Research Article |
Corresponding author: Watanabe Yoichi ( ashitaka3776@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Peter de Lange
© 2019 Watanabe Yoichi, Tadashi Minamitani, Sang-Hun Oh, Atsushi J. Nagano, Harue Abe, Tomohisa Yukawa.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Yoichi W, Minamitani T, Oh S-H, Nagano AJ, Abe H, Yukawa T (2019) New taxa of Rhododendron tschonoskii alliance (Ericaceae) from East Asia. PhytoKeys 134: 97-114. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.134.38216
|
Three new taxa, Rhododendron sohayakiense Y.Watan. & T.Yukawa (Ericaceae), and its two varieties, var. kiusianum Y.Watan., T.Yukawa & T.Minamitani and var. koreanum Y.Watan. & T.Yukawa are described and illustrated from Japan and South Korea. They can be distinguished from each other and from the other members of the R. tschonoskii alliance, i.e. R. tschonoskii, R. tetramerum, R. trinerve and R. tsusiophyllum, through their combination of leaf size, leaf morphologies including lateral nerves on abaxial leaf surface, corolla morphologies including number of corolla lobes, style length and anther form. Phylogenetic inferences based on chloroplast DNA and genome-wide sequences revealed that each of the three new taxa is monophyletic and they further form a clade. Distributions of the three taxa are also clearly separated from each other and also from the other members of the R. tschonoskii alliance.
Ericaceae, new species, phylogeny, Rhododendron
The genus Rhododendron L. (Ericaceae) is morphologically diverse, comprising about 1,000 woody species (
Rhododendron tschonoskii Maxim., R. tetramerum (Makino) Nakai, R. trinerve Franch. ex Boisser and R. tsusiophyllum Sugim. are closely related species placed within the subgenus Tsutsusi, which grow on exposed rocks or open sites in slopes and ridges on mountains. Among them, R. tsusiophyllum was originally described as a species of an independent genus Tsusiophyllum tanakae Maxim. (1870), because anthers of this species open through longitudinal slits while anthers of all other species in Rhododendron open through apical pores. The first taxonomic reappraisal of this group except R. tsusiophyllum was conducted by
Rhododendron tschonoskii sensu
The morphological characters were observed and measured based on living materials in the field and herbarium specimens listed in the sections “Additional specimens examined”.
Samples for DNA analyses were collected from three individuals for Rhododendron tschonoskii, R. tetramerum, R. trinerve, R. tsusiophyllum and new entities, respectively. Three samples for each species and two entities and two samples for one entity (see Results and Discussion) were selected for covering entire range, and a holotype for each entity was included (Table
Species | Code | Locality | Latitude / Longitude | Haplotype | Voucher |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
R. sohayakiense var. sohayakiense (Type 1) |
Syk | Mt. Syakagadake, Nara, Japan | 34.1145, 135.9020 | H1 | Y. Watanabe & K. Yukitoshi s.n. |
Miu | Mt. Miune, Tokushima, Japan | 33.8398, 133.9877 | H1 | Y. Watanabe & T. Fukuda s.n. | |
Ttj | Mt. Tsutsujyo, Ehime, Japan | 33.7333, 133.1593 | H1 | Y. Watanabe & M. Takahashi Ttj02 | |
R. sohayakiense var. kiusianum (Type 2) |
Ici | Mt. Ichifusa, Kumamoto, Japan | 32.3124, 131.1010 | H2 | Y. Watanabe Ici01 |
Mks | Mt. Mukousaka, Kumamoto, Japan | 32.5842, 131.1054 | H2 | Y. Watanabe Mks04 | |
Sob | Mt. Sobo, Miyazaki, Japan | 32.8114, 131.3470 | H3 | Y. Watanabe & T. Oi s.n. | |
R. sohayakiense var. koreanum (Type 3) | Gom | Gonam, Jeollabuk-do, South Korea | 35.4744, 127.5002 | H4 | Y. Watanabe, S. Hwang & N. Yun Gom01 |
Wol | Mt. Wolbong, Gyeongsangnam-do, South Korea | 35.7476, 127.7094 | H4 | Y. Watanabe, S. Hwang & N. Yun Wol01 | |
R. trinerve | Snp | Mt. Sanpouiwa, Ishikawa, Japan | 36.2586, 136.8441 | H5 | Y. Watanabe Snp02 |
Sad | Sado Island, Niigata, Japan | 37.9280, 138.4534 | H5 | H. Abe s.n. | |
Iid | Mt. Iide, Niigata, Japan | 37.9188, 139.5849 | H6 | Y. Wataanbe s.n. | |
R. tetramerum | Utk | Mt. Utsukushigahara, Nagano, Japan | 36.2277, 138.0975 | H7 | Y. Watanabe s.n. |
Abe | Abe-touge pass, Shizuoka, Japan | 35.3135, 138.3605 | H7 | Y. Watanabe Abe01 | |
Kmg | Mt. Kamagatake, Mie, Japan | 35.0012, 136.4212 | H7 | Y. Watanabe & T. Oi s.n. | |
R. tschonoskii | Zao | Mt. Zao, Miyagi, Japan | 38.1105, 140.4553 | H8 | Y. Watanabe Zao01 |
Mus | Mt. Musadake, Hokkaido, Japan | 43.6741, 144.8850 | H8 | Y. Watanabe s.n. | |
Tor | Mt. Toraidake, Aomori, Japan | 40.4505, 141.0100 | H9 | Y. Watanabe s.n. | |
R. tsusiophyllum | Hkn | Mt. Hakone-komagatake, Kanagawa, Japan | 35.2235, 139.0233 | H10 | Y. Watanabe Hkn01 |
Kdz | Kouzushima Island, Tokyo, Japan | 34.13103, 139.0912 | H11 | H. Abe s.n. | |
Tng | Mt. Tengu, Nagano, Japan | 35.99188, 138.5689 | H11 | Y. Watanabe s.n. |
In addition, genome-wide SNPs were identified from two double digest restriction-site associated DNA (ddRAD) libraries using
The phylogenetic relationships were inferred from two data sets, which were obtained from chloroplast DNA sequences and RAD-seq, based on the maximum likelihood method using RAxML v. 8.2.0 (
We found three new entities (Types 1, 2 and 3) that have previously been included within Rhododendron tschonoskii (Fig.
The three types share the following combination of characters as commonly derived character states, which can be distinguished from the other members of the R. tschonoskii alliance. The corolla form of the three types are tubular-funnelform and corolla lobes are tetramerous; in addition, lateral nerves on abaxial leaf surface are raised or obscure raised, and not prominent, such as R. trinerve.
Photographs of flowers and leaves for the new taxa described in this study. A, B Rhododendron sohayakiense var. sohayakiense, Mt. Tsutsujo, Ehime Prefecture, Japan C, D Rhododendron sohayakiense var. kiusianum, Mt. Mukousaka, Kumamoto Prefecture, Japan E, F Rhododendron sohayakiense var. koreanum, Mt. Wolbong, Gyeongsangnam-do, South Korea. Photographs by Yoichi Watanabe.
Photographs of flowers for the other members of Rhododendron tschonoskii alliance. A Rhododendron tschonoskii, Mt. Bandai, Fukushima Prefecture, Japan B Rhododendron tsusiophyllum, Mt. Kobushigatake, Yamanashi Prefecture, Japan C Rhododendron trinerve, Mt. Sanpouiwa, Ishikawa Prefecture, Japan D Rhododendron tetramerum, Mt. Yatsugatake, Nagano Prefecture, Japan. Photographs A–C by Yoichi Watanabe D courtesy of Osamu Takahashi.
Character | R. sohayakiense var. sohayakiense (Type 1) | R. sohayakiense var. kiusianum (Type 2) | R. sohayakiense var. koreanum (Type 3) | R. tschonoskii | R. tsusiophyllum | R. trinerve | R. tetramerum |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Leaf length (mm) | 10–20 | 10–20 | 10–35 | 10–25 | 5–13 | 15–50 | 5–20 |
Leaf width (mm) | 4–7 | 5–10 | 5–15 | 5–12 | 2–5 | 5–20 | 5–10 |
Nerve on abaxial surface of leaf | pinnate 2–3 pairs, obscurely raised | pinnate 2–3 pairs, raised | pinnate 1–3 pairs, raised | nervules reticulate | nervules obscurely reticulate | pinnate 1–2 pairs, prominent, nervules reticulate | nervules obscurely reticulate |
Hair of leaf | densely strigose on adaxial surface, glabrous or sparsely strigose on abaxial surface | densely strigose on adaxial surface, sparsely strigose on abaxial surface | densely strigose on adaxial surface, sparsely strigose on abaxial surface | strigose on both surfaces | densely strigose on adaxial surface, glabrous on abaxial surface | strigose on both surfaces | densely strigose on adaxial surface, glabrous or sparsely strigose on abaxial surface |
Corolla form | tubular-funnelform | tubular-funnelform | tubular-funnelform | tubular-funnelform | tubiform | tubular-funnelform | tubiform |
Number of corolla lobes | 4 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 |
Corolla tube length (mm) | 2–3 | 3–4 | 2–3 | 2–4 | 5–7 | 2–4 | 3.5–4.5 |
Corolla lobe length (mm) | 3–5 | 2–5 | 3–5 | 4–6 | ca. 2 | 4–6 | 2–3 |
Style length (mm) | 4–10 | 3–4 | 5–6 | 6–13 | 4–5 | 3–7 | 2.5–3.5 |
Style condition | exserted | included | exserted | exserted | included | exserted | included |
Anther | opening by apical pores | opening by apical pores | opening by apical pores | opening by apical pores | opening by longitudinal slits | opening by apical pores | opening by apical pores |
Distribution | Japan: Honshu (Kii Peninsula) and Shikoku | Japan: Kyushu | South Korea: Gyeongsang and Jeolla provinces | Japan: Honshu (Kanto and Tohoku districts) and Hokkaido. Russia: Kunashir Island | Japan: Honshu (Chubu and Kanto districts) | Japan: Honshu (Kinki, Chubu, Kanto and Tohoku districts) | Japan: Honshu (Kinki, Chubu and Kanto districts) |
Phylogenetic relationships of the R. tschonoskii alliance based on chloroplast DNA sequences (2,847 bp with 76 polymorphic sites) and genome-wide sequences (RAD-seq, 316,455 bp with 37266 SNPs) were almost concordant including outgroup species (Fig.
Thus the three types can be distinguished from each other and also from the other members of the R. tschonoskii alliance. The results indicate that the three types should be treated as different taxa but these are more closely related than the others in the R. tschonoskii alliance. Since we confirmed the independent state of the three types from morphological and phylogenetic characteristics, we hereby describe them as a new species and its two varieties.
Comparative phylogenies for A haplotypes based on chloroplast DNA sequences and B genotypes based on restriction site associated DNA sequences (RAD-seq). Bootstrap probabilities (> 70%) are shown above nodes. Gray boxes indicate three new taxa described in this study and light gray boxes indicate the other members of the Rhododendron tschonoskii alliance.
This species is similar to Rhododendron tschonoskii Maxim, but is distinguishable through its 4 corolla lobes and its pinnate nerves on the adaxial leaf surface.
JAPAN. Shikoku: Ehime Pref., Kumakogen Town, Mt. Tsutsujo-yama, 33°44'00.01"N, 133°09'33.40"E, on ridge of the mountain, 1800 m, 20 July 2016 (fl), Y. Watanabe and M. Takahashi Ttj02 (holotype TNS; isotypes TNS, KYO).
JAPAN. Kii Peninsula, Honshu: Nara Pref., Yoshino County, Kamikitayama Village, Mt. Oodaigahara, Daijyagura, 1500 m, 23 Aug 1956 (fr), G. Murata 10133 (KYO); Nara Pref., Yoshino County, Kamikitayama Village, Mt. Oodaigahara, Daijyagura, 1600 m, 18 Jul 2012 (fl), K. Yamawaki 4869 (KYO); Nara Pref., Yoshino County, Shimokitayama Village, Mt. Kujyaku, 1800 m, 17 Jul 1954 (fl), G. Murata & T. Shimizu 104 (KYO); Shikoku: Tokushima Pref., Miyoshi County, Higashiiya Village, Mt. Tsurugi, 1950 m, 25 Jul 1986 (fl), G. Murata et al. 45946 (KYO); Tokushima Pref., Miyoshi County, Higashiiya Village, Mt. Tsurugi, 1700m, 22 Oct 2012 (fr), Y. Katayama 32 (KYO); Tokushima Pref., Miyoshi County, Nishiiyayama Village, Mt. Nakatsu, 1400 m, 10 Aug 1954, G. Murata 7728 (KYO); Kochi Pref., Nagaoka County, Otoyo Village, Mt. Kajigamori, 1200 m, 22 Aug 1964, G. Murata 18671 (KYO); Ehime Pref., Kamiukena County, Kumakougen Town, Mt. Ishizuchi, between Dogamori and summit, 1600–1980 m, 27 Jul 1983 (fl), G. Murata 44754 (KYO); Ehime Pref., Saijyo City, Mt Ishizuchi, between starting point and summit, 1400–1850 m, 17 Jul 1992 (fl), T. Minamitani 43440 (TNS); Ehime Pref., Niihama City, Mt. Douzanmine, 1300 m, 15 Jul 1980 (fl), K. Tsuchiya 491 (KYO); Ehime Pref., Uma County, Mt. Higashiakaisi and Mt. Futatsudake, 1600 m, 8 Sep 1961 (fr), G. Murata 14993 (KYO); Ehime Pref, Niihama City, Mt. Higashiakaishi, 33°52'31.03"N, 133°22'26.31"E, 1700 m, 15 Jul 2017 (fl), Y. Watanabe Hga03 (TNS).
Much branched semi-evergreen shrubs 1–1.5 m tall. Branchlets and petioles with dense appressed flattened brownish strigose hairs. Spring leaves scattered or crowded on upper branchlets; petioles 0.5–1 mm long; blade thick chartaceous, oblong, 10-20 mm long (at maximum within each individual), 4–7 mm wide, apex acute and terminating in a gland, base acute, adaxial surface green, abaxial surface pale green, densely strigose on adaxial surface, glabrous or sparsely strigose on abaxial surface without midrib; midrib prominent abaxially; lateral nerves pinnate, 2–3 paired, obscure raised abaxially. Summer leaves oblanceolate, 5–10 mm long, 1–6 mm wide, densely strigose on both surfaces. Flower buds terminal, single, broadly ovoid, acute, ca. 2 mm long, 2 mm wide; scales widely ovate, densely strigose on upper outer surface. Inflorescences umbel-like, 2–4 flowers. Pedicel 2–4 mm long at flowering, densely appressed hirsute. Calyx saucer-shaped, ca. 1.5 mm in diam., densely strigose, shallowly 4-lobed; lobes semiorbiculate, ca. 0.5 mm long. Corolla white, no blotches, openly tubular-funnelform, 8–12 mm long and wide, dissected 1/2 corolla length into 4 lobes; tube 2–3 mm long, ca. 2 mm wide, glabrous outside, pilose on upper inside; lobes elliptic to oblong, rounded, 3–5 mm long, 2–4 mm wide. Stamens 4, subequal, 5–8 mm long, exserted; filaments densely pilose on lower three-quarters; anthers yellow, oblong, ca. 1 mm long. Ovary ovoid, densely soft strigose, ca. 1.5 mm. Style 4–10 mm long, exserted, glabrous. Capsule ovoid, 2–5 mm long, 2–3 mm wide, densely strigose.
JAPAN: Honshu (Kii Peninsula), Shikoku.
The plants inhabit sunny places and grow on mountain ridges and slopes at altitudes over 1000 m above sea level. In such places, there are few trees and established communities of shrubs and dwarf bamboos (Sasa sp.). Flowering specimens have been collected from July to August; fruiting specimens have been collected from October to November. Bumblebees are frequent visitors to the flowers, suggesting that they are pollinators of the species.
The specific epithet refers to ‘Sohayaki’ a floristic region in Japan that covers Kii Peninsula of Honshu, Shikoku and Kyushu (
This variety is similar to Rhododendron sohayakiense var. sohayakiense Y. Watan. & T. Yukawa and R. sohayakiense var. koreanum Y. Watan. & T. Yukawa, but is distinguishable through its longer corolla tube and its shorter style included within the corolla. Further, it differs from the former through its raised lateral nerves on the abaxial leaf surface and from the latter through its small leaf size.
JAPAN. Kyushu: Kumamoto Pref., Kamimashiki County, Yamato Village, Mt. Mukosaka, 32°35'03.22"N, 131°06'19.30"E, on rocky ridge of the mountain, 1500 m, 23 July 2016 (fl), Y. Watanabe Mks04 (holotype: TNS; isotypes: TNS, KYO).
JAPAN. Kyushu: Ooita Pref., Mt. Katamuki, 2 Aug 1921 (fl), Z. Tashiro (KYO); Miyazaki Pref., Higashi-Usuki County, Shiiba Village, Mt. Eboshi, 1690 m, 18 Jul 2007 (fl), T. Minamitani (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Higashi-Usuki County, Shiiba Village, Mt. Ougi, 1200–1661 m, 7 Jul 1994 (fl), T. Minamitani 049666 (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Nishi-Usuki County, Hinokage Town, Mt. Goyou, 1570 m, 11 Aug 1990 (fr), T. Minamitani (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Nishi-Usuki County, Hinokage Town, Mt. Katamuki, 1500 m, 25 Aug 1970 (fr), T. Minamitani (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Nishi-Usuki County, Takachiho Town, Mt. Tengu, 1700 m, 24 Jun 1993 (fl), T. Minamitani (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Nishi-Usuki County, Takachiho Town, Mt. Tengu, 1600–1700 m, 16 Aug 1992, T. Minamitani 44119 (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Nishi-Usuki County, Takachiho Town, Mt. Shoji, 1600–1700 m, 16 Aug 1992, T. Minamitani 44128 (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Nishi-Usuki County, Gokase Town, Mt. Mukosaka, Tsutsujigaoka, 1570 m, 12 Jul 1993 (fl), T. Minamitani (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Nishi-Usuki County, Gokase Town, Mt. Mukosaka, Kita, 1550 m, 24 Sep 1996 (fl, fr), T. Minamitani B-T-052838 (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Higashi-Usuki County, Kitakata Town, Mt. Hoko, 1100–1200 m, 26 Jun 1994 (fl), T. Minamitani (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Higashi-Usuki County, Kitakata Town, Mt. Hoko, 1270 m, 23 Sep 1989 (fr), T. Minamitani (TNS); Miyazaki Pref., Nobeoka City, Kitakata, Mt. Ohkue, Kozumidaki, 1340 m, 6 Aug 1992 (fr), T. Minamitani (TNS); Kumamoto Pref., Kuma County, Mt. Ichifusa, 1700 m, 6 Aug 1960 (fl), M. Tagawa & K. Iwatsuki 3676 (KYO); Kumamoto Pref., Kuma County, Yunomae Town, Mt. Ichifusa, 26 Jul 1992 (fl), T. Minamitani 43478 (TNS); Kumamoto Pref., Kuma County, Mizukami Village, Mt. Ichifusa, 32°18'44.65"N, 131°06'03.50"E, on summit of the mountain, 1600 m, 24 July 2016 (fl), Y. Watanabe Ici02 (TNS).
Spring leaves scattered or crowded on upper branchlets; petioles 0.5–1 mm long; blade thick chartaceous, oblong-ovate, 10–20 mm long (at maximum within each individual), 5–10 mm wide, apex acute and terminating in a gland, base acute, strigose on both surfaces; midrib prominent abaxially; lateral nerves pinnate, 2–3 paired, raised abaxially. Summer leaves oblanceolate, 3–10 mm long, 1–5 mm wide, densely strigose on both surfaces. Calyx saucer-shaped, ca. 1.5 mm in diam., densely soft strigose, shallowly 4-lobed; lobes semiorbiculate, ca. 0.5 mm long. Corolla white, no blotches, tubular-funnelform, 7–13 mm long and wide, 4 lobes; tube 3–4 mm long, ca. 3 mm wide, glabrous outside, pilose on upper inside; lobes elliptic to oblong, rounded, 2–5 mm long, ca. 2 mm wide. Stamens 4, irregular, 3–5 mm long, as long as or shorter than corolla; filaments densely pilose on lower half; anthers yellow, oblong, ca. 1 mm long. Ovary ovoid, densely soft strigose, ca. 1.5 mm. Style 3–4 mm long, glabrous, shorter than corolla. Capsule ovoid, 3–4 mm long, 2.5 mm wide, densely strigose.
JAPAN: Kyushu.
The plants inhabit sunny and rocky mountain ridges and slopes at altitudes over 1000 m above sea level. Flowering specimens have been collected from July to August; fruiting specimens have been collected from October to November.
The specific epithet refers to ‘Kyushu’ where the new variety is distributed.
Although the style of this variety is included within the corolla, this part is exserted from the corolla in individuals from Mt. Ichifusa.
This variety is similar to Rhododendron sohayakiense var. sohayakiense Y. Watan. & T. Yukawa and R. sohayakiense var. kiusianum Y. Watan., T. Yukawa & T. Minamitani, but is distinguished by its large leaf size. Further, it differs from the former through its raised lateral nerves on the abaxial leaf surface and from the latter through its shorter corolla tube and by its longer style exserted from the corolla.
SOUTH KOREA. Gyeongsangnam-do: Hamyang County, Mt. Wolbong, 35°44'51.31"N, 127°42'33.99"E, on slope of the mountain, 1000 m, 15 June 2017 (fl), Y. Watanabe, S. Hwang and N. Yun Wol06 (holotype: TNS; isotypes: TNS, KB).
SOUTH KOREA. Jeollabuk-do: Namwon City, Mt. Gonam, 35°28'27.74"N, 127°30'00.82"E, 800 m, 15 Jun 2017 (fl), Y. Watanabe, S. Hwang and N. Yun Gom01 (TNS); Mt. Jirisan, Banyabong peak, 1700 m, 20 Aug 1982 (fr), T. Yamazaki & F. Yamazaki 3294 (KYO); Gyeongsangnam-do: Mt. Gayasan, 23 Aug 1935 (fr), G. Koidzumi (KYO).
Spring leaves scattered or crowded on upper branchlets; petioles 0.5–1 mm long; blade thick chartaceous, oblong, 10–35 mm long (25–35 mm long at maximum within each individual), 5–15 mm wide, apex acute and terminating in a gland, base acute, strigose on both surfaces; midrib prominent abaxially; lateral nerves pinnate, 1–3 paired, raised abaxially. Summer leaves oblanceolate, 6–20 mm long, 1–8 mm wide, densely strigose on both surfaces. Calyx saucer-shaped, ca. 1.5 mm in diam., densely soft strigose, shallowly 4-lobed; lobes semiorbiculate, ca. 0.5 mm long. Corolla white, no blotches, openly tubular-funnelform, 8–12 mm long and wide, dissected 1/2 corolla length into 4 lobes; tube 2–3 mm long, ca. 2 mm wide, glabrous outside, pilose on upper inside; lobes elliptic to oblong, rounded, 3–5 mm long, 2–4 mm wide. Stamens 4, subequal, 6–9 mm long, exserted; filaments densely pilose on lower three-quarters; anthers yellow, oblong, ca. 1 mm long. Ovary ovoid, densely soft strigose, ca. 2 mm. Style 5–6 mm long, exserted, glabrous. Capsule ovoid, 3–4 mm long, 2.5 mm wide, densely strigose.
SOUTH KOREA: Jeollabuk-do, Gyeongsangnam-do.
The plants inhabit mountain ridges and slopes at altitudes over 800 m above sea level. Flowering specimens have been collected from June to August; fruiting specimens have been collected from October. Honeybees are frequent visitors to the flowers, suggesting that they are pollinators of the variety.
The specific epithet refers to ‘Korea’ where the new variety is distributed.
1 | Corolla 4 lobes | 2 |
– | Corolla 5 lobes | 6 |
2 | Corolla tubiform | R. tetramerum |
– | Corolla tubular-funnelform | 3 |
3 | Spring leaves 25–50 mm long at maximum within each individual | 4 |
– | Spring leaves 10–20 mm long at maximum within each individual | 5 |
4 | Lateral nerves of spring leaf 1 paired, prominently raised abaxially, grooved adaxially, nervules reticulate | R. trinerve |
– | Lateral nerves of spring leaf 1–3 paired, raised abaxially, not grooved adaxially | R. sohayakiense var. koreanum |
5 | Style 4–10 mm long, exserted from corolla; lateral nerves of spring leaf obscurely raised | R. sohayakiense var. sohayakiense |
– | Style 3–4 mm long, included within corolla; lateral nerves of spring leaf raised | R. sohayakiense var. kiusianum |
6 | Corolla tubular-funnelform, tube 2–4 mm long; style 6–13 mm long, exserted from corolla | R. tschonoskii |
– | Corolla tubiform, tube 5–7 mm long; style 4–5 mm long, included within corolla | R. tsusiophyllum |
DNA sequences of chloroplast DNA haplotypes reported in this study were deposited in GenBank under accession numbers; LC499847–LC499863 for trnL-F, LC499864–LC499880 for trnL intron, LC499830–LC499846 for trnS-G, LC499813–LC499829 for trnG intron, LC499796–LC499812 for rpl32-trnL. Genotype data for RAD-seq were deposited in Dryad: https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.5tm6680.
We are grateful to Osamu Takahashi for providing a beautiful photograph; and Seung-Hyun Hwang and Narae Yun in South Korea, Takao Oi, Kyohei Yukitoshi, Takumi Fukuda, Minami Takahashi in Japan for their help in collecting plant material. This study was supported by a Grant-Aid for Scientific Research (15K07473, 16K18714) from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science, JSPS.