Research Article |
Corresponding author: Andrey S. Erst ( erst_andrew@yahoo.com ) Academic editor: Marco Pellegrini
© 2020 Andrey S. Erst, Alexander P. Sukhorukov, Elizaveta Yu. Mitrenina, Mikhail V. Skaptsov, Vera A. Kostikova, Olga A. Chernisheva, Victoria Troshkina, Maria Kushunina, Denis A. Krivenko, Hiroshi Ikeda, Kunli Xiang, Wei Wang.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Erst AS, Sukhorukov AP, Mitrenina EYu, Skaptsov MV, Kostikova VA, Chernisheva OA, Troshkina V, Kushunina M, Krivenko DA, Ikeda H, Xiang K, Wang W (2020) An integrative taxonomic approach reveals a new species of Eranthis (Ranunculaceae) in North Asia. PhytoKeys 140: 75-100. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.140.49048
|
A new endemic species, Eranthis tanhoensis sp. nov., is described from the Republic of Buryatia and Irkutsk Province, Russia. It belongs to Eranthis section Shibateranthis and is morphologically similar to E. sibirica and E. stellata. An integrative taxonomic approach, based on cytogenetical, molecular and biochemical analyses, along with morphological data, was used to delimit this new species.
Biochemistry, cytology, integrative taxonomic approach, morphology, phylogeny, Ranunculales, Russia
The genus Eranthis L. (Ranunculaceae) consists of eight to ten species distributed in southern Europe and temperate Asia (
On the basis of morphology, the genus has been divided into two sections: E. sect. Eranthis and E. sect. Shibateranthis (Nakai) Tamura (
Recent studies have revealed the genetic diversity, phylogeny and presumed origin of some narrowly distributed Korean and Japanese species with further conclusions about their taxonomic status (
The aim of the present study was to investigate the morphological, molecular, biochemical and cytogenetic heterogeneity of the Baikal populations to determine whether any undescribed species were present there. The relationship between E. sibirica, E. stellata and a new species, described and named below as Eranthis tanhoensis Erst, sp. nov. is explored here.
More than 300 herbarium specimens were collected during field investigations in the Republics of Khakassia and Buryatia and the Irkutsk Province during 2018 and 2019. Fieldwork was conducted during different seasons to observe the species in both their flowering and fruiting stages. The specimens were deposited in the E and NS herbaria (herbarium abbreviations according to
We sampled 15 individuals of E. tanhoensis and six of E. sibirica. Two individuals of E. stellata and one each of E. pinnatifida and E. longistipitata were also included. The details of the samples are presented in Suppl. material
The morphology of vegetative and reproductive structures was examined on well-developed specimens. For numerical analysis, 25 specimens at flowering and 25 specimens at fruiting stages were examined for each species (more than 150 specimens altogether). For each species, we studied different populations from across the range, including populations from the type localities of E. stellata and E. sibirica. As E. stellata often does not produce basal leaves at flowering, we studied this character in a limited number of samples. The morphological characters were measured using AxioVision 4.8 software (Carl Zeiss, Munich, Germany).
The missing values in the original data table were restored using multidimensional linear regression, in accordance with recommendations of
Somatic chromosomes were studied in root tip cells. Tubers were germinated in wet moss at ~15 °C for 2–4 weeks. Newly formed 1–2 cm long roots were excised and pretreated in a 0.5% colchicine solution for 2–3 h at 15 °C. Roots were fixed in a mixture of 96% ethanol and glacial acetic acid (3:1). Root tips were stained with 1% aceto-haematoxylin and the squash method was employed for investigation of the karyotype (
Chromosomes were counted in 50–100 mitotic cells for each population. Mitotic metaphase chromosome plates were observed using an Axio Star microscope (Carl Zeiss, Munich, Germany) and photographed using an Axio Imager A.1 microscope (Carl Zeiss, Germany) with AxioVision 4.7 software (Carl Zeiss, Germany) and AxioCam MRc5 CCD–camera (Carl Zeiss, Germany) at 1000× magnification in the Laboratory for Ecology, Genetics and Environmental Protection (Ecogene) of the National Research Tomsk State University. KaryoType software (
Flow cytometry with propidium iodide (PI) staining was used to determine the absolute DNA content. The relative DNA content in the nucleus (C-value) in representatives of three Eranthis species – E. stellata, E. sibirica and E. tanhoensis from different populations, was determined in this study. In total, more than 70 samples from 15 populations were studied (see Suppl. material
The 1Cx-value (monoploid DNA content sensu
In order to determine the composition of phenolic compounds, air-dried plant material was mechanically ground to obtain a homogenous powder and then samples of ~0.2 g were extracted three times using 70% aqueous ethanol solution for 30 min in a water bath at 72 °C. Next, the combined extract was concentrated in porcelain dishes to 5 ml. The solutions were filtered and stored at 4 °C until analysis. Analysis of phenolic components was performed using an Agilent 1200 HPLC system equipped with a diode array detector and a ChemStation system for the collection and processing of chromatographic data (Agilent Technology, Palo Alto, CA, USA). The separation was performed on a Zorbax SB-C18 column (5 µm, 4.6 × 150 mm) at 25 °C. The methanol content of the mobile phase in an aqueous solution of phosphoric acid (0.1%) varied from 50–52% over 56 min (
Bayesian and ML analyses of the combined dataset produced highly consistent topologies. Eranthis sibirica and the new species E. tanhoensis formed a sister clade of that of E. pinnatifida. The monophyly of each species, E. tanhoensis sp. nova, E. sibirica and E. stellata, was strongly supported (Fig.
The morphological analysis revealed that E. sibirica was not homogeneous across its distribution area. We compared 41 characters to distinguish E. sibirica, E. tanhoensis and E. stellata (Suppl. material
The ANOVA of morphometric characters showed significant differences amongst the studied species in characters (1), (9), (16), (18), (22), (24), (29), (30), (31) and (32) at the flowering stage and (6), (10), (14), (17), (19), (23), (25), (40) and (41) at the fruiting stage (Suppl. material
Scatter point diagram in the space of the first two main components for Eranthis sibirica (red dots), Eranthis tanhoensis (green triangles) and Eranthis stellata (blue squares) A at flowering and B at fruiting stages. Ellipses enclose the regions of the space that contain each of the plant species with a 95% probability (95% confidence ellipses).
The karyotypes of three related species, E. sibirica, E. tanhoensis and E. stellata, were investigated (Table
Chromosome numbers (2n), ploidy level (nx), karyotype formulas, and C-values (C ± SD) of the three studied Eranthis species.
Voucher number | Species | Voucher information | 2n | nx | Karyotype formulae | 2C±SD, pg | 1Cx±SD, pg |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | E. sibirica | Republic of Khakassia, Bolshoi On river | 28 | 4x | 2n = 20m (2 sat) + 2m/sm + 6 sm | 38.83±1.03 | 9.71±0.26 |
2 | E. sibirica | Irkutsk Province, Kuitun river | 28 | 4x | 2n = 20m (2 sat) + 2m/sm + 6 sm | 38.19 ± 0.28 | 9.55 ± 0.14 |
3 | E. sibirica | Irkutsk Province, Slyudyanka river | 42 | 6x | 2n = 30m + 12sm (2 sat) | 55.75±0.28 | 9.23±0.14 |
4 | E. sibirica | Irkutsk Province, Burovschina river | 42 | 6x | 2n = 30m + 12sm (2 sat) | 55.76±0.47 | 9.27±0.23 |
5 | E. sibirica | Irkutsk Province, Utulik river | 42 | 6x | 2n = 30m + 12sm (2 sat) | 55.31±0.45 | 9.22±0.25 |
6 | E. tanhoensis | Irkutsk Province, Mamai river | 14 | 2x | 2n = 10m (2sat) + 4sm | 24.88±0.54 | 12.44±0.27 |
7 | E. tanhoensis | Republic of Buryatia, Duliha river | 14 | 2x | 2n = 10m (2sat) + 4sm | 24.97±0.43 | 12.49±0.22 |
8 | E. tanhoensis | Republic of Buryatia, Tolbazikha river | 14 | 2x | 2n = 10m (2sat) + 4sm | 24.77±0.52 | 12.38±0.26 |
9 | E. tanhoensis | Irkutsk Province, Malye Mangaly river | 14 | 2x | 2n = 10m (2sat) + 4sm + 0–8B | 24.15±0.11 | 12.07±0.06 |
10 | E. tanhoensis | Irkutsk Province, Semirechka river | 14 | 2x | 2n = 10m (2sat) + 4sm | 25.31±0.15 | 12.41±0,29 |
11 | E. tanhoensis | Republic of Buryatia, Osinovka river (Tanhoi village) | 14 | 2x | 2n = 10m (2sat) + 4sm | 25.11±0.32 | 12.56±0.16 |
12 | E. tanhoensis | Republic of Buryatia, Mishiha river | 14 | 2x | 2n = 10m (2sat) + 4sm + 0–4B | 25.25±0.15 | 12.07±0.07 |
13 | E. tanhoensis | Republic of Buryatia, Shestipalikha river | 14 | 2x | 2n = 10m (2sat) + 4sm | 25.53±0.18 | 12.77±0.09 |
14 | E. stellata | Primorsky Krai, Vladivostok, Studencheskaya railway station | 16 | 2x | 2n = 16 = 10m + 4sm (2sat) + 2t | 31.76±0.61 | 15.88±0.31 |
15 | E. stellata | Primorsky Krai, Malaya Sedanka river | 16 | 2x | 2n = 16 = 10m + 4sm (2sat) + 2t | 31.88±0.67 | 15.94±0.34 |
16 | E. stellata | Primorsky Krai, “13th km” railway station |
16 | 2x | 2n = 16 = 10m + 4sm (2sat) + 2t | – | – |
17 | E. stellata | Primorsky Krai, Russkiy Island | 16 | 2x | 2n = 16 = 10m + 4sm (2sat) + 2t | 28.47±0.46 | 14.23±0.23 |
Eranthis sibirica. Two cytotypes, with basic chromosome number x = 7, were revealed. Eranthis sibirica from the Republic of Khakassia (1) and Irkutsk Province (2) were tetraploid with 2n = 4x = 28 (Fig.
Mitotic metaphase chromosomes. A Eranthis sibirica (voucher 1 in Table
Eranthis tanhoensis. We determined the chromosome numbers in specimens of eight populations of E. tanhoensis. All plants studied were diploid, with 2n = 2x = 14 (Table
Eranthis stellata. In all four studied populations of E. stellata, the basic chromosome number was x = 8. This species was diploid with 2n = 2x = 16, which is typical of the genus (Table
The basic chromosome number x = 8 has been reported for the entire genus Eranthis (
The average absolute DNA content of hexaploid samples of E. sibirica was 2C = 55.33 ± 0.52 pg and that of tetraploid samples was 2C = 38.19 ± 0.28 pg. In diploid E. tanhoensis, the average absolute DNA content was 2C = 25.02 ± 0.28 pg. The average absolute DNA content of diploid E. stellata was 2C = 31.47 ± 0.46 pg. The monoploid DNA content of the E. sibirica cytotypes was similar: 1Cx = 9.55 ± 0.14 pg in tetraploids and 1Cx = 9.25 ± 0.20 pg in hexaploids. The monoploid DNA content of E. tanhoensis was 1Cx = 12.49 ± 0.16 pg and that of E. stellata was 1Cx = 15.77 ± 0.20 pg.
Tetraploids and hexaploids of E. sibirica exhibited insignificant differences in DNA content (9.25 pg for 6x and 9.55 for 4x), whereas diploids of E. tanhoensis showed a higher 1Cx level (12.49 pg), which may indicate a relatively ancient diversification of these species. Data on the 1Cx level of E. stellata (15.77 pg) indicated the independent or parallel evolution of genome size in this species. According to flow cytometry, variations in 1Cx levels between diploid samples of E. tanhoensis and hexaploids and tetraploids of E. sibirica were in accordance with the hypothesis of genome downsizing in polyploid flowering plants (
Phenolic compounds are often used in chemotaxonomic studies owing to their wide distribution in plants, structural diversity and chemical stability (
Twenty four phenolic compounds were detected in 70% ethanol extracts of plant leaves of the three Eranthis species (E. sibirica, E. stellata and E. tanhoensis) using HPLC (Fig.
HPLC chromatograms of 70% water-ethanol extracts of Eranthis leaves detected by HPLC-DAD at 255 nm. The X-axis displays the retention time, min; Y-axis – the detector signal in optical density units. The identified peaks are 1. chlorogenic acid, 2. gentisic acid, 3. caffeic acid, 5. orientin, 8. vitexin, 10. hyperoside, 11. salicylic acid, 19. quercetin and 24. kaempferol.
The chromatographic profile of E. sibirica differed from that of E. tanhoensis in the presence of caffeic acid, orientin, vitexin and flavone (peak 6: tR, min = 9.4, λmax, nm = 270, 310) in 70% ethanol leaf extracts (Fig.
The analysis of the data presented above allowed us to distinguish a new species from specimens previously identified as E. sibirica.
Russia, Republic of Buryatia, Kabansky district, Osinovka River near Tanhoi village, 51°33'06.2"N, 105°05'34.7"E, 458 m a.s.l., 01 May 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko, & O.A. Chernysheva s.n. (holotype, NS-0000948!, isotypes TK, IRK, E).
Herb perennial, 12.0–23.0 cm long at flowering and 18.0–40.0 cm long at fruiting. Tubers subglobose, not or slightly branching, 1.2–3.3 cm diam., producing thin fibrous roots. Basal leaf single, long-petiolate, green; petioles 5.0–6.0 cm long at flowering and 23–25 cm at fruiting; blades 2.5–3.8 × 2.5–3.5 cm at flowering and 7.5–12 × 7.5–12 cm at fruiting, deeply palmately divided into 5 segments (maximum length of segment dissection 2.3 cm at flowering (3.5 cm at fruiting)); leaf blade segments rounded or widely rhombic, 0.8–2.5 × 0.4–1.8 cm at flowering (1.7–8.5 × 1.2–7.5 cm at fruiting), unlobed or dissected into 1–2 lobes at both flowering and fruiting stages; segment of basal leaves with 5–19 acute teeth at apex at flowering, 6–25 teeth at fruiting. Involucre present, 1.1–5.5 cm diam. at flowering (7–11 cm at fruiting stage); involucral bracts (cauline leaf) sessile, laciniate, similar to basal leaf, divided into 5 trifid leaf-like segments (maximum length of segment dissection is 1.6 cm at flowering (4.0 cm at fruiting)); segments rounded or widely rhombic, 1.1–3.0 × 0.5–2.5 cm at flowering (3.3–6.4 × 1.4–5.3 cm at fruiting), unlobed or dissected into 2 lobes both at flowering and fruiting stages; each segment with 5–21 teeth (at both flowering and fruiting stages), acute at the apex. Pedicels 0.5–1.5 cm long, elongated in fruiting (3.5–5.5 cm long), densely covered with papillate and large hemispherical trichomes. Flowers bisexual, actinomorphic, solitary, erect, 2–4 cm diam. Sepals 4–7, deciduous in fruit, white or light pink at margin, flat, narrowly obovate or elliptic, 1.1–2.6 × 0.5–1.3 cm. Petals 5–15 × 0.6–0.8 cm long, bicoloured, white, tubular, two-lipped with bilobate or forked lips, each lobe of abaxial lip acute at the apex and with globular yellow swellings (nectaries: Fig.
The new species belongs to E. sect. Shibateranthis (Nakai) Tamura and it is sister to E. sibirica, according to the results of molecular phylogenetic analysis (Fig.
Morphological differences among E. sibirica, E. tanhoensis, and E. stellata.
Character | E. sibirica | E. tanhoensis | E. stellata |
---|---|---|---|
Leaf colour at flowering | green | green | coppery or green |
Teeth at the apex of basal leaf segments | rounded | acute | rounded |
Maximum dissection of the basal leaf segments (at flowering), cm | 1.0 | 2.3 | 0.4–? |
Maximum dissection of the basal leaf segments (at fruiting), cm | 2.3 | 3.5 | 1.3 |
Number of teeth on the segments of the basal leaf (at fruiting) | 3–12 | 6–25 | 3–5 |
Apex of involucral leaves | rounded | acute | rounded |
Width of the involucral leaf segments (at fruiting), cm | 0.4–1.2 | 1.4–5.3 | 0.5–2.3 |
Maximum dissection of the involucral leaf segments (at flowering), cm | 1.6 | 1.6 | 1.0 |
Maximum dissection of the involucral leaf segments (at fruiting), cm | 2.1 | 4.0 | 1.7 |
Number of teeth on the segments of the involucral leaf (at flowering) | 1–5 | 5–21 | 3–9 |
Number of teeth on the segments of the involucral leaf (at fruiting) | 2–5 | 5–21 | 3–8 |
Flower position | erect | erect | recurved |
Scape pubescence | glabrous or with papillate trichomes | large hemispherical and papillate trichomes | glandular and stellate trichomes |
Sepal number | 5–7 | 4–7 | 5–8 |
Shape of petals | narrow urn-shaped | broadly urn-shaped | funnelform |
Swellings (nectaries) position | at the apex | at the apex | in medium part |
Apex colour of adaxial lip | yellow | yellow | white |
Apex colour of abaxial lip | yellow | yellow | white |
Margin colour between abaxial and adaxial lips | white | yellow | white |
Stamen colour | white | white | violet, pink or white |
Stylodium length, cm | 0.2–0.5 | 0.1–0.3 | 0.2–0.4 |
The new species differs from other related species by dense glandular pubescence of the flower stems, rounded or widely rhombic (not obovate or lanceolate) leaf blade segments, acute, rather than rounded teeth apices of the basal and stem leaves, a large number of teeth and width of the segments of the basal and stem leaves (see also 2). Additionally, all three species growing in Russia have different distribution patterns (Figs
Flowering time: April–early May; fruiting time: late May–June.
(Fig.
Eranthis tanhoensis can be found at 350–2400 m a.s.l., where it grows in fir, Siberian pine, spruce and birch forests, on riverbanks, beside streams (up to 1500 m a.s.l.) and in subalpine meadows (at higher altitudes).
The specific epithet of the new species is derived from the type locality, Tanhoi village, Republic of Buryatia, Russia.
Russia: Republic of Buryatia: Kabansky district, Osinovka river (Tanhoi village), 51°33'06.2"N, 105°05'34.7"E, 458 m a.s.l., 20 Jun 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko, E.Yu. Mitrenina & O.A. Chernysheva s.n. (NS-0000949!); Kabansky district, Mishikha river, 51°37'46.7"N, 105°32'05.2"E, 480 m a.s.l., 01 May 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko & O.A. Chernysheva 31 (NS-0000950!); Kabansky district, Mishikha river, 51°37'46.7"N, 105°32'05.2"E, 480 m a.s.l., 01 May 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko & O.A. Chernysheva 31a (NS-0000951!); Kabansky district, Mishikha river, 51°37'32.6"N, 105°32'03.4"E, 478 m a.s.l., 20 Jun 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko, E.Yu. Mitrenina & O.A. Chernysheva s.n. (NS-0000952!); Kabansky district, Dulikha river, 51°32'04.9"N, 105°01'43.2"E, 461 m a.s.l., 01 May 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko & O.A. Chernysheva 14 (NS-0000953!); Kabansky district, Dulikha river, 51°32'04.9"N, 105°01'43.2"E, 461 m a.s.l., 20 Jun 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko, E.Yu. Mitrenina & O.A. Chernysheva (NS-0000954!); Kabansky district, Shestipalikha river, 51°32'46.4"N, 105°04'28.9"E, 465 m a.s.l., 01 May 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko & O.A. Chernysheva s.n. (NS-0000955!); Kabansky district, Shestipalikha river, 51°32'46.4"N, 105°04'28.9"E, 465 m a.s.l, 21 Jun 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko, E.Yu. Mitrenina & O.A. Chernysheva (NS-0000956!); Kabansky district, Tolbazikha river, 51°26'21.06"N, 104°41'09.82"E, 471 m a.s.l., 02 May 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko & O.A. Chernysheva s.n. (NS-0000957!); Kabansky district, Tolbazikha river, 51°26'21.06"N, 104°41'09.82"E, 471 m a.s.l., 20 Jun 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko, E.Yu. Mitrenina & O.A. Chernysheva s.n. (NS-0000958!); Irkutsk Province: Slyudyansky district, Semirechka river, 51°28'56.92"N, 104°19'43.47"E, 470 m a.s.l., 02 May 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko & O.A. Chernysheva 048 (NS-0000959!); Slyudyansky district, Semirechka river, 51°28'56.92"N, 104°19'43.47"E, 470 m a.s.l., 21 Jun 2019, A.S. Erst, D.A. Krivenko, E.Yu. Mitrenina & O.A. Chernysheva s.n. (NS-0000960!).
Although the species seems to have a small distribution area in southern Baikal Lake, the populations observed in 2018 and 2019 consisted of numerous individuals producing viable fruits and no threats to the habitats were observed in the field studies. The EOO of E. tanhoensis was estimated for an area of more than 1372 km2, while the AOO was 72 km2. Preliminary conservation status, according to IUCN’s Extent of Occurrence criteria indicates the species as Endangered (EN) (
1 | Maximum dissection of basal leaf segments ~0.4 cm long at flowering stage, 1.3 cm long at fruiting stage; scape with stellate hairs; involucral leaves green or coppery at flowering; maximum dissection of the involucral leaves 1.7 cm long at fruiting; flowers recurved; petals narrowly funnelform, swellings (nectaries) located in medium part of adaxial lip lobes, apex of abaxial and adaxial lips white; anthers violet, pink or white | E. stellata |
– | Maximum dissection of basal leaf segments at least 1.0 cm long at flowering, 2.3 cm long at fruiting stage; scape without stellate hairs; involucral leaves green at flowering; maximum dissection of the involucral leaves 2.1 cm long or more at fruiting; flowers erect, petals urn-shaped, swellings (nectaries) located at the apex of adaxial lip lobes, apex of abaxial and adaxial lips yellow; anthers white | 2 |
2 | Apex of basal and involucral leaves rounded; maximum dissection of basal leaf segments 1.0 cm long at flowering and 2.3 cm long at fruiting; segments of involucral leaves at fruiting 0.4–1.2 cm wide; maximum dissection of the involucral leaves at fruiting 2.1 cm long; each segment of involucral leaves with 1–5 teeth; scape glabrous or papillate; petals narrowly urn-shaped, margins between abaxial and adaxial lips white | E. sibirica |
– | Apex of basal and involucral leaves acute; maximum dissection of basal leaf segments 2.3 cm long at flowering and 3.5 cm long at fruiting; segments of involucral leaves at fruiting 1.4–5.3 cm wide; maximum dissection of the involucral leaves at fruiting 4.0 cm long; each segment of involucral leaves with 5–21 teeth; scape papillate and with large hemispherical glands; petals broadly urn-shaped, margins between abaxial and adaxial lips yellow | E. tanhoensis |
We thank Mark Newman, Marco Pellegrini, Andriy Novikoff, Colin Pendry, Christoph Dobeš and Johannes Walter for discussion of some parts of the manuscript and valuable comments, the staff of the herbaria visited, as well as Valentin Yakubov for the images of Eranthis stellata and Roman Annenkov for preparing Fig.
Tables S1–S4
Data type: measurement.
Explanation note: Table S1. List of samples characters used in molecular (M), cytogenetical (C) and biochemical (B) analyses. Table S2. Morphological characters of Russian Eranthis species. An asterisk indicates characters used in the numerical analysis. Table S3. The results of the variance analysis for plant characters in the flowering stage. The values in parentheses are adjusted P-values; the characters in bold are those without significant interspecific differences. Table S4. The results of the variance analysis for plant characters in the fruiting stage. The values in parentheses are adjusted P-values; the characters in bold are those without significant interspecific differences.