Research Article |
Corresponding author: Quan-Ru Liu ( liuquanru@bnu.edu.cn ) Academic editor: James Cohen
© 2021 Dan-Hui Liu, Xue-Min Xu, Yi He, Quan-Ru Liu.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Liu D-H, Xu X-M, He Y, Liu Q-R (2021) A new combination in Pseudolappula (Boraginaceae, Rochelieae) based on morphological, molecular and palynological evidence. PhytoKeys 187: 77-92. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.187.75346
|
Lappula sinaica was recently transferred to the monotypic genus Pseudolappula based on phylogenetic studies, while the related species, L. occultata, has remained in the genus Lappula. In this study, morphological, molecular, and palynological evidence supports that L. occultata should be transferred to the genus Pseudolappula. Both L. occultata and P. sinaica share a combination of nutlets features that distinguish them from Lappula: a longer adaxial keel and a linear attachment scar. Phylogenetic analysis based on ITS and trnL-F strongly supports L. occultata as the sister taxon of P. sinaica. In addition, pollen grains of these two species are 3-syncolporate with 3 alternating pseudocolpi, which is significantly different from the grains of Lappula taxa. Based on the above evidence, the new combination Pseudolappula occultata is proposed.
Boraginaceae, Lappula occultata, new combination, Pseudolappula
Recent phylogenetic studies on the Rochelieae (Boraginaceae) have greatly advanced our understanding of this plant group, and the circumscription of some genera has been changed (
Echinospermum sinaicum A.DC. was described by
The related species, Lappula occultata
Historical classifications of L. sinaica with L. occultata and its congeneric relatives.
|
|
|
|
|
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Genus | Lappula | Lappula | Lappula | Lappula | Pseudolappula |
Section | Eulappula | Lappula | Lappula | Sinaicae | – |
Series/Subsection | Sinaicae | Sinaicae | Sinaicae | – | – |
Species | L. sinaica | L. sinaica | L. sinaica | L. sinaica | P. sinaica |
– | L. occultata | L. sessiliflora | L. occultata | L. occultata | – |
– | L. lipschitzii | – | – | L. mogoltavica | – |
Although L. sinaica has now been formally placed in the new genus Pseudolappula by
The specimens used in the previous phylogenetic analyses (
Therefore, it was necessary to revise the circumscription of L. occultata based on a more appropriate understanding and identification of that species. In this study, morphological, molecular, and palynological analyses are conducted to clarify the systematic position of L. occultata.
Specimens at PE, XJU, XJA, XJBI, MW, NSK, and TASH were examined critically, including type specimens. Field observations were carried out in Xinjiang province, China. Morphological studies were made of living plants in the field and of pressed specimens, with particular attention to the mature nutlets which were photographed by a ZEISS V8 stereoscopic microscope.
In order to verify the evolutionary relationships between Pseudolappula and L. occultata, 46 taxa within the tribe Rochelieae were sampled, including 5 genera of subtribe Eritrichiinae (Hackelia, Pseudolappula, Eritrichium, Rochelia, and Lappula), which covered all main clades of this lineage. Pseudoheterocaryum subsessile (Vatke) Kaz.Osaloo & Saadati was selected as an outgroup according to the previous studies (
Genomic DNA was extracted from silica-gel dried leaves using the Plant Genomic DNA Kit (Tiangen, Beijing, China), following the manufacturer’s instructions. The ITS (
Sequences of ITS and trnL-F were aligned with MAFFT online version 7 and manually adjusted (
Samples of taxa were obtained from field surveys during 2019–2021 and from voucher specimens were preserved in the BNU herbarium (Appendix
The results of morphological comparisons indicated that Pseudolappula sinaica (A.DC.) Khoshsokhan, Sherafati & Kaz.Osaloo and L. occultata are quite similar and likely closely related. The two taxa exhibited a special combination of characters in both the nutlet attachment scar and adaxial keel (Fig.
Characters | Pseudolappula | L. occultata | Lappula | |
Life form | annual | annual | annual, biennial, perennial | |
Leaves | basal leaves | petiolate | petiolate | sessile |
Bracts | lower shape | lanceolata | narrowly ovate | leaflike or linear |
Calyx | shape | oblong-linear | linear | linear, oblong |
Corolla | color | blue | blue | blue, white |
size (mm) | 2–3 × 1–2 (3) | 2–2.5 × 1–1.5 | 2.5–4 × 1.5–12 | |
limb/tube (ratio) | ca. 1 | ca. 1 | ca. 1–3 | |
Stamens | pollen aperture type | 3-syncolporate 3 pseudocolpi | 3-syncolporate 3 pseudocolpi | 3-colporate 3 pseudocolpi |
polar axis | 12.3–15 μm | 13.6–15.5 μm | 8.9–19.4 μm | |
equatorial axis | 4.3–5.6 μm | 4.7–7.1 μm | 2.2–9.1 μm | |
Style | – | exceeding the nutlets | exceeding the nutlets | exceeding or not the nutlets |
Nutlets | disk shape | narrowly oblong | oblong | lanceolata to ovate |
attachment scar (cicatrix) | not obvious, linear | not obvious, linear | obvious, narrow lanceolata to ovate | |
adaxial keel | as long as the nutlets | as long as the nutlets | shorter than the nutlets |
Nutlet morphology of Pseudolappula and Lappula A–D Pseudolappula sinaica A fruit lateral view B fruit polar view (growth direction of nutlets indicated by arrows) C nutlet abaxial view D nutlet adaxial view E–H Lappula occultata E fruit lateral view F fruit polar view (arrangement of nutlets indicated by cross lines) G nutlet abaxial view H nutlet adaxial view I–L Lappula patula I fruit lateral view J fruit polar view (arrangement of nutlets indicated by cross lines) K nutlet abaxial view L nutlet adaxial view M adaxial keel of P. sinaica (adaxial view) N adaxial keel of L. occultata (lateral view) O attachment scar of Lappula balchaschensis P attachment scar of Lappula brachycentra. Scale bars: 1 mm.
The phylogeny was rooted with Pseudoheterocaryum subsessile from the tribe Rochelieae, and the tree showed subtribe Eritrichiinae as monophyletic. Eritrichiinae comprised 5 major clades (Fig.
Maximum Likelihood tree of subtribe Eritrichiinae inferred from ITS + trnL-F. The tree topology was constructed using RAxML. Bootstrap values and Bayesian posterior probabilities are indicated above branches. Note that the Lappula occultata (
The palynological data also supported that P. sinaica and L. occultata are closely related to each other. We examined the pollen morphology of Pseudoheterocaryum, Pseudolappula, Lappula, and Rochelia taxa. Pollen grains were isopolar, dumbbell-shaped or oblong in equatorial view and sub-circular in polar view (Fig.
The pollen apertures of the studied taxa were of three types: 3-colporate alternating with 3 pseudocolpi (Figs
Nutlets are always important for identification and classification of Boraginaceae, especially for Lappula (
Lappula sinaica and L. occultata were placed in the section Eulappula, series Sinaicae by
To better resolve relationships of P. sinaica with L. occultata and the Lappula species within subtribe Eritrichiinae, we newly sequenced the ITS and trnL-F regions from a ‘real’ specimen of L. occultata, which was determined to match the initial species description after careful specimen examination. As a result, the phylogenetic framework within tribe Rochelieae is highly congruent with previous work (
Boraginaceae are a palynologically heterogeneous family (
Although Lappula species have been studied in terms of nutlet morphology (
Lappula occultata
Tajikistan: Sary-tau mountains. 25 June 1920, Popov 697 (TASH003719!).
Annual herbs. Stems erect, 15–40 cm tall, frequently branched from base or above middle, with appressed or semi-appressed white hairs. Basal leaves oblong with obvious petiole, 2–3 cm long, 5–8 mm wide; cauline leaves sessile, oblong to lanceolate, 2–4 cm long, 4–9 mm wide, with spreading hairs, hairs discoid at base. Inflorescences to 10–15 cm in fruit; bracts small, narrowly ovate to linear. Pedicels erect, the lower 5–6 mm long. Calyx lobes linear, erect, 2 mm long, to 4–5 mm in fruit, enclosing the nutlets. Corolla blue, 2–3 mm long, the tube shorter than calyx; throat appendages yellow, trapeziform, ca. 0.3 mm; limb 1–1.5 mm wide, lobes ovata-rounded. Stamen 5, filaments short, pollen grains isopolar, dumbbell-shaped in equatorial view and subcircular in polar view, 3-syncolporate apertures alternating with 3 pseudocolpi, with 6 orae. Coenobium 2–3 mm in diameter, homomorphic nutlets. Style surpassing the nutlets by ca. 0.5 mm. Nutlets ovoid, shiny, ca. 2 mm long, not easily separated from gynobase; disk ovate, weakly keeled, densely with rounded granulose, margin prominent and forming a narrow smooth rim. Cicatrix linear, not obvious, adaxial keel ca. 2 mm long.
Flowering and fruiting from May to July.
China, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Afghan, Mongolia (
The section Sinaicae (Riedl) Ovczinnikova was proposed by
China. Xinjiang: Yining county, 29 April 1977, suzenan 613 (XJU!); Gongliu county to Tekes county, 9 August 1996, wangqi 96–047 (XJA00057876!); Nilak county, 43°41'18.28"N, 82°20'4.70"E, alt. 1287 m, 17 May 2020, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2020XJ088 (BNU!); Huocheng county, 44°18'35.61"N, 81°6'6.07"E, 21 May 2021, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2021XJ095 (BNU!). Kazakhstan. Alma-Ata region, Enbekshikazakh district, 43°39'N, 78°56'E, 17 May 2003, A.Yu.Korolyuk, I.A.Khrustaleva s.n. (NSK0005820!); East Kazakhstan region, Urdzhar district, alt. 660 m, 30 May 2003, A.Yu.Korolyuk 45 (NSK0005868!); Karaganda region, 47°42994'N, 74°81770'E, 13 May 2014, A.L.Ebel s.n. (NSK0008730!); Baidibek district, 25 April 2015, N.N.Lashchinsky s.n. (NSK0008234!). Uzbekistan. Viloyat Surxondaryo, 15 km W from city Boysun, 38°14'12"N, 67°1'54"E, alt. 1140 m, 7 May 2013, D.Lyskov s.n. (MW0895220!). Afghan. Kabul, 20 km SE, alt. 2000–2400 m, 21 May 1968, Freitag 2641 (KUFS!); Kapisa, Unteres Panjsher Tal gegenueber Korawa, alt. 1700 m, 24 May 1973, O. Anders 9764 (KUFS!); Takhar, Gebirgshange 12 km SE Eshkamesh, alt. 1300–2100 m, 24 May 1970, O. Anders 6751 (KUFS!); Upper Maidan-valley near Takona, alt. 2700 m, 11 June 1968, Freitag 2970 (KUFS!); Loghar, Dobandaytal, alt. 2800 m, 4 May 1970, O. Anders 3356 (KUFS!); Paktya, Saydkhelo Lgad, alt. 1620 m, 12 May 1972, O. Anders 8877 (KUFS!); Nangahar, N Haenge des Safeed Koh bei Baghdara, alt. 1200–1400 m, 23 March 1973, O. Anders 9511 (KUFS!).
We would like to express gratitude to the curators of the herbaria MW, NSK, PE, TASH, XJU, and XJBI. We are grateful to Professor Simpson for helpful comments and corrections, to Chen Chen and Chu-Ze Shen for the modification of English. This research was financed by the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (No. 310421121) and China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (No. 2020M680434).
Taxa used for molecular analyses (Taxon, GenBank accession no. (ITS, trnL-F), source and collector/collection number).
Outgroup Taxa: Pseudoheterocaryum subsessile Vatke, AB758297, AB758326, Iran, Faghihna & Zangooei 28193 (TMUH). Ingroup Taxa: Eritrichium aretioides DC. KU927709, KC542591, U.S.A., Weigend 9126 (BSB); Eritrichium canum (Benth.) Kitam. AB758294, AB758323, Germany, cultivated in Munich Botanical Garden; Eritrichium nanum Schrad. Ex Gaudin, KU927711, KC542483, Switzerland, Zippel & al. s.n. (B); Eritrichium pamiricum B.Fedtsch. KU927712, KC542564, Afghanistan, Anders 8098 (M); Eritrichium sericeum DC. JQ388500, Russia, West Chukotka, Petrovsky & Plieva s.n. (O); Eritrichium splendens Kearney, JQ388501, Alaska, Noatak Quad, Solstad & Elven 03/1216 (O); Eritrichium thymifolium (DC.) Y.S.Lian & J.Q.Wang, JX976807, JX976913, China, Xinjiang, B. C. Han et J. F. Huang 201007004 (PE); Hackelia bella I.M.Johnst., KU927715, KC542497, U.S.A., Merello & al. 702 (MO); Hackelia floribunda I.M.Johnst., JQ513445, Reveal 2390 (SD 103849) KC542513, USA Miller et al. 6966 (MO) ; Hackelia micrantha (Eastw.) J.L.Gentry, JQ388504, JQ388584, U.S.A, Oregon, Grant Co., Hinchliff 869 (WS); Hackelia revoluta I.M.Johnst., KF849119, KF849224, Argentina, C. Aedo 15407 (MA); Hackelia sharsmithii I.M.Johnst., KU927717, KC542498, U.S.A., Hilger U.S.A. 94/18 (BSB); Hackelia velutina I.M.Johnst., KU927719, KC542530, U.S.A., Hilger 411/1997 (BSB); Hackelia deflexa (Wahlenb.) Opiz, JX976808, JX976914, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang 20090109 (XJBI); Lappula albiflora (Riedl) Khoshsokhan & Kaz.Osaloo, KF287982, KF288065, Rechinger 31424 (TARI); Lappula anocarpa Ching J.Wang, JQ388505, JQ388585, China, Xinjiang, Juan Qiu 08-0007 (XJA); Lappula balchaschensis M.Popov ex Golosk., JX976776, JX976890, China, Xinjiang, J. F Huang et B. C. Han 201008016 (XJBI); Lappula brachycentra (Ledeb.) Gürke, JX976777, JX976891, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang et B. C. Han 201008042 (XJBI); Lappula consanguinea (Fischer et C.A. Mey.) Gürke, JX976779, JX976893, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang 20090213 (XJBI); Lappula consanguinea var. cupuliformis Ching J.Wang, JX976780, JX976894, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang et B. C. Han 201009011-2 (XJBI); Lappula duplicicarpa Pavlov, JX976781, JX976895, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang 20090181 (XJBI); Lappula lipschitzii Popov, JX976787, JX976899, China, Xinjiang, W. Zhai 087 (SHI); Lappula microcarpa (Ledeb.) Gürke, JX976788, JX976900, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang et B. C. Han 201009003 (XJBI); Lappula myosotis Moench, JX976789, JX976901, China, Shanxi, J. F. Huang 2010050 (XJBI); Lappula occultata Popov, JX976791, JX976902, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang et B. C. Han 201008043 (XJBI); OK135686, OL364176, China, Xinjiang, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2020XJ088 (BNU); Lappula patula (Lehm.) Menuharth, JX976792, JX976903, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang 20090056-A (XJBI); Lappula persica (Boiss.) Khoshsokhan & Kaz. Osaloo, AB758312, AB758339, Iran, Assadi and Maassumi 51278 (TARI); Lappula redowskii (Hornem.) Greene, KP027121; KF288063, U.S.A., Cohen 161; Lappula semiglabra (Ledeb.) Gürke, JX976793, JX976904, China, Gansu, J. F. Huang et B. C. Han 2010055 (XJBI); Lappula semiglabra var. heterocaryoides Popov ex Ching J.Wang, JX976784, JX976896, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang et B. C. Han 201008054 (XJBI); Lappula shanhsiensis Kitag., KU927725, KU927725, China, Kürschner & al. 634 (BSB); Lappula spinocarpos (Forssk.) Asch. ex Kuntze, JX976795, JX976906, China, Xinjiang, W. Zhai 120 (SHI); Lappula stricta (Ledeb.) Gürke, JX976798, JX976907, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang et B. C. Han 201008052 (XJBI); Lappula tadshikorum Popov, JX976799, JX976908, China, Xinjiang, W. Zhai 12 (SHI); Lappula tenuis (Ledeb.) Gürke, JX976800, JX976909, China, Xinjiang, J. F. Huang et B. C. Han 201008049 (XJBI); Lappula wendelboi (Riedl) Khoshsokhan & Kaz.Osaloo, AB758314, AB758340, Iran, Kazempour Osaloo 2008-7 (TMUH); Rochelia bungei Trautv., AB564695, AB564705, Iran, Assadi & Massoumi 55785 (TARI); Rochelia cancellata Boiss. & Balansa, AB564702, AB564712, Turkey, Bani 4971 (TMUH); Rochelia cardiosepala Bunge, AB564701, AB564711, Iran, Kazempour Osaloo 2006-1 (TMUH); Rochelia disperma (L.) Wettst., AB564698, AB564708, Iran, Kazempour Osaloo 2007-2 (TMUH); Rochelia mirheydari Riedl & Esfand., AB564696, AB564706, Iran, Faghihnia & Zangooei 23477 (TMUH); Rochelia peduncularis Boiss., AB564699, AB564709, Iran, Abdolzadeh 20447 (FUMH); Rochelia persica Bunge ex Boiss., AB564697, AB564707, Iran, Kazempour Osaloo 2007-1 (TMUH); Pseudolappula sinaica (A.DC.) Khoshsokhan, Sherafati & Kaz.Osaloo, AB758308, AB758336, Iran, Kazempour Osaloo 2007-7 (TMUH);
Species | Voucher |
Pseudoheterocaryum rigidum (A.DC.) Kaz.Osaloo & Saadati | China. Xnjiang, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2020XJ079 (BNU) |
Lappula macrantha (Ledeb.) Gürke | China. Xnjiang, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2020XJ147 (BNU) |
L. occultata Popov | China. Xnjiang, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2020XJ088 (BNU) |
L. redowskii (Hornem.) Greene | China. Gansu, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2020GS038 (BNU) |
L. shanhsiensis Kitag. | China. Shanxi, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2020GS117 (BNU) |
L. tianschanica Popov & Zakirov | China. Xinjiang, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2019XJ346 (BNU) |
Rochelia bungei Trautv. | China. Xinjiang, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2021XJ076 (BNU) |
Pseudolappula sinaica (A.DC.) Khoshsokhan, Sherafati & Kaz.Osaloo | China. Xinjiang, Dan-Hui Liu BNU2021XJ095 (BNU) |