | – | sterile plant, P. riparia or P. ambigua? |
Killip 26683 | Peru | P. riparia | below middle | – | – | – | – | – | – | "flowers blue and white" (label) |
Killip 28214 | Peru | impossible | near apex | – | – | – | – | – | – | sterile plant |
Killip 28940 | Peru | impossible | middle | – | – | – | – | – | – | sterile plant, P. riparia or P. ambigua? |
Killip 29012 | Peru | impossible | middle | – | – | 4 × 2 cm | – | – | – | fruit orange, P. riparia or P. ambigua? |
Klug 3897 | Peru | P. riparia | middle | yes | peduncle - bracts - calyx - petioles of pseudoraceme | 2 × 1.5 cm | reddish | white | one, the outermost being completely atrophied | |
Klug 4037 | Peru | P. riparia | middle | yes | ? | – | – | grayish | one, the outermost being completely atrophied | |
Spruce 1172 | Brazil | P. cf. laurifolia | apex | no | peduncle | – | – | – | – | |
Spruce 1394 | Brazil | P. laurifolia | apex | no | ? | – | green | red | two unequal | no inner filaments |
Spruce 3390 | – | P. phellos | apex | no | ? | 1.5 × 0.5 cm | green | red | two unequal | corky stems |
Swallen 3390 | Brazil, Para | P. laurifolia | apex | no | ? | – | green | purple | two unequal | |
Williams 1392 | Peru | impossible | below middle | – | – | – | – | – | – | sterile plant, P. riparia or P. ambigua? |
Williams 1440 | Peru | P. riparia | middle | yes | – | – | reddish | white | one, the outermost being completely atrophied | |
Williams 3126 | Peru | impossible | middle | no | fruits - peduncles | – | – | – | – | P. riparia or P. ambigua? |
Williams 5637 | Peru | P. venusta | apex | no | ? | 4 × 2.2 cm | green | purple red | – | triangular sepals and petals, coriaceous leaves |
Williams 5848 | Peru | P. cf. venusta | below apex | no | – | – | green | – | – | coriaceous leaves |
Williams 6300 | Peru | impossible | below apex | – | – | – | – | – | – | sterile plant, P. riparia or P. ambigua? |
Williams 6378 | Peru | P. venusta | near apex | no | ovary | – | green | – | two unequal series | |
Williams 7876 | Peru | P. riparia | middle | no | ovary - peduncle - bracts | 3 × 1.5 cm | reddish | white | Unequal, the outermost filiform and short, next one thicker and longer | |
Williams 7996 | Peru | P. riparia | below middle | yes | peduncle - bracts - stipule and petioles of pseudoraceme | 3.5 × 2 cm | reddish | – | – | |
|
||||||||||
Kuhlmann 1066 (HT) | Brazil, Mato Grosso | P. riparia | below middle | yes | ovary - peduncle - bracts- hypanthium - petioles of pseudoraceme | 2.5–3.5 × 1.5–2.5 cm | white | white | Unequal, the outermost filiform and short, next one thicker and longer | short inner series (1–2 mm) in the hypanthium |
Kuhlmann 1064 (PT) | Brazil, Mato Grosso | P. riparia | below middle | yes | ovary - peduncles - bracts-hypanthium - petiole of pseudoraceme | 2.5–3.5 × 1.5–2.5 cm | white | white | Unequal, the outermost filiform and short, next one thicker and longer | short inner series (1–2 mm) in the hypanthium |
|
||||||||||
Feuillet 573 | French Guiana | P. riparia | middle | yes | peduncles - calyx - bracts - petioles of pseudoraceme | 4–5 × 2–3 cm | white | white | Unequal, the outermost filiform and short, next one thicker and longer | |
Prevost 563 | French Guiana | P. riparia | below middle | yes | peduncle - bracts - fruit | 5–6 × 4 cm | – | – | – | fruit green with white spots |
|
||||||||||
Rome specimens | French Guiana | P. riparia | below middle | yes | peduncles - calyx - bracts - petioles of pseudoraceme | 4.5–6.2 × 2.7–4.3 cm | white to pink | white to greenish white | Unequal, the outermost filiform and short or absent, the second one thicker and longer | intermediate series atrophied and the innermost slightly longer; operculum membranous, horizontal, with margin recurved, crenulate |
|
||||||||||
Holm-Nielsen 1040 | Ecuador | P. tolimana | below apex | no | ? | 1.5 × 0.5 cm | reddish | lilac | two subequal series | bracts short and acute |
Knapp 6242 | Ecuador | P. tolimana | apex | no | ? | 1.5 × 0.4 cm | reddish | pinkish lavender | two subequal series | bracts short and acute, inner series oriented towards the androgynophore, covering the entrance to the hypanthium |
|
||||||||||
Schultes 9900 | Brazil, Amazonas | P. phellos | apex | – | ? | 3 × 1 cm | green | – | – | corky stems |
Spruce 1394 | Brazil, Amazonas | P. laurifolia |
see above, among materials cited by |
|||||||
Spruce 1172 | Brazil, Amazonas | P. cf. laurifolia | ||||||||
Spruce 3390 | P. phellos | |||||||||
Ducke 17338 | Brazil, Para | P. riparia | see above, among materials cited by |
|||||||
Allen 3340 | Colombia | P. laurifolia | apex | no | ? | 3 × 1.5 cm | green | lavender | two unequal series | – |
Jativa 439 | Ecuador | P. ambigua | middle | yes | ovary | 4.5 × 2.5 cm | green | petals white outside, pink inside | – | |
Warush BBAE86 | Ecuador | impossible | below middle | no | fruits - peduncles | – | – | – | – | P. riparia or P. ambigua? |
Holm-Nielsen 1040 | Ecuador | P. tolimana |
see above, among materials cited by |
|||||||
Smith 3157 | Guyana | P. laurifolia | apex | bracts - peduncles | 3.5 × 2 cm | green | red | two unequal series | ||
Ancuash 506 | Peru | impossible | middle | yes | fruits - peduncles | – | – | – | – | fruit with a uniform color, could be P. ambigua |
Schunke 907 | Peru | P. riparia | below middle | yes | ? | 2.5 × 1.5 cm | reddish | – | one, the outermost being completely atrophied | |
Revilla 241 | Peru | P. riparia | below middle | yes | peduncles - bracts - calyx - fruit | 2.5 × 1.5 cm | reddish | white | Unequal, the outermost filiform and short, next one thicker and longer | long peduncles |
Klug 3897 | Peru | P. riparia | see above, among materials cited by |
|||||||
Schunke 3555 | Peru | P. riparia | middle | yes | ? | 1.5 × 1 cm | purple | – | Unequal, the outermost filiform and short, next one thicker and longer | fruit pale green, with white spots |
Schunke 3579 | Peru | P. riparia | middle | yes | ? | 2.5 × 1.5 cm | reddish purple | – | one, the outermost being completely atrophied | immature fruits green with white dots |
Schunke 2112 | Peru | P. riparia | middle | yes | ? | 3 × 1.5 cm | violet | – | one, the outermost being completely atrophied | |
|
||||||||||
Harling 13771 | Ecuador | P. riparia | middle | yes | ? | 3.5–4.5 × 3–4 cm | violet | more or less white | one, the outermost being completely atrophied | inner series of filaments reduced, filaments cross-striped in white and dark violet |
|
||||||||||
Fernández Casas 3341 | Bolivia | P. riparia | middle | yes | peduncles - bracts - calyx - petioles of pseudoraceme (some trichomes on leaves of pseudoracemes) | 2.5 × 1.5 cm | white | white | Unequal, the outermost filiform and short, next one thicker and longer |
The two collections used in the original description of P. riparia provide complementary information. Spruce 2191 is the most complete; on the sample conserved in Paris, the corona of its flowers has a single series of well-developed filaments (about 35 mm long), whereas the outermost series is severely reduced (slender filaments ca. 5–10 mm). Its bracts and the abaxial sepal surface are slightly pubescent. The bracts are reddish (confirmed by a handwritten note on the Kew specimen). Two samples belong to Martius 3228. The first one has very degraded flowers and it is impossible to see the series of external filaments and the internal structure. However, a handwritten note by Martius mentions the presence of two series of main filaments, the outermost being filiform and the second one thicker; the corolla is described as pink outside and white inside, and the bracts as pink to red, which is consistent with the reddish color of their dry remains. The second sample bears long peduncles, however the flowers themselves are lacking. In these samples, the bracts, hypanthium, peduncles, and the abaxial face of the sepals are pubescent.
Out of the 22 specimens mentioned by
The description of P. emiliae is based on only two herbarium specimens (Kuhlmann 1066 and Kuhlmann 1064) collected from the same locality (margins of Rio Arinos, Mato Grosso). They are very similar to Spruce’s syntype of P. riparia, with the exception of bract color (white vs. reddish in the syntype). As indicated in Sacco’s description, the outermost corona filaments are shorter than in the second series. As in three specimens cited in Killip’s description, the ovary, peduncles, bracts and petioles of pseudoracemes are pubescent.
In the description of P. crenata,
Comparison between flowers of P. riparia and P. crenata. A–C flowers of P. riparia from Alta Floresta, Mato Grosso, Brazil (photo: Rich Hoyer) D flower of P. riparia from Marituba, Para, Brazil (photo: Luis Otavio Adão Teixeiro) E–H flowers of P. crenata from Cacao village, French Guiana. Flower size is indicated by 1 cm white bars.
Both specimens mentioned by
Out of the 20 herbarium specimens cited in the description of P. riparia by
On Harling 13771, the holotype of P. pergrandis, the leaves bear two glands below the middle of petiole. Flowers, surrounded by three violet bracts, are gathered in pseudoracemes. They have a white perianth with one outer series of long filaments (the outermost filaments being vestigial), cross-striped in white and dark violet. The inner series are reduced (2–3 mm long). The pubescence of the plant could not be observed. Thus, Harling 13771 belongs to P. riparia, as assessed from all the traits presented above: submedian petiolar glands, the occurrence of pseudo-racemes, colored bracts, white perianth, and a reduced outermost series of corona filaments.
Wide variation was observed for bract dimensions within the sets of specimens used by the different authors for the different taxa (see also bract size variation within populations in Figure
A total of 83 specimens and live populations were georeferenced, 62 for P. riparia and its presumed synonyms, and 20 for P. ambigua (Table
Distribution of the georeferenced sample used for Ecological Niche Modeling and habitat information retrieved from voucher labels and aerial photographs (when geographic coordinates are very precise).
Species | Specimens/obs. | Ecological info. | Humid habitat | Riparian habitat |
---|---|---|---|---|
P. riparia | 38 | 35 | 28 | 19 |
P. emiliae | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 |
P. crenata | 12 | 12 | 8 | 5 |
P. fernandezii | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 |
P. pergrandis | 7 | 7 | 6 | 5 |
Total | 62 | 59 | 46 | 32 |
P. ambigua | 20 | 18 | 5 | 4 |
Figure
Distribution of examined specimens of P. riparia (X), P. emiliae (red cross), P crenata (blue cross), P. fernandezii (green cross), P. pergrandis (purple cross), and the bioclimatic distribution model, highlighting climates that are marginal (grey), favorable (light yellow), very favorable (light orange) or excellent (bright orange). Black triangles represent distribution of examined specimens of P. ambigua.
Table
Principal component analysis on the bioclimatic variables contributing to the MAXENT distribution model of P. riparia, P. emiliae, P. crenata, P. fernandezii, and P. pergrandis. Factor loadings.
Bioclimatic variable | Factor 1 | Factor 2 | Factor 3 |
---|---|---|---|
2-Mean diurnal range | -0.45 | -0.68 | -0.17 |
5-Max. temp. of warmest month | 0.71 | -0.48 | -0.28 |
6-Min. temp. of coldest month | 0.85 | 0.33 | -0.33 |
8-Mean temp. of wettest quarter | 0.86 | -0.12 | -0.36 |
13-Precipitation of wettest month | 0.55 | 0.40 | 0.63 |
14-Precipitation of driest month | -0.26 | 0.85 | -0.33 |
15-Precipitation seasonality | 0.51 | -0.56 | 0.61 |
18-Precipitation of warmest quarter | -0.35 | 0.57 | 0.21 |
19-Precipitation of coldest quarter | 0.52 | 0.67 | 0.09 |
Explained variance | 3.19 | 2.80 | 1.28 |
Proportion of total | 0.35 | 0.31 | 0.14 |
Most of the confusion in the definition of P. riparia has arisen from the incomplete description by
In 1966, Sacco realized the inconsistency between Killip’s description of P. riparia and two Kuhlmann specimens of this species where he could observe the reduction of the outermost series of filaments. But he used them as types for the description of a new species, P. emiliae, logically differentiated from P. riparia by the outer corona structure. It seems that this new species description remained confidential and only attracted the attention of Cervi, who reclassified a few other exemplars from P. riparia to P. emiliae, such as Ducke 21311, Kuhlmann sn (R136313). Later, in 1997, he changed his mind and followed
Originally, P. crenata was described as an endemic of French Guiana, distinguished from P. riparia by its white bracts and the type of inflorescence. However, bract color at anthesis varies between white and deep red in populations from French Guiana and from Brazil (Figure
The two more recent descriptions of P. pergrandis and P. fernandezii did not present new variations in any of the characters discussed above. Finally, we can conclude that the differences in the descriptions of P. riparia, P. emiliae, P. crenata, P. pergrandis and P. fernandezii are either related to the confusion introduced by the iconography associated with the original description or with the imprecisions related to the initial observation of two dry specimens. More details and variation have logically been documented after the examination of specimens from a wider geographic range, as well as the direct observations on living materials. The variations observed among specimens of P. riparia encompass the variations between this taxon on one hand and P. crenata, P. emiliae, P. fernandezii or P. pergrandis on the other hand. Furthermore, most specimens from the latter taxa have been collected under very similar habitats, dominated by lowland tropical climates in riparian habitats (Table
Passiflora ambigua appears very similar to P. riparia, mostly differing in the color of bracts (green) and the corolla (lilac), but its distribution and ecology are different, with a much lesser frequency of riparian habitats and a capacity to thrive at much higher elevations, up to hillsides in the Andes of tropical South America and Central America.
Gathering P. riparia, P. crenata, P. emiliae, P. fernandezii and P. pergrandis into a single species imposes a new description, taking into account the reduction of the outermost series of corona filaments and variation observed in other traits, on our whole sample. In the following treatment, the lectotype and isotype chosen by Lawesson are logically retained, however, as its damaged flowers do not allow the observation of the corona structure, we choose as epitype the syntype Spruce 2191, i.e., the much better-preserved specimen that was observed by Masters for the original description.
Passiflora emiliae Sacco, Boletim do Museu Nacional de Rio de Janeiro. Botanica 32: 1–5. 1966. Type: Brazil. Mato Grosso, Rio Arinos, Dec. 1914, Kuhlmann 1066 (holotype, R!), Kuhlmann 1064 (paratype, R!).
Passiflora crenata Feuillet & Cremers, Proceedings of the Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen, Series C: Biological and Medical Sciences 87(4): 378. 1984. Type: French Guiana. Road between Roura and the Kaw mountain, 24 Jan. 1983, Feuillet 573 (holotype, CAY!; isotype, BR, P!, U, US).
Passiflora pergrandis Holm-Niels. & Lawesson, Annals of the Missouri Botanical Garden 74(3): 501, f. 4. 1987. Type: Ecuador. Zamora-Chinchipe: Zamora –Gualaquiza road, 5 km N of Cumbaraza, 900 m, 20 Apr. 1974, Harling 13771 (holotype, GB! ; isotype, AAU)
Passiflora fernandezii L. K. Escobar, Phytologia 66(1): 80–81. 1989. Type: Bolivia. Pando: Nicolas Suarez: between Porvenir and Cachuelita, along the trail, 19 Jan 1983, F. Javier Fernández Casas 8341 (holotype, NY; isotypes, MO!, NY).
Brazil. Forest near mouth of Madeira River, Brazilian state of Amazonas (in silvis prope ostium fluvii “Madeira”), March 1819, Martius 3228 (lectotype, M! designated by
Woody liana. Stem terete to subangulate, glabrous to slightly pubescent (on young parts or pseudoracemes), and green; internodes 4–48 cm. Tendrils glabrous, green. Stipules setaceous to narrow linear, generally aristate, yellow green to brown purple, eglandular to glandular (1–2 nectaries), 8.8–18.1 × 0.2–1.4 mm (including an arista 0–2.7 mm), early deciduous. Petiole 1.3–3.8 cm long, green to dark green, slightly canaliculate adaxially, glabrous (pubescent on pseudoracemes), bearing two conspicuous oval sessile glands (about 1 mm long), at or below the middle (0.4–1.3 cm from petiole base). Leaves simple, unlobed, 10.5–21 × 5.5–11 cm, glabrous throughout, green to dark green, adaxial surface lustrous, cordate to rounded at base, obtuse to acute at apex, mucronate and acuminate; margin entire (rarely glandular-serrulate). Inflorescence axillary, sessile, 1-flowered. Peduncles terete, green, pubescent, 1.9–2.8 mm in diameter, 1.4–3.5 cm long; pedicel 6.5–10 mm long. Bracts deciduous (at fruit maturity), pubescent on both sides, white to dark purple or white and more or less pink-purple veined, concave, free to base, 2.5–6.2 × 1.4–4.3 cm, with 3–7 marginal sessile green nectaries in distal half. Flowers axillary, pendulous, 2.8–3.4 cm long (from the base of nectary chamber to the ovary apex), solitary or presented in clusters on pseudoracemes (short internode branches). Nectary chamber pubescent externally, white greenish outside and white inside, 14.8–20.3 mm in diameter, 4.5–11.9 mm in depth. Hypanthium campanulate, pubescent, white greenish outside and white inside, 15–20 mm long and 18–21 mm in diameter at the base of sepals. Sepals pubescent, oblate, 4.2–6.4 × 1.8–2.8 cm, adaxial surface white to slightly pink, abaxial surface white to white greenish, slightly keel-shaped in distal half with a short awn (3–5 mm long). Petals glabrous, oblate, 4.2–5.4 × 1.2–1.6 cm, white. Corona filaments in 6–9 series, banded white and purple to dark purple; two major outer series, slightly curved, unequal: outer series 0–18 mm, second series 43.9–55.4 mm; inner series 1–2 mm, curved filiform, white with purple tip, covering the interior of the hypanthium. Staminal filaments 8–11 mm long, white greenish. Ovary pubescent, white, 8–9 mm long; three styles, white, 9–12 mm long, stigmas white to cream. Androgynophore glabrous, greenish white, 14–17 mm long with an enlarged base about 10 mm wide. Operculum membranous, 4–5 mm long, recurved, shortly fimbriated at margin. Fruit obovoid, round in transversal section, pubescent, 3.6–7.3 cm long, about 2.5–4.8 cm in diameter; pericarp 0.5–1 cm thick; immature fruits green with fine white dots; mature fruits light orange, white spotted, with a sweet translucent pulp. Seeds obovoid, flat, with retuse apex, about 1 cm long.
Following our morphological and ecological analyses, P. emiliae, P. pergrandis, P. fernandezii and P. crenata are placed as synonyms of P. riparia, which reduces the current number of species belonging to series Laurifoliae to 21. Like Passiflora nitida, P. laurifolia or P. ambigua, P. riparia is a new example of a very widely distributed species in this series. In fact, its variability appears relatively limited in the context of its wide distribution.
The description of P. riparia in the Flora of Ecuador corresponds to P. tolimana; Holm-Nielsen 1040 and Knapp 6242 are the only known specimens from Ecuador for this species, hitherto considered endemic to Colombia. The determination of Spruce 2191 under P. ambigua by Lawesson, endorsed by
This research has been carried out with support from the Herbarium of Pontificia Universidad Católica del Ecuador and the Ecuadorian Ministry of the Environment. We thank especially Daniela Cevallos and Katya Romoleroux for their help during our expedition in Ecuador. The first author also thanks the Missouri Botanical Garden, Jim Solomon, and John MacDougal for their help during the week he spent in the herbarium at St. Louis, Mathew Rees (Kew Garden) for his help during Panama and Ecuador trips, Jean-Jacques de Granville for the exceptional welcome in French Guiana, Rich Hoyer (Birdernaturalist) and Luiz Otavio Adão Teixeira for their stunning pictures of P. riparia, and the different herbaria with which we have collaborated for this work: Field Museum herbarium, Paris herbarium, Lyon botanical garden (Frédéric Danet), Cayenne herbarium, New York Botanical Garden, Kew Garden, Munich herbarium (Hajo Esser). Finally, we thank Ana Carolina Mezzonato-Pires and John MacDougal for their comments and corrections to improve the manuscript.
Examined specimens
P. ambigua
BRAZIL. Amazonas: Esperança, mouth of Javari River, non-flood forest, 4-2-1942, Ducke 878 (MO). COLOMBIA. Antioquia: San Luis, 26 Jul. 1981, Hoyos 132 (JAUM). Municipality of Frontino, Las Orquídeas National Park, 31 Jan. 1995, Pipoly 18177 (JAUM). Municipality of Turbo, road of Tapón del Darién, 28 Feb. 1984, Brand 947 (JAUM). Chocó: area of Baudó, 4 Feb. 1967, Fuchs 21744 (COL). Huila: Municipality of Gigante, farm of Adonai Moreno, 20 Dec. 1976, Escobar 435 (MO). Meta: Río Bravo village, La Cristalina stream, El Pital, 4 Mar. 1986, Devia 1121 (MO). COSTA RICA. Puntarenas: Osa Península, 6 Jan. 1994, Aguilar 2974 (CR). Cartago: Orosi, Navarro del Muñeco, 12 Apr. 1998, Blanco 805 (USJ). San José: Vicinity of El General, Jan. 1939, Skutch 3037 (US). ECUADOR. Esmeraldas: El Timbre, near Esmeraldas, 6 Aug. 1962, Jativa 439 (US). Napo: Road Hollín-Loreto-Coca, Chaluayacu Community, 23 Dec. 1988, Cerón 5772 (MO). Pichincha: Alluriquin, 19 Oct. 1921, Werling 458 (QCA). Zamora-Chinchipe: Municipality of Zamora, Road Zamora-Loja, 29 Oct. 1991, Palacios 8811 (MO). Palanda, Río Vergel Valley, 14 Nov. 2006, Werff 22075 (MO). GUATEMALA. Secanquim, 14 May 1914, Cook 79 (US). HONDURAS. Machaca, 8 Feb. 1934, Schipp 1302 (F). MEXICO. Veracruz: Biological station of Los Tuxtlas, 7 Apr. 1971, Calzada 230 (MEXU). Municipality of San Andrés Tuxtla, south of Ebitrolotu, 30 APr. 1973, Villegas Herrera 112 (MEXU). PANAMA. Colón: Santa Rita Ridge, east of transisthmian highway, 16 Dec. 1972, Gentry 6561 (MO). Panamá: just before la Eneida along new trail which begins exactly beside López House, 8 March 1968, Correa 825 (PMA). El Llano-Carti Road, 18 Apr. 1981, Sytsma 4027 (MO). PERU. Loreto: Maynas, near Iquitos, in 1996, Grandez 7837 (MO).
P. laurifolia
BRAZIL. Bahia: Barra, Spruce 1394 (P). Pará: Santarem, 19 Jan. 1934, Swallen 3309 (US). COLOMBIA. Vaupés: Vicinity of Mitú, Rio Vaupés, 22 Feb. 1945, Allen 3340 (US). GUYANA. Western extremity of Kanuku Mountains, in drainage of Takutu River, 4 March 1938, Smith 3157 (U).
P. phellos
BRAZIL. Amazonas: Uanadona, near mouth of Rio Dimiti, 10 May 1948, Schultes 9900 (K). VENEZUELA. Río Pacimini, Feb. 1854, Spruce 3390 (K).
P. riparia
BOLIVIA. La Paz: Prov. Iturralde, Siete Cielos, Rio Manupare, 4 June 1987, Solomon 16923 (MO). BRAZIL. Acre: Municipality of Plácido de Castro, Rio Abunã, 10 Jan. 1995, Figueiredo 506 (NY). Amapá: National park of Tumucumaque, Rio Jari, 21 Feb. 2013, Hopkins 2284 (INPA). Municipality of Monção, basin of the Rio Turiaçu, Ka’apor Indian Reserve, 12 Feb. 1985, Balée 794 (MO), Balée 810 (MO). Amazonas: Presidente Figueredo, Nazaré locality, Rio Uatumã between Rio Pitinga and Rio Uatumã, 18 March 1986, Ferreira 6808 (NY). Amazonas: Mouth of Rio Madeira, Martius 3228 (M). São Gabriel da Cachoeira near the Rio Negro, Apr. 1852, Spruce 2191 (P). Pará: Ruropolis Presidente Medici, 9 Feb. 1976, Bamps 5341 (K). Municipality of Almeirim, Mte. Dourado, road Mte Dourado-Munguba, 10 Feb. 1986, Pires 784 (INPA), Mt. Dourado, 20 June 1988, Pires 2227 (NY). Banks of Rio São Manoel, 14 Jan. 1952, Pires 3931. Belem, 29 Dec. 1922, Ducke 17338 (US). Rio Xingu, Island of Piracui, 22 Oct. 1986, Souza 449. Goias: ca. 2 km S. of Guará, 19 March 1968, Irwin 21451 (NY). Mato Grosso: Rio Arinos, Dec. 1914, Kuhlmann 1066 (R), Kuhlmann 1064 (R). Novo Mundo, Forest Reserve of Rio Cristalino, 11 Feb. 2008, Zappi 1194, margin of Rio Cristalino, 29 Nov. 1996, Dubs 2335 (K). Alta floresta, private property of environmental preservation, 10 Nov. 2006, Sasaki 1087 (K), 13 Dec. 2006, Sasaki 1199 (INPA), 23 Jan. 2007, Sasaki 1390 (INPA). COLOMBIA. Guainía: confluence of Ríos Guaviare, Atabapo and Inirida, 23 Aug. 1975, García-Barriga 20929 (COL). ECUADOR. Sucumbios: Cuyabena faunistic reserve, Rio Cuyabeno from outlet of Laguna Grande and 5 km upstream, 2 Apr. 1989, Balslev 84715 (QCA). Orellana: National park Yasuní, south of Río Napo, 31 Jan. 1998, Burnham 1628 (QCA), Río Tivacuno, 0.5 km upstream of confluence with Río Tiputini, 24 March 1998, Burnham 1690 (QCNE). National Park Yasuní, 16 Feb. 2002, Pérez 392 (QCA). Zamora-Chinchipe: Road Zamora-Gualaquiza, ca 5 km north of Cumbaraza, 20 Apr. 1974, Harling 13771 (GB). Nangaritza, Río Tzenganga, 6 June 2005, Quizhpe 1201 (MO). Hill about 2 km downstream from Campamento Shaime along Río Nangaritza, 15 Feb. 1994, Werff 13084 (QCNE). FRENCH GUIANA. Road to Montsinery, 7 March 2017, Rome 567 (P). Road between Cayenne and Cacao, 25 Feb. 2017, Rome 559 (P). Road to Régina, 17 May 2008, Rome 118 (LYJB), Rome 119 (LYJB), Rome 120 (LYJB), Rome 121 (LYJB), Rome 122 (LYJB). Road between Régina and St Georges, 10 Apr. 2008, Rome 45 (LYJB), 19 May 2008, Rome 129 (LYJB), Rome 136 (LYJB), Rome 138 (LYJB), Rome 142 (LYJB). Road of Kaw Mountain, 24 Nov. 2009, Rome 201 (LYJB), Rome 202 (LYJB), 29 Jan. 2013, Rome 400 (LYJB). Road to Tonnegrande, 30 Jan. 2013, Rome 405 (LYJB), Rome 406 (LYJB), Rome 407 (LYJB), Rome 408 (LYJB), Rome 409 (LYJB). Kotika mount, 21 Feb. 2005, Granville (de) 16896 (CAY). Municipality of Saint-Georges, Oyapock basin, 15 Aug. 1997, Berton 250 (CAY). Kamuyene Kamuyene, 12 Apr. 2005, Bourdy 3128 (CAY). Road of Kaw mountain, 24 Jan. 1983, Feuillet 573 (CAY), 1 Jan. 1986, Feuillet 2975 (CAY), 25 Aug. 2009, Feuillet 17078 (CAY). Path between Roura and the Gabrielle Creek, 21 Apr. 1979, Prevost 563 (CAY). Road to Régina, near Camp Hervo, 14 March 2009, Vanderplanck 1605 (CAY). PERU. Huánuco: Prov. Pachitea, region of Pucallpa, western part of the “Sira montains” and adjacent lowland, 31 July 1988, Wallnöfer 12-31788 (MO). Along Río Pachitea, 12 July 1967, Schunke 2112 (US). Junín: Chanchamayo prov., El Bocaz, 20 Nov. 1982, Vargas 64 (USM). Loreto: in lower forest at Neshuya, 2 Oct. 1965, Schunke 907 (US). Madre de Dios: National Park Manu, Río Manu, 1 Oct. 1986, Foster 11539 (F), Foster 11558 (F). Tambopata prov., Las Piedras, Cusco Amazónico, 7 Oct. 1991, Timaná 2457 (MO). San Martín: Mariscal Cáceres, mouth of Río Tocache, 6 Nov. 1969, Schunke 3579 (US). San Martín, Boca Toma del Shicayo, N of Tarapoto along Río Shilcayo, 27 May 1986, Alcorn 10 (MO). Juan Jui, Alto Río Huallaga, Oct. 1934, Klug 3897 (MO). Chazuta, Río Huallaga, March 1935, Klug 4037 (K). Mariscal Cáceres, Canyon of Huaquisha, right margin of Río Huallaga, 30 June 1974, Schunke 7083 (MO). Amazonas: between Uchpayaco and Rimachi, banks of Río Pastaza, 30 July 1979, Díaz 1283 (MO). Pasco: Oxapampa, Puerto Bermúdez, 14 July 1929, Killip 26683 (US). Oxapampa, ca. 1 km from division of Villa Rica-Pto. Bermúdez road and Villa Rica-Palcazu road, on Palcazu branch, 15 Aug. 1984, Knapp 6633 (MO). Loreto: Maynas, Iquitos, July 1929, Williams 1440 (US), March 1930, Williams 7996 (US). Yurimaguas, lower Río Huallaga, March 1930, Williams 7876 (US). Maynas, district of Iquitos, Caserío, 25 Feb. 1976, Revilla 241 (MO), Río Nanay near Astoria, 15 March 1973, Rimachi 126 (USM). Tarapoto, Nov. 1902, Ule 6547 (K). Ucayali: Pucapanga, margin of Río Ucayali, 20 Aug. 1965, Sagástegui 5739 (HUT). SURINAME. Sipaliwini, vicinity of airstrip along Ulemari river, 1 May 1998, Evans 2971 (MO).
P. sp. (impossible or doubtful identification)
BRAZIL. Amazonas: Lake of Aleixo, in riparian forest, 3 Apr. 1932, Ducke 24044 (US). Bahia, Barra, March 1851, Spruce 1172 (P). ECUADOR. Morona Santiago: Shuar Pampants center, 10 Sept. 1986, Warush RBAE86 (QCNE). PERU. Amazonas: Río Cenepa, 2 June 1973, Ancuash 506 (US). Junín: Junín, Puerto Yesup, 10 July 1929, Killip 26307 (US). Loreto: Alto Amazonas, Yurimaguas, lower Río Huallaga, 22 Aug. 1929, Killip 28214 (US). Near Iquitos, July 1929, Williams 1392 (US). La Victoria on the Amazon River, Aug. 1929, Williams 3126 (US). Santa Rosa, Lower Río Huallaga below Yurimaguas, 1 sept. 1929, Killip 28940 (US). Wooded banks of lower Río Huallaga, 5 Sept. 1929, Killip 29012 (US). San Martín: Alto Río Huallaga, Dec. 1929, Williams 6300 (US). Tarapoto, Alto Río Huallaga, Dec. 1929, Williams 5848 (F).
P. tolimana
ECUADOR. Napo: 2 km W of Archidonia, 27 June 1968, Holm-Nielsen 1040 (AAU). Morona-Santiago: ca. 32.5 km S. of Gualaquiza on road to Zamora, 4 Feb. 1984, Knapp 6242 (US).
P. venusta
PERU. San Martín: Lamas, Dec. 1929, Williams 6378 (US). Tarapoto, Alto Río Huallaga, Dec. 1929, Williams 5637 (F).
Index to Numbered Collections
Aguilar, R. 2974 (ambigua)
Alcorn, P. 10 (riparia)
Allen, P. H. 3340 (laurifolia)
Ancuash, E. 506 (sp.)
Balée, W. L. 794, 810 (riparia)
Balslev, H. 84715 (riparia)
Bamps, P. 5341 (riparia)
Berton, M. E. 250 (riparia)
Blanco, M. 805 (ambigua)
Bourdy, G. 3128 (riparia)
Brand, J. 947 (ambigua)
Burnham, R. J. 1628, 1690 (riparia)
Calzada, J. I. 230 (ambigua)
Cerón, C. E. 5772 (ambigua)
Cook, O. F. 79 (ambigua)
Correa, M. D. 825 (ambigua)
Devia, W. 1121 (ambigua)
Díaz, C. 1283 (riparia)
Ducke, A. 17338 (P. riparia), 24044 ( sp.), 878 (ambigua)
Dubs, B. 2335 (riparia)
Escobar, L. 435 (ambigua)
Evans, R. 2971 (riparia)
Feuillet, C. 573, 2975, 17078 (riparia)
Ferreira, C. A. C. 6808 (riparia)
Figueiredo, C. 506 (riparia)
Foster, R. B. 11539 (riparia)
Fuchs, H. P. 21744 (ambigua)
García-Barriga, H. 20929 (riparia)
Gentry, A. 6561 (ambigua)
Grandez, C. 7837 (ambigua)
Granville (de), J. J. 16896 (riparia)
Harling, G. 13771 (riparia)
Holm-Nielsen, L. 1040 (tolimana)
Hopkins, M. J. G. 2284 (riparia)
Hoyos, S 132 (ambigua)
Irwin, H. S. 21451 (riparia)
Jativa, C. D. 439 (ambigua)
Killip, E. P. 24044, 26307, 28214, 28940, 29012 ( sp.), 26683 (riparia)
Klug, G. 3897, 4037 (riparia)
Knapp, S. 6633 (P. riparia), 6242 (tolimana)
Kuhlmann, J. G. 1066, 1064 (riparia)
Martius, C. F. P. 3228 (riparia)
Palacios, W. 8811 (ambigua)
Pérez, A. J. 392 (riparia)
Pipoly, J. 18177 (ambigua)
Pires, M. J. P. 784, 2227, 3931 (riparia)
Prevost, M. F. 563 (riparia)
Quizhpe, W. 1201 (riparia)
Revilla, J. 241 (riparia)
Rimachi, M. 126 (riparia)
Rome, M. 567, 559, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 45, 129, 136, 138, 142, 405, 406, 407, 408, 409 (riparia)
Sagástegui, A. 5739 (riparia)
Schunke, J. V. 907, 2112, 3555, 3579, 7083 (riparia)
Sasaki, D. 1087, 1199, 1390 (riparia)
Schipp, W. A. 1302 (ambigua)
Schultes, R. E. 9900 (phellos)
Skutch, A. F. 4037 (ambigua)
Smith, A. C. 3157 (laurifolia)
Solomon, J. C. 16923 (riparia)
Souza (de), S. A. M. 449 (riparia)
Spruce, R. 1172 (sp.), 1394 (laurifolia), 3390 (phellos), 2191 (riparia)
Swallen, J. R. 3309 (laurifolia)
Sytsma, K. J. 4027 (ambigua)
Timaná, M. 2457 (riparia)
Ule, E. 6547 (riparia)
Vanderplanck, R. J. R. 1605 (riparia)
Vargas, M. A. 64 (riparia)
Villegas Herrera, A. 112 (ambigua)
Wallnöfer, B. 12-31788 (riparia)
Warush, A. 86 (sp.)
Werff (van der), H. 13084 (riparia), 22075 (ambigua)
Werling, L. 458 (ambigua)
Williams, L. 1392, 3126, 5848, 6300 (sp.), 5637, 6378 (venusta), 1440, 7876, 7996 (riparia)
Zappi, D. 1194 (riparia)