Research Article
Print
Research Article
Townsendia lemhiensis (Asteraceae, Astereae): A narrowly endemic new species from Idaho, USA
expand article infoChristopher Lee, Curtis R. Björk§, Jeannette Whitton§
‡ Monash University, Clayton, Australia
§ University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada
Open Access

Abstract

Townsendia lemhiensis (Asteraceae) is described from the Lemhi Valley of east-central Idaho. From a genus with weak intrinsic isolating barriers, T. lemhiensis remains distinct apparently due to apomixis and to its isolation and habitat specialization on spatially limited occurrences of ashy white soils in the Lemhi Valley. Despite similarities to T. spathulata, this new species differs in its persistent pappus, fewer series of phyllaries and sericeous rather than long woolly hairs.

Keywords

Apomixis, compositae, Flora of Idaho, Lemhi Valley

Introduction

Townsendia Hook. includes about 29 recognized species distributed predominantly throughout the Rocky Mountain and Great Basin regions of western North America (Larsen 1927; Beaman 1957; Shultz and Holmgren 1980). Species of Townsendia are generally characterized by showy inflorescences nestled in a dense rosette of leaves or on short stems; and by a pappus of short bristles. Many species also have strong edaphic affinities that delimit their distribution (Lowrey and Knight 1994). Six species of Townsendia are known to occur in Idaho (T. condensata Parry, 1874, T. florifera (Hook.) A.Gray, 1880, T. hookeri Beaman, 1957, T. leptotes (A.Gray) Osterh., 1908, T. montana M.E.Jones, 1895, and T. parryi D.C.Eaton, 1874), yet none of these species approach the combination of characteristics present in T. lemhiensis.

Methods

Field methods

Specimens were initially collected during cursory exploration by Curtis Björk on May 20th, 2012. Curtis Björk further sampled the area in 2013, and two additional populations were found. In 2018, Chris Lee and Jeannette Whitton used localities provided by Curtis Björk to collect additional samples. We also used satellite imagery of nearby areas to identify potential habitat for T. lemhiensis, and these areas were targeted for additional surveying. Several voucher specimens were taken during each site visit, and dried between newspaper and cushioned cardboard in a plant press. Characters were measured directly from herbarium specimens. Herbaria acronyms follow Index Herbariorum (Thiers 2016).

Pollen counts

We removed 2–3 florets from individual plants and placed them in a 200 μL microtube. After adding approximately 20 μL of lactophenol blue stain to each tube, we vortexed tubes for 20–30 seconds to release pollen into suspension. Slides were prepared using the resulting suspension, and viewed under a standard light microscope. This procedure was repeated multiple times on various specimens but yielded no pollen grains, thus no pollen counts or measurements could be completed. We later examined disk florets from individuals of all known populations under a dissecting microscope, and found that stamens were abortive and evidently non-functional; no anthers were observed.

Taxonomic treatment

Townsendia lemhiensis C.Lee, Björk & Whitton, sp. nov.

Holotype

Björk 29248 (UBC V252324) 20 May 2012. USA, Idaho, Lemhi County, 18 Mile Wilderness Area, ca. 24 km SSE of Leadore, 44.44806°N, 113.17222°W, on dry ashy white soil on slope (7368 ft) in sagebrush steppe (Fig. 1A). Paratypes: Björk 30627 (UBC V252325) 14 May 2013. USA, Idaho, Lemhi County, 18 Mile Wilderness Area, on a ridge crest near the middle road, 44.46707°N, 113.22570°W, on ashy white slope, sparsely vegetated, soil derived from tuff conglomerates, in upper elevation (6968 ft) sagebrush steppe in intermontane valley; Björk 30772 (UBC V252326) 21 May 2013. USA, Idaho, Lemhi County, 18 Mile Wilderness Area, south of McFarland Road, 44.48000°N, 113.20333°W, on ashy white flats and slopes, sparsely vegetated, in upper elevation (6857 ft) sagebrush steppe in intermontane valley; Whitton 252 (UBC V252322) 13 May 2018. USA, Idaho, Lemhi County, 18 Mile Wilderness Area, 44.47293°N, 113.20670°W, on open hillside (7355 ft) with sparse sagebrush and antelope brush on grey-brown rocky substrate; Whitton 256 (UBC V252323) 14 May 2018. USA, Idaho, Lemhi County, 18 Mile Wilderness Area, 44.44530°N, 113.17541°W, on exposed rocky slope (7371 ft), in areas of grey-white substrate, with bunchgrass, and antelope brush.

Figure 1. 

A habitat of the type locality of Townsendia lemhiensis B habit of Townsendia lemhiensis at the type locality C close-up of Townsendia lemhiensis capitulum D close-up of Townsendia lemhiensis phyllaries. Photos A-B by Björk; Photos C-D by Whitton.

Ab Townsendia spathulata pappi ad maturitatem persistens, series phyllariorum pauciores, pilis caulibus sericeus non villosus, folia non carnosa differt.

Description

Plants perennial, 25–30 mm tall, rosette forming, rosettes 8–17 mm wide, solitary or (more often) arising from a few-branched caudex; stems essentially absent, or when visible, then villosulous; leaves 4–14 × 2 mm, narrowly oblanceolate to narrowly elliptic-oblanceolate, silvery, moderately sericeous but not villous, apex acute; capitula one per fertile rosette, sessile or nearly so; involucre campanulate, 9–10 mm wide, phyllaries appressed, narrowly elliptic-lanceolate, 6–7 × 1 mm, graduated, in 2–3 series, reddish brown, sericeous, apex acute to acuminate; ray florets 15–24, pistillate; ray corollas true ray, 7–8 mm long, surpassing pappus bristles, light brownish pink or whitish and tipped in pink, slightly darker abaxially, aglandular; disc florets 24–30, functionally pistillate; disc corollas tubular, 4 mm long, shortly surpassed by the pappus bristles, yellow, aglandular; stamens reduced to strap-like staminodes, anthers and pollen absent; cypselae 3 × 1 mm, oblanceolate and compressed, with glochidiate hairs; pappus bristles 23–26 in disc florets, 14–20 in ray florets, 6–7 mm long, white, barbellate, persistent. (Figs 1B–D, 2A–F).

Figure 2. 

A capitulum B outer involucral bract C inner involucral bract D ray floret E disc floret F mature disc cypsela. Photos by Spencer Goyette (UBC Herbarium).

Etymology

Townsendia lemhiensis is named after the Lemhi Valley, Idaho, where individuals of this species were first noticed by Curtis Björk.

Distribution and habitat

Townsendia lemhiensis is known only from the Lemhi Valley in east-central Idaho, which is situated within a region known for its numerous geographically endemic plants (Moseley and Conley 1989; Moseley et al. 1990; Ertter and Moseley 1992). The species has been found in three populations, within an area of 4.9 km2.

Townsendia lemhiensis grows on ashy white slopes of eroded rhyolite tuff. These slopes of powdery soils and friable rock are sparsely vegetated, forming edaphic islands of open ground within a more densely vegetated surrounding matrix of sagebrush steppe. Numerous other plants having narrow geographical ranges occupy similar ashy slopes elsewhere in dry interior regions of western North America (Grimes 1984; Reveal and Björk 2004; Brown and Mansfield 2017). The Lemhi Valley is lined on the east and west by alpine ridges, and the valley floor sits at a high elevation, making it cooler than the sagebrush steppes both further south on the adjacent Snake River Plains and further north in the Salmon-Challis Valleys region.

Associated species growing with Townsendia lemhiensis on the ashy slopes include: Artemisia frigida Willd., 1838, Artemisia tridentata subsp. wyomingensis Beetle & A.L.Young, 1965, Chaenactis douglasii Hook. & Arn., 1839, Comandra pallida A.DC., 1857, Cymopterus bipinnatus S.Wats., 1885, Elymus lanceolatus (Scribn. and J.G.Sm.) Gould, 1949, Eriogonum mancum Rydb., 1917, Eriogonum soliceps Reveal & Björk, 2004, Ipomopsis spicata subsp. orchidacea (Brand) D.Wilken & R.L.Hartm., 1991, Linum lewisii var. alpicola Jeps., 1936, Oreocarya humilis Greene, 1896, Packera cana (Hook.) W.A.Weber & Á.Löve, 1981, Penstemon humilis Nutt. ex A.Gray, 1862, Phlox muscoides Nutt., 1831, Stenotus acaulis (Nutt.) Nutt., 1840, Townsendia hookeri Beaman, 1957, T. leptotes (A.Gray) Osterh., 1908, and T. parryi D.C.Eaton, 1874.

Phenology

We observed T. lemhiensis in flower in mid-May over three years (2012, 2013, 2018). At this time, some individuals had some capitula in bud, and others had mature seeds or open flowers. On this basis, we describe flowering as likely occurring throughout May, and seedset through late May or possibly into June. Further studies are needed to document the timing of bud formation, and potential variation in flowering and fruiting phenology. Another early-flowering species, Townsendia hookeri, co-occurs with T. lemhiensis, and has been observed to set buds in fall that open soon after snow melt (Lee and Whitton, personal observation). Given the early flowering of T. lemhiensis and the presence of snow patches persisting in surrounding areas, we suspect fall bud set may also occur in this species. Co-occurring species of Townsendia were found on site in bud (T. parryi) and late-bud (T. leptotes and T. hookeri).

Discussion

Townsendia lemhiensis is most similar in morphology to T. spathulata Nutt., which shares a generally hairy appearance. However, T. lemhiensis is morphologically distinct because its leaves are narrowly oblanceolate with short dense pubescence, instead of the fleshy, spathulate leaves covered in long, tangled hairs in T. spathulata. Also, the cypselae of T. lemhiensis have persistent pappi rather than the rare characteristic (in Townsendia) of deciduous pappi found only in T. spathulata, T. microcephala and T. condensata (Beaman 1957; Dorn 1992). Its capitulum is protected by fewer phyllary series (2–3), rather than 3–4 phyllary series found in T. spathulata.

Townsendia lemhiensis is morphologically distinct from the seven other species of Townsendia known from this region. We include T. spathulata here, because of its similarity to T. lemhiensis, and because it has been documented in the Beaverhead range overlooking the Lemhi Valley, Idaho (>9000 ft) at the border with Montana (Fig. 3). The seven species of Townsendia in Idaho and adjacent Montana can be distinguished using the taxonomic key below. Four of these species tend to occur at higher elevations (T. condensata, T. leptotes, T. spathulata and T. montana), while T. florifera is often at lower elevations than T. lemhiensis, and is associated with basalt. We found T. parryi, T. leptotes and T. hookeri co-occurring with T. lemhiensis, but these species were in bud, while Townsendia lemhiensis was in full flower. The nearby locality of T. spathulata is somewhat unusual; more typically, T. spathulata inhabits the semi-arid plains of Wyoming and Montana along the eastern side of the Great Divide.

Figure 3. 

Occurrence records of Townsendia lemhiensis and other nearby Townsendia spp. (ArcMap v.10.3.1) (Consortium of Pacific Northwest Herbaria 2022)

Although many Townsendia species occupy distinct geographical ranges and possess a multitude of unique character traits, Beaman (1957) describes them as lacking strong (intrinsic) genetic isolating barriers, based on crossing studies in the greenhouse, and on observed patterns of morphological intergradation in nature (Beaman 1954). While interbreeding is sometimes possible in cultivation, and likely occurs in nature, geographic isolation, phenological differences, and habitat differentiation, especially edaphic specialization, contribute to maintaining species boundaries in this genus. The species recognized by Beaman all include sexually reproducing populations, but apomictic populations also occur in a number of Townsendia species (Beaman 1954, 1957). Sexual populations are diploid and outcrossing, while known apomicts are triploid or tetraploid (Beaman 1954). Sexual and apomictic forms typically have distinct (sometimes overlapping) distributions, and provide classic examples of geographical parthenogenesis (Bierzychudek 1985). Apomixis also contributes to maintaining species boundaries, because hybridization involving apomicts is not likely. As a result, hybrids will not necessarily be produced, even where multiple Townsendia species co-occur.

Although direct genetic or experimental evidence of apomixis is not available for T. lemhiensis, no pollen was detected on florets sampled from our collections, which strongly suggests that these populations are apomictic. As a result, despite the physical proximity of T. lemhiensis to T. hookeri, T. leptotes, and T. parryi, hybridization is unlikely given that in this region, all four species are likely apomicts (Beaman 1957; Thompson and Whitton 2006). We note that while it is uncommon for species in Townsendia to be recognized based solely on apomictic populations, to date, apomicts have generally fit within the boundaries of morphological descriptions of known sexual populations. In this case, T. lemhiensis has no known sexual populations; whether these are undiscovered or extinct, or whether T. lemhiensis is of hybrid origin is not known.

The first author examined the majority of Townsendia specimens from UBC, UAC, SASK, RM, CS, and UNLV from 2008–2014, and the second author examined all Asteraceae at ID in 2002, and did not find any specimens of Townsendia lemhiensis. Additionally, from 2008–2014, the first author undertook targeted searches for all species of Townsendia throughout their range in WA, ID, MT, WY, CO, NV, NM and CA, and no similar populations were encountered.

Despite the second author’s searches in apparently suitable habitats throughout the Lemhi Valley and adjacent valleys in Idaho and Montana in the years 1999–2013, only the three reported populations have been located. Thus it appears that T. lemhiensis is a high priority for conservation. All known occurrences of T. lemhiensis are situated on public land administered by the Bureau of Land Management. Hence, the landscape surrounding this species is somewhat protected from threats, but such a small, rare species may still undergo population reduction from factors such as trampling by cattle or recreationists, invasive exotic plant species, or from climate change that could cause higher frequency and severity of drought and excessive heat events.

Key to Townsendia of Idaho and adjacent Montana

1a Lax-growing plants with elongated stems, many internodes > 2 mm long, plants often lacking sterile rosettes when flowering 2
2a Stems erect or sub-erect; longest phyllaries > 9 mm long 3
3a Rays purplish; longest phyllaries mostly > 10 mm long; stems erect, unbranched T. parryi
3b Rays white or pink; longest phyllaries mostly < 10 mm long; stems sub-erect, often branched T. florifera
2b Stems decumbent; longest phyllaries up to 9 mm long 4
4a Stems gray-white, obscured by dense hairs T. incana
4b Stems lightly to moderately strigose T. strigosa
1b Compact plants, stems scarcely elongated, internodes < 2 mm long; sterile rosettes commonly present 5
5a Plants with abundant spreading hairs 6
6a Pappus persistent; leaf hairs sericeous T. lemhiensis
6b Pappus easily breaking away from the cypselae at maturity; leaf hairs villous 7
7a Phyllaries > 40, the longest ones > 9 mm long, involucres > 12 mm long T. condensata
7b Phyllaries < 40, the longest ones < 9 mm long, involucres < 12 mm long T. spathulata
5b Plants with appressed hairs only, or spreading hairs few and inconspicuous 8
8a Phyllaries 2–5 × long as wide; rays purplish, often glandular abaxially 9
9a Phyllaries acute to acuminate; ray laminae 5–8 mm long T. leptotes
9b Phyllaries blunt; ray laminae 7–16 mm long T. montana
8b Phyllaries at least 6 × long as wide; rays white to pink, glabrous 10
10a Longest phyllaries > 12 mm long and > 1.5 mm wide; disc pappi 6.5–11+ mm long; leaf midvein apparent T. exscapa
10b Longest phyllaries < 12 mm long and ca. 1 mm wide; disc pappi 4–6(-7.5) mm long; leaf midvein obscure T. hookeri

Acknowledgements

We are grateful to Ryan Batten for his assistance in the field. The curatorial staff of UBC, CS, ID, RM, SASK, UAC, and UNLV are thanked for their kind and generous help facilitating specimen research. In particular, we appreciate the rapid assistance from Linda Jennings and Spencer Goyette at UBC in processing accession numbers, and mounting, photographing and scanning specimens for this study.

References

  • Consortium of Pacific Northwest Herbaria (2022) Occurrence Download (www.pnwherbaria.org). [accessed: 13.02 2022]
  • Lowrey TK, Knight PJ (1994) Townsendia gypsophila (Compositae: Astereae): a new species from northern New Mexico. Brittonia 46(3): 194–199. https://doi.org/10.2307/2807232
  • Shultz LM, Holmgren AH (1980) A new species of Townsendia (Asteraceae) from Northern Arizona. Brittonia 32(2): 144–147. https://doi.org/10.2307/2806780

Supplementary material

Supplementary material 1 

Townsendia lemhiensis occurence records

Christopher Lee, Curtis R. Björk, Jeannette Whitton

Data type: Occurence.

Explanation note: Type and paratype specimens collected of Townsendia lemhiensis.

This dataset is made available under the Open Database License (http://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/1.0/). The Open Database License (ODbL) is a license agreement intended to allow users to freely share, modify, and use this Dataset while maintaining this same freedom for others, provided that the original source and author(s) are credited.
Download file (5.10 kb)