Research Article |
Corresponding author: Paul M. Peterson ( peterson@si.edu ) Academic editor: Maria Vorontsova
© 2019 Paul M. Peterson, Konstantin Romaschenko, Robert J. Soreng, Jesus Valdés Reyna.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the CC0 Public Domain Dedication.
Citation:
Peterson PM, Romaschenko K, Soreng RJ, Valdés Reyna J (2019) A key to the North American genera of Stipeae (Poaceae, Pooideae) with descriptions and taxonomic names for species of Eriocoma, Neotrinia, Oloptum, and five new genera: Barkworthia, ×Eriosella, Pseudoeriocoma, Ptilagrostiella, and Thorneochloa. PhytoKeys 126: 89-125. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.126.34096
|
Based on earlier molecular DNA studies we recognize 14 native Stipeae genera and one intergeneric hybrid in North America. We provide descriptions, new combinations, and 10 illustrations for species of Barkworthia gen. nov., Eriocoma, Neotrinia, Oloptum, Pseudoeriocoma gen. nov., Ptilagrostiella gen. nov., Thorneochloa gen. nov., and ×Eriosella nothogen. nov. The following 40 new combinations are made: Barkworthia stillmanii, Eriocoma alta, E. arida, E. arnowiae, E. bloomeri, E. bracteata, E. contracta, E. coronata, E. curvifolia, E. hendersonii, E. latiglumis, E. lemmonii, E. lemmonii ssp. pubescens, E. lettermanii, E. lobata, E. nelsonii, E. nelsonii ssp. dorei, E. nevadensis, E. occidentalis, E. occidentalis ssp. californica, E. occidentalis ssp. pubescens, E. parishii, E. parishii ssp. depaupertata, E. perplexa, E. pinetorum, E. richardsonii, E. robusta, E. scribneri, E. swallenii, E. thurberiana, E. wallowaensis, ×Eriosella caduca, Pseudoeriocoma acuta, P. constricta, P. editorum, P. eminens, P. hirticulmis, P. multinodis, Ptilagrostiella kingii, and Thorneochloa diegoensis. A key to the native and introduced genera of North American Stipeae, and an overview of the tribe in North America and worldwide are given. Lectotypes are designated for Eriocoma cuspidata Nutt., Fendleria rhynchelytroides Steud., Stipa bloomeri Bol., Stipa coronata Thurb., Stipa membranacea Pursh, Stipa mormonum Mez, Stipa richardsonii Link, and Stipa williamsii Scribn. Achnatherum s.s. and Piptatherum s.s. are now restricted to Eurasia and the Mediterranean/Asia, respectively.
Basados en estudios anteriores de ADN molecular, reconocemos 14 géneros nativos de Stipeae y un híbrido intergenérico en América del Norte. Se presentan descripciones, nuevas combinaciones, y 10 ilustraciones para las especies de Barkworthia gen. nov., Eriocoma, Neotrinia, Oloptum, Pseudoeriocoma gen. nov., Ptilagrostiella gen. nov., Thorneochloa gen. nov. y ×Eriosella nothogen. nov. Se realizan las siguientes 40 nuevas combinaciones: Barkworthia stillmanii, Eriocoma alta, E. arida, E. arnowiae, E. bloomeri, E. bracteata, E. contracta, E. coronata, E. curvifolia, E. hendersonii, E. latiglumis, E. lemmonii, E. lemmonii ssp. pubescens, E. lettermanii, E. lobata, E. nelsonii, E. nelsonii ssp. dorei, E. nevadensis, E. occidentalis, E. occidentalis ssp. californica, E. occidentalis ssp. pubescens, E. parishii, E. parishii ssp. depaupertata, E. perplexa, E. pinetorum, E. richardsonii, E. robusta, E. scribneri, E. swallenii, E. thurberiana, E. wallowaensis, ×Eriosella caduca, Pseudoeriocoma acuta, P. constricta, P. editorum, P. eminens, P. hirticulmis, P. multinodis, Ptilagrostiella kingii y Thorneochloa diegoensis. Se presenta una clave para los géneros nativos e introducidos de las especies norteamericanas, y una visión general de la tribu en América del Norte y en todo el mundo. Se designan lectotipos para Eriocoma cuspidata Nutt., Fendleria rhynchelytroides Steud., Stipa bloomeri Bol., Stipa coronata Thurb., Stipa membranacea Pursh, Stipa mormonum Mez, Stipa richardsonii Link y Stipa williamsii Scribn. Achnatherum s.s. y Piptatherum s.s. ahora están con distribución restringida- a Eurasia y el Mediterráneo/Asia, respectivamente.
Barkworthia, Eriocoma, ×Eriosella, Gramineae, Neotrinia, North America, Poaceae, Pseudoeriocoma, Ptilagrostiella, Stipeae, taxonomy, Thorneochloa
The tribe Stipeae Dumort. comprises temperate, cool-season (C3) grasses that generally occupy somewhat moist to predominantly dry open grasslands and steppe communities in all continents except Antarctica. They represent an ecologically and morphologically specialized lineage within the subfamily Pooideae including approximately 527 species in 28 genera (
Overview of numbers of species in each genus of Stipeae in North America north of Mexico (FNA), endemic to Mexico, and Worldwide with distribution.
Genus | Year Publ. |
|
|
Present in FNA Region | Mexico Endemic | World-wide | Distribution (* = genus introduced in NA, c = cultivated NA) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Achnatherum | 1812 | 0 | 28 | 0 | 0 | 21 | Mediterranean & Eurasia |
Aciachne | 1881 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 | South America |
Amelichloa | 2006 | ‒ | 3 | 3 | 0 | 5 | Americas |
Anatherostipa | 1996 | ‒ | 0 | 0 | 0 | 8 | South America |
Anemanthele | 1985 | ‒ | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | New Zealand*c |
Austrostipa | 1996 | ‒ | 2 | 2 | 0 | 64 | Australia*c |
Barkworthia | here | ‒ | ‒ | 1 | 0 | 1 | United States |
Celtica | 2004 | ‒ | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | Mediterranean*c |
Eriocoma | 1818 | 0 | ‒ | 25 | 2 | 27 | North America |
Hesperostipa | 1993 | ‒ | 4 | 4 | 1 | 5 | North America |
Jarava | 1794 | 0 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 33? | Latin America*c |
Lorenzochloa | 1969 | ‒ | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | South America |
Macrochloa | 1829 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | Mediterranean*c |
Nassella | 1854 | 1 | 10 | 10 | 3 | 117 | Americas |
Neotrinia | 2019 | ‒ | ‒ | 1 | 0 | 1 | Asia *c |
Oloptum | 2012 | ‒ | ‒ | 1 | 0 | 1 | Mediterranean*c |
Ortachne | 1854 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | South America |
Orthoraphium | 1841 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | Southeast Asia |
Oryzopsis | 1803 | 12 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | North America |
Pappostipa | 2008 | ‒ | ‒ | 2 | 0 | 31 | South America*c |
Patis | 1942 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 3 | East Asia & North America |
Piptatheropsis | 2011 | ‒ | ‒ | 5 | 0 | 5 | North America |
Piptochaetium | 1830 | 1 | 6 | 6 | 5 | 35? | Americas |
Piptatherum | 1812 | 0 | 7 | 0 | 0 | 32 | Mediterranean and Asia |
Psammochloa | 1927 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | East Asia |
Pseudoeriocoma | here | ‒ | ‒ | 1 | 5 | 6 | North America |
Ptilagrostiella | here | ‒ | ‒ | 1 | 0 | 1 | United States |
Ptilagrostis | 1852 | 0 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 15 | East Asia & North America |
Stipa | 1753 | 34 + 2 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 150+ | Mediterranean & Eurasia*c |
Stipellula | 2012 | ‒ | ‒ | 1 | 0 | 1 | Mediterranean & Eurasia* |
Thorneochloa | here | ‒ | ‒ | 1 | 0 | 1 | Western North America |
Timouria | 1916 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | East Asia |
Trikeraia | 1954 | ‒ | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 | East Asia |
× Achnella | 1993 | ‒ | 1 | 0 | ‒ | ‒ | North America |
× Eriosella | here | ‒ | ‒ | 1 | 0 | 1 | North America |
We follow the results previously presented in our molecular studies and provide overall morphological evidence for all genera recognized in this manuscript (
In this paper we propose a new classification of the North American Stipeae, include a key to the native and introduced genera (and Ampelodesmeae) found in Canada, United States of America, and Mexico, and provide descriptions, new combinations, and 10 illustrations for the species of Barkworthia Romasch., P.M. Peterson & Soreng, Eriocoma, Neotrinia, Oloptum, Pseudoeriocoma Romasch., P.M. Peterson & Soreng, Ptilagrostiella Romasch., P.M. Peterson & Soreng, Thorneochloa Romasch., P.M. Peterson & Soreng, and the hybrid genus ×Eriosella Romasch.
Barkworthia stillmanii (Bol.) Romasch., P.M. Peterson & Soreng (≡ Stipa stillmanii Bol.).
Barkworthia differs from Piptatherum P. Beauv. in having spikelets with a pilose callus, paleas with prolonged veins, and 2-lobed lemma apices with lobes 1–3 mm long; and differs from Achnatherum in having saw-like lemma epidermal pattern, not the maize-like pattern characteristic of all achnatheroid grasses.
Plants short-rhizomatous perennials. Culms 60–150 cm tall with 2–5 puberulent nodes, 2–5 mm thick below, often geniculate. Leaf sheaths mostly glabrous or distally ciliate; collars glabrous or pubescent; ligules 0.2–0.5 mm long, membranous, apex truncate; blades 15–30 cm long; 3–7 mm wide, scabrous. Panicles 10–24 cm long, 1.5–3 cm wide, contracted; branches appressed, ascending, lower branches 2–3.5 cm long. Spikelets 14–18 mm long, lanceolate, subterete with one fertile floret without rachilla extension, disarticulation above the glumes; glumes 14–18 mm long, single-awned, the awns 2–3 mm long; lower glumes 1–3-veined, upper glumes 3–5-veined; florets 8–10 mm long, fusiform; calluses 0.5–1.2 mm long, rounded, pilose; lemmas 3-veined, evenly hairy, the hairs about 1.5 mm long, apex 2-lobed, the lobes 1–3 mm long with awnlike tips, narrow; lemma epidermal pattern saw-like; fundamental cells of variable length with sinuous sidewalls 2–7 times longer than silica cells irregularly alternating; silica bodies elongated-rectangular with straight or very shallow contracted sidewalls; cork cells not prominent; lemmatal awns 18–30 mm long, terminal, awned from the sinus, scabrous, 1 or 2-geniculate, persistent; paleas as long or longer than lemmas, 2-veined, hairy, the veins 1–3 mm prolonged reaching almost to the tip of the lemma lobes; anthers 4–6 mm long, penicillate, 3 in number; lodicules 3; stigmas 2. Caryopses fusiform, pericarp adherent, hilum linear.
The generic name honors Mary Elizabeth Barkworth, a well-known American agrostologist, who has contributed many papers investigating the taxonomy of the Stipeae.
Stipa stillmanii
Bol., Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci. 4: 169. 1872 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum stillmanii (Bol.) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 14. 1993 – Type: USA, California, Sierra Nevada, Blue Cañon, Jul 1870, H.N. Bolander, M.D. Kellogg & co. s.n. (holotype: NY-00431576 [image!]; isotypes: GH-00017890 [image!], K-000873398 [image!], MO-3055652!, MO-3055653!, MO-3055654!, NDG-07159 [image!], US-556922!). Fig.
Barkworthia stillmanii is distributed in scattered locations in northern California (Butte, El Dorado, Nevada, Placer, Plumas, Sacramento, Shasta, Sierra, Tehama, Trinity, Tulare, and Yuba Counties) associated with yellow pine and red fir forests; 10–1500 m (
In a molecular-derived phylogeny of the Stipeae using 10 DNA markers Barkworthia stillmanii is sister to a well-supported Piptatherum clade, which is strictly Old World in distribution, and has cauducous awns, and dark glossy lemmas in fruit (
= Fendleria Steud., Syn. Pl. Glumac. 1: 419. 1854. Type: Fendleria rhynchelytroides Steud. (= Eriocoma hymenoides).
Eriocoma hymenoides (Roem. & Schult.) Rydb. (≡ Stipa hymenoides Roem. & Schult.).
Plants perennial, sometimes short rhizomatous, tightly to loosely cespitose. Culms 10–230 cm tall, erect, unbranched above, nodes glabrous or pubescent, nodes 2–4 (5). Leaf sheaths glabrous, pubescent or pilose, glabrous or distally ciliate; collars glabrous or with a tufts of hairs; ligules 0.1–10 mm long, hyaline to membranous, apex truncate, obtuse, acute or narrowly acute; blades 0.1–7 mm wide, flat, convolute or involute, smooth, scabrous, glabrous or hairy. Panicles 2.5–60 cm long, up to 15 cm wide, usually contracted, sometimes open with divergent branches; branches straight, sometimes flexuous. Spikelets 5–21 mm long, usually lanceolate, sometimes obovoid, subterete, rarely laterally compressed, with one fertile floret without rachilla extension, disarticulation above the glumes; glumes 5–21 mm long, longer than the florets, unawned, 1(3)-veined, apex usually acuminate, sometimes acute; florets 2.5–10 mm long, usually fusiform, sometimes obovoid; calluses 0.3–2 mm long, blunt, sharp, or acute, hairy; lemmas usually coriaceous, sometimes indurate, usually evenly hairy, sometimes glabrous, or distally or with longer or shorter hairs than the body, apex usually entire or 2-lobed with lobes less than 2.1 mm long; lemma epidermal pattern maize-like; fundamental cells square with roundish corners and straight sidewalls subequal to silica cells or shorter, often regularly alternating; silica bodies square-cornered or sometimes rounded without contractions; cork cells scarce to absent; lemmatal awns 3–80 mm long, 1 or 2-geniculate; paleas ¼ to as long or longer than the lemma, 2-veined, usually hairy, sometimes glabrous, veins usually not prolonged, but if prolonged then not more than 0.3 mm long; anthers 1–5 mm long, usually penicillate, 3 in number; lodicules 2 or 3; stigmas 2. Caryopses fusiform, pericarp adherent, hilum linear.
There are 27 species of Eriocoma, all occurring in western North America (Canada, Mexico, and the USA) and only E. hymenoides extends its range into northeastern USA (
Within our earlier and unpublished molecular analyses of Eriocoma there are three separate clades of E. lobata and one undescribed species (
Stipa alta Swallen, Proc. Biol. Soc. Wash. 56: 79. 1943 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum altum (Swallen) Hoge & Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 5. 1993. Type: Mexico, Coahuila, mpio. Cuatro Cienegas, Sierra de la Madera, Canon del Agua, rare in dry shrub zones of lower canyon, 10 Sep 1939, C. H. Muller 3261 (holotype: US-2209361!; isotypes: GH-00024473 [image!], US-2871136!).
Stipa arida M.E. Jones, Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci., ser. 2, 5: 725. 1895 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum aridum (M.E. Jones) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 6. 1993. Type: USA, Utah, Piute Co., Marysvale, 6000 ft, 4 Jun 1894, M.E. Jones 5377 (holotype: not located; isotypes: AHUC-13276 [image!], BM-001042155 [image!], G-00176508 [image!], MO-2151568 [image!], MSC-0092934 [image!], US-236787!).
= Stipa mormonum Mez, Repert. Spec. Nov. Regni Veg. 17: 209. 1921. Type: USA, Utah, Milford, 21 Jun 1880, 5000 ft, M.E. Jones 2106 (lectotype: MO-2151566 [image!] designated here; isolectotypes: S-G-5821 [image!], US-866079 fragm. ex B! [image 00157472!]).
Stipa arnowiae S.L. Welsh & N.D. Atwood, Utah Fl. (ed. 3) 799. 2003 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum arnowiae (S.L. Welsh & N.D. Atwood) Barkworth, Sida 22(1): 496. 2006. Type: USA, Utah, Kane Co., T43S, R4W, S13, ca. 9 mi E of Johnson Canyon Jct,, 1740 m, 30 May 2003, S. L. Welsh & T. O’Dell 28062 (holotype: BRY; isotypes: GH-00247115 [image!], NY-00887984 [image!], US-3498681!).
Stipa bloomeri Bol., Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci. 4: 168. 1872 [Basionym] ≡ Oryzopsis bloomeri (Bol.) Ricker, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 11: 109. 1906 ≡ ×Stiporyzopsis bloomeri (Bol.) B.L. Johnson, Amer. J. Bot. 32: 602, f. 14–18. 1945 ≡ Achnatherum × bloomeri (Bol.) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 14. 1993 Type: USA, California, Bloody Canyon near Mono Lake, Sep 1866, H.N. Bolander 6116 (lectotype: US-2947421! [US-00141573 image!] designated here, partial lectotype [collection number only] designated by Hitchcock Flora N. Amer. 17(6): 429. 1935; isolectotypes: CAS-0005671 [image!], K-000912826 [image!], K-000912827 [image!], MO-2151483 [image!], MO-2151484[image!], UC-38998 [image!].
Stipa bracteata Swallen, J. Wash. Acad. Sci. 30(5): 213. 1940 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum bracteatum (Swallen) Valdés-Reyna & Barkworth, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 48: 15. 2003. Type: Mexico, Baja California, collected on grassy flats 25 mi N of Ensenada, 4 Apr 1931, I.L. Wiggins 5153 (holotype: US-1721797!; isotypes: CAS-0004680 [image!], CAS-0004681 [image!], GH-00024475 [image!].
Oryzopsis hymenoides var. contracta B.L. Johnson, Bot. Gaz. 107: 24. 1945 [Basionym] ≡ Oryzopsis contracta (B.L. Johnson) Y. Schechter, Brittonia 18: 342. 1967 ≡ Stipa contracta (B.L. Johnson) W.A. Weber, Phytologia 67(6): 428. 1989, nom. illeg. hom., non Stipa contracta Phil. ≡ Achnatherum contractum (B.L. Johnson) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 6. 1993. Type: USA, Wyoming, Carbon Co., Freezeout Hills, E. Nelson 4850 (holotype: RM-0000328 [image!].
Stipa coronata Thurb., Bot. California 2: 287–288. 1880 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum coronatum (Thurb.) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 6. 1993. Type: USA, California, San Diego Co., in a cañon around springs on hillside near Julian City, Apr 1872, H.N. Bolander, A. Kellogg & co. s.n. (lectotype: US-745776 [accession no.!] & US-00406146 [image!] designated here; isolectotypes: GH-00017898 [image!], MO-2151562 [image!], MO-2151563 [image!], MO-2151564 [image!]).
Stipa curvifolia Swallen, J. Wash. Acad. Sci. 23(10): 456. 1933 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum curvifolium (Swallen) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 7. 1993. Type: USA, New Mexico, Eddy Co., Guadalupe Mountains, in crevices of limestone cliff near mouth of North Fork of Rocky Arroyo, 29 Apr 1932, H. Wilkens 1660 (holotype: US-1538063!; isotype: PH-00028074 [image!]).
Oryzopsis hendersonii Vasey, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 1(8): 267 [Basionym] ≡ Oryzopsis exigua var. hendersonii (Vasey) M.E. Jones, Contr. W. Bot. 14: 11. 1912 ≡ Stipa hendersonii (Vasey) Mehlenb., Canad. J. Bot. 49(9): 1568. 1971 ≡ Achnatherum hendersonii (Vasey) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 7. 1993. 1893. Type: USA, Washington, North Yakima, Clements Mountain, 1892, L.F. Henderson 2249 (holotype: US-81978!).
Stipa hymenoides
Roem. & Schult., Syst. Veg. 2: 339. 1817 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa membranacea Pursh, Fl. Amer. Sept. II: 728. 1814 nom. illeg., non Stipa membranacea L. ≡ Oryzopsis membranacea Vasey, U.S.D.A. Div. Bot. Bull. 12(2): 10, t. 10. 1891, nom. illeg. superfl. ≡ Eriocoma membranacea (Vasey) Beal, Grass. N. Amer. 2: 232. 1896, nom. illeg. superfl. ≡ Oryzopsis hymenoides (Roem. & Schult.) Ricker ex Piper, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 11: 109. 1906 ≡ Achnatherum hymenoides (Roem. & Schult.) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 7–8. 1993. Type: USA, on the banks of the Missouri River, J. Bradbury no. 12 (lectotype: K-000912825 [image!] designated here; isolectotype: PH-00008181 [image!]). Fig.
= Eriocoma cuspidata Nutt., Gen. N. Amer. Pl. 1: 40. 1818 ≡ Milium cuspidatum (Nutt.) Spreng., Syst. Veg. 1: 251. 1824 ≡ Urachne lanata Trin. & Rupr., Mem. Acad. Imp. Sci. Saint-Petersbourg, Ser. 6, Sci. Math., Seconde Pt. Sci. Nat. 3,1(2–3): 126. 1834, nom. Illeg. superfl. ≡ Eriocoma membranacea Steud., Nomencl. Bot. (ed 2) 1: 586. 1840, nom. inval., as syn. of Urachne lanata Trin. ≡ Oryzopsis cuspidata (Nutt.) Benth. ex Vasey, Grass. U.S. 23. 1883. Type: USA, Platte Plains, T. Nuttall s.n. (lectotype: BM-001042144 [image!]) designated here; isolectotype: LE-TRIN 1466.01 ex PH!).
= Fendleria rhynchelytroides Steud., Syn. Pl. Glumac. 1: 420. 1854. Type: USA, New Mexico, near Santa Fe, 1847, A. Fendler 979 (lectotype: P-01941338 [image!] designated here ; isolectotypes: GH-00023719 [image!], K-000912824 [image!], NY [image!], S14-1154 [image!], US-823154 [image!], W-0029207 [image!], W-0029208 [image!], W-18890236595 [image!].
Stipa latiglumis Swallen, J. Wash. Acad. Sci. 23(4): 198, f. 1. 1933 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum latiglume (Swallen) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 8. 1993. Type: USA, California, Yosemite Valley, Camp Lost Arrow, 4000–4500 ft, 22 Jun 1911, L. Abrams 4469 (holotype: US-992334!; isotype: US-59760!).
Stipa pringlei var. lemmonii Vasey, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 3(1): 55. 1892 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa lemmonii (Vasey) Scribn., Circ. Div. Agrostol. U.S.D.A. 30: 3. 1901 ≡ Achnatherum lemmonii (Vasey) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 8. 1993. Type: USA, California, Plumas Co., Mohawk Valley, May 1889, J.G. Lemmon 5456 (holotype: US-556900!).
= Stipa columbiana Macoun, Cat. Canad. Pl. 2(4): 191. 1888, nom. utique rej. under International Code of Botanical Nomenclature (ICBN 1988) Art. 56.1, (see ICNAFP 2018 - Appendix V; also
Stipa lemmonii var. pubescens Crampton, Leafl. W. Bot. 7(9): 220. 1955 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum lemmonii subsp. pubescens (Crampton) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 8. 1993. Type: USA, California, Tehama Co., Whitlock Camp, Round Mt. area west of Paskenta, 4000 ft, 16 Jul 1954, B. Crampton 2000 (holotype: AHUC-21077 [image!]; isotypes: AHUC-21078 [image!], CAS-0005669 [image!], US-2152024!).
= Stipa lemmonii var. jonesii Scribn., Bull. Div. Agrostol., U.S.D.A. 30: 4. 1901. Type: USA, California:, Emigrant Gap, 28 Jun 1882, M.E. Jones 3298 (holotype: US-556899! [US-00141633 image!]; isotypes: BR-0000006884598 [image!], CAS-0005668 [image!], GH-00017900 [image!], MO-2151560 [image!], NY-00431560 [image!]), POM-116527).
Stipa lettermanii Vasey, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 13: 53. 1886 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa viridula var. lettermanii (Vasey) Vasey, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 3(1): 50. 1892 ≡ Achnatherum lettermanii (Vasey) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 9. 1993. Type: USA, Idaho, Snake River, Aug 1885, G.W. Letterman 102 (lectotype: US-556904! designated by Hitchcock, Manual. Grass. US ed. 1, 964. 1935 as to the collection no. 102, Barkworth & Maze identifed the US specimen number, Taxon 31(2): 294 f. 6. 1982).
= Stipa viridula var. minor Vasey, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 3(1): 50. 1892 ≡ Stipa occidentalis var. minor (Vasey) C.L. Hitchc., Vasc. Pl. Pacific NW 1: 714. 1969 ≡ Stipa minor (Vasey) Scribn., Bull. Div. Agrostol., U.S.D.A. 11: 46–47. 1898. Type: USA, Colorado, Kelso Mountain near Torrey’s Peak, 13000 ft, 13 Aug 1885, G.W. Letterman 95 (lectotype: US-556903! designated by Hitchcock, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 24(7): 253. 1925).
Stipa lobata
Swallen, J. Wash. Acad. Sci. 23(10): 199, f. 2. 1933 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum lobatum (Swallen) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 9. 1993. Type: USA, New Mexico, Guadalupe Co., Queen, Guadalupe Mts., on a rocky hill, Ranger Station, 6000–7000 ft, 3–6 Sep 1915, A. S. Hitchcock 13502 (holotype: US-905722!). Fig.
Stipa nelsonii Scribn., Bull. Div. Agrostol., U.S.D.A. 11: 46. 1898 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa columbiana var. nelsonii (Scribn.) Hitchc., Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 24(7): 254. 1925 ≡ Stipa columbiana var. nelsonii (Scribn.) H. St. John, Fl. S.-E. Washington 61. 1937 ≡ Stipa occidentalis var. nelsonii (Scribn.) C.L. Hitchc., Vasc. Pl. Pacific NW 1: 715. 1969 ≡ Achnatherum nelsonii (Scribn.) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 9. 1993. Type: USA, Wyoming, Albany Co., Woods Landing, 2600 m, 9 Aug 1898, A. Nelson 3963 (lectotype: US-556901! designated by Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 9. 1993; isolectotype: MPU-026968 [image!]).
= Stipa williamsii Scribn., Bull. Div. Agrostol., U.S.D.A. 11: 45–46, t. 4. 1898. Type: USA, Wyoming, dry soil on W side of Big Horn Mt., near Monument Spring, 2200–2400 m, 3 Aug 1897, T.A. Williams 2804 (lectotype: US-556907! & US-00141714 [image!] designated here, partially lectotypified by Hitchcock, N. Amer. Fl., part 6. 422. 1935).
Stipa nelsonii subsp. dorei Barkworth & J. Maze, Taxon 28(5/6): 623 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa nelsonii var. dorei (Barkworth & J. Maze) Dorn, Vasc. Pl. Wyoming 298. 1988 ≡ Achnatherum nelsonii subsp. dorei (Barkworth & J. Maze) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 9. 1993. 1979. Type: Canada, Alberta, Dungarvan Creek, W.G. Dore 12136 (holotype: DAO-000465415 [image!]).
Stipa nevadensis B.L. Johnson, Amer. J. Bot. 49: 257. 1962 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum nevadense (B.L. Johnson) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 9. 1993. Type: USA, California, Mono Co., Upper Twin Lake, near Bridgeport, 7096 ft, 29 Aug 1960, B.L. Johnson 211 (holotype: UC-1936202 [image!]; isotypes: ARIZ-BOT-0005299[image!], DAV-181068 [image!], SD-00000116 [image!]).
Stipa occidentalis Thurb. ex S. Watson, Botany (Fortieth Parallel) 380. 1871 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa stricta var. sparsiflora Vasey, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 3(1): 51. 1892 ≡ Stipa occidentalis var. montana Merr. & Davy, Univ. Calif. Publ. Bot. 1: 62. 1902, nom. illeg. superfl. Achnatherum occidentale (Thurb. ex S. Watson) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 10. 1993 ≡ Type: USA, California, Yosemite Trail, 8000 ft, 20 Aug 1866, H.N. Bolander 5038 (lectotype: GH-22338! designated by Hitchcock, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 24(7): 242. 1925; isolectotypes: BM-000797606 [image], G-00176505 [image!], MO-2151636 [image!], NY-00431565 [image!], NY-00431567 [image!], US-3441781, US-992306 ex GH!, US-745821!, W-18890217496 [image!], YU-244757 [image!]).
= Stipa stricta Vasey, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 10: 42. 1883, nom. illeg. hom. non S. stricta Lam. ≡ Stipa oregonensis Scribn., Bull. Div. Agrostol., U.S.D.A. 17: 130, f. 426. 1899. Type: USA, “Oregon” [but from Washington, which became a state in 1889], 1882, W.N. Suksdorf s.n. (holotype: US-556921!).
Stipa californica Merr. & Burtt Davy, Univ. Calif. Publ. Bot. 1: 61. 1902 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa occidentalis var. californica (Merr. & Burtt Davy) C.L. Hitchc., Vasc. Pl. Pacific NW 1: 715. 1969 ≡ Achnatherum occidentale subsp. californicum (Merr. & Burtt Davy) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 10. 1993. Type: USA, California, San Jacinto Mts., north side of Fullers Ridge, 2100 m, Jul 1901, H.M. Hall 2556 (holotype: unknown; isotypes: CAS-0005660 [image!], US-556911!).
= Stipa nelsonii var. longiaristata Barkworth & J. Maze, Taxon 28(5/6): 623. 1979 ≡ Achnatherum nelsonii subsp. longiaristatum (Barkworth & J. Maze) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 9. 1993. Type: USA, Washington, 8–9 mi W of Spokane, 19 Jun 1940, J.S. Swallen 6231 (holotype: DAO-000465413 [image!]; isotype: US-2303647!).
Stipa viridula var. pubescens Vasey, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 3(1): 50. 1892 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa elmeri Piper & Brodie ex Scribn., Bull. Div. Agrostol., U.S.D.A. 11: 46. 1898 ≡ Stipa occidentalis var. pubescens (Vasey) J. Maze, Roy L. Taylor & MacBryde, Canad. J. Bot. 56(2): 193. 1978 ≡ Achnatherum occidentale subsp. pubescens (Vasey) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 10. 1993. Type: USA, Washington, on dry ground along the Columbia River, 1883, W.N. Suksdorf s.n. (lectotype: US-79560! [US-00036944 image!], designated by Hitchcock, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 24(7): 241. 1925; isolectotype: GH-00443467 [image!]).
Stipa parishii Vasey, Bot. Gaz. 7(3): 33. 1882 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa coronata var. parishii (Vasey) Hitchc., Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 24: 227, t. 50, f. 13. 1925 ≡ Achnatherum parishii (Vasey) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 11. 1993. Type: USA, California, San Berardino Mts., Aug 1881, S.B. Parish & W.F. Parish 1079 (lectotype: US-556918! & US-00406147 [image!] designated by Hitchcock, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 24(7): 227. 1925).
Stipa parishii var. depauperata M.E. Jones, Contr. W. Bot. 14: 11. 1912 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa coronata var. depauperata (M.E. Jones) Hitchc., J. Wash. Acad. Sci. 24(7): 292. 1934 ≡ Achnatherum parishii subsp. depauperatum (M.E. Jones) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 11. 1993. Type: USA, Utah, Detroit, 25 May 1891, M.E. Jones s.n. (holotype: RSA-0000500 [image!]; isotype: US-83026!).
Achnatherum perplexum Hoge & Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 11. 1993 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa perplexa (Hoge & Barkworth) Wipff & S.D. Jones, Phytologia 77(6): 461. 1995. Type: USA, New Mexico, Bernalillo Co., Cibola National Forest, 1.5 mi E of USFS road 413, 9 mi S of Tijeres on NM 14, 8 Sep 1985, M.E. Barkworth 4764 (holotype: US-3239133!; isotype: RSA-0000391 [image!]).
Stipa pinetorum
M.E. Jones, Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci., ser. 2, 5: 724. 1895 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum pinetorum (M.E. Jones) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 12. 1993. Type: USA, Utah, Panguitch Lake, 8400 ft, growing in open places among the pine forests, 8 Sep 1894, M.E. Jones 6023 (holotype: RSA-0000501 [image!]); isotype: US-236788!). Fig.
Stipa richardsonii Link, Enum. Pl. 2: 245. 1833 [Basionym] ≡ Oryzopsis richardsonii (Link) Beal, Bot. Gaz. 15(5)12: 111. 1890 ≡ Achnatherum richardsonii (Link) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 12. 1993. Type: Habitat in America boreali occidental, cultivated in Hortus Berolensis from seed sent by Richardson (lectotype: LE-TRIN-1436.01 fragm. ex B! designated here).
Stipa viridula var. robusta
Vasey, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 1(2): 56. 1890 [Basionym] ≡ Stipa robusta (Vasey) Scribn., Bull. Div. Agrostol., U.S.D.A. 5: 23. 1897 ≡ Stipa vaseyi Scribn., Bull. Div. Agrostol., U.S.D.A. 11: 46. 1898, nom. illeg. superfl. ≡ Achnatherum robustum (Vasey) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 12. 1993. Type: USA, New Mexico, 1881, G.R. Vasey s.n. (conserved type: US-993051!). Fig.
Stipa scribneri Vasey, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 11: 125. 1884 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum scribneri (Vasey) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 13. 1993. Type: USA, New Mexico, Santa Fe Co., Santa Fe, collected on dry hillsides, Aug 1884, G.R. Vasey s.n. (lectotype: US-556905! & US-00141676 [image!] designated by Barkworth in Phytologia 74(1): 13. 1993; isolectotypes: K-000873388 [image!], MO-2151550 [image!], MSC-0092941 [image!], NY-00431574 [image!], PH-00028089 [image!], US-84603!, W-19160026444 [image!]).
Oryzopsis swallenii C.L. Hitchc. & Spellenb., Brittonia 20: 164. 1968 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum swallenii (C.L. Hitchc. & Spellenb.) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 14. 1993. Type: USA, Idaho, Clark Co., just N of Birch Creek, along Hwy. 28, near the Lemhi Co. line, 7 Jul 1965, C.L. Hitchcock 23868 (holotype: WTU-227273 & WTU-V-000041[image!]; isotypes: CAS-0006990 [image!], COLO-00391284 [image!], DAV-38298 [image!], DAO-000465414 [image!], F-0046857F [image!], G-00176562 [image!], GH-00024084 [image!], ID-00157718 [image!], NCU-00000362 [image!], NY-00381560 [image!], OSC-0001820 [image!], RM-0000329 [image!], RSA-0000458 [image!], TEX-00370123 [image!], UBC-V116845 [image!], US-3465271!, V-047552 [image!]).
Stipa thurberiana Piper, Circ. Div. Agrostol. U.S.D.A. 27: 10. 1900, nom. nov [Basionym] ≡ Stipa occidentalis Thurb., U.S. Expl. Exped. 17: 483. 1874 non. Stipa occidentalis Thurb. ex S. Watson ≡ Achnatherum thurberianum (Piper) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 14. 1993. Type: USA, Washington, North Branch of the Columbia River, C. Pickering & W. D. Brackenridge s.n. (holotype: GH-00017772 [image!]).
Achnatherum wallowaense J. Maze & K. Robson, Madrono 43(3): 401, f. 1–2. 1996 [Basionym]. Type: USA, Oregon, Wallowa Co., Wallowa-Whitman National Forest, ca. 34 km N of Enterprise, near Boner Gulch along Forest Service road, 46, 45°43'41.16"N, 117°08'10.32"W (SW 1/4 of SE 1/4, sect 24, T3N, R45E), 1481 m, 26 Jun 1993, J. Maze, E. Maze, K.A. Robson & T. Henn 1007 (holotype: US-3323518!; isotypes: COLO-00339663 [image!], DAV-126946 [image!], DAV-128405 [image!], ID-00157713 [image!], MO-128384 [image!], NCU-00012752 [image!], NY-00039022 [image!], UBC-V209875 [image!]).
Eriocoma webberi Thurb., Bot. California 2: 283–284. 1880 [Basionym] ≡ Oryzopsis webberi (Thurb.) Benth. ex Vasey, Grass. U.S. 23. 1883 ≡ Stipa webberi (Thurb.) B.L. Johnson, Bot. Gaz. 107: 25. 1945 ≡ Achnatherum webberi (Thurb.) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 14. 1993. Type: USA, California, Sierra Valley, 1 May 1871, H.N. Bolander, A. Kellogg & co. s.n. (holotype: GH-00024083 [image!]; isotypes: MO-2151485[image!], NY-00381032 [image!], US-81935!).
Eriocoma Nutt. × Nassella (Trin.) E. Desv. Type: ×Eriosella caduca (Beal) Romasch. (≡ Oryzopsis caduca Beal)
Plants perennial, cespitose, not rhizomatous. Culms up to 90 cm tall, nodes glabrous. Leaf sheaths mostly glabrous, margins sparsely ciliate, hairs longer apically; collars glabrous or with tufts of hairs; ligules 0.5–1.7 mm long, scarious, glabrous, apex truncate to obtuse; blades 1–3.5 mm wide, flat to convolute when dry, apices narrowly acute; basal blades to 40 cm long; flag blades longer than 10 cm. Panicles 15–18 cm long, narrow, branches ascending. Spikelets 6–8.5 mm long, fusiform, with one fertile floret without rachilla extension, disarticulation above the glumes; glumes 6–8.5 mm long, longer than the florets, saccate-lanceolate, 3–5-veined, apices attenuate from about the middle; upper glumes slightly narrower than the lower; florets 4–5 mm long, fusiform; calluses about 0.7 mm long, blunt; lemmas 7-veined, coriaceous, evenly hairy throughout, the hairs 1–2 mm long, apex minutely lobed; lemmatal awns 9–16 mm long, twisted, straight or 1-geniculate, readily deciduous, lower portion scabrous and without hairs; paleas 2.5–3.3 mm long, 2/3–3/4 as long as the lemma, hairy; stamens 2, anthers 1.2–2.3 mm long, variable in length within the floret, 2 in number indehiscent, penicillate, with only a few apical hairs. Caryopses not seen.
The name, ×Eriosella, is a combination of the prefix ‘Erio’ from Eriocoma and the suffix ‘sella’ from Nassella.
Known only from Montana, North Dakota, and western Wyoming (
Oryzopsis caduca Beal, Bot. Gaz. 15(5): 111. 1890 [Basionym] ≡ Eriocoma caduca (Beal) Rydb., Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 1: 25. 1900 ≡ Stipa caduca (Beal) Scribn., Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 3(1): 54. 1892 ≡ ×Stiporyzopsis caduca (Beal) B.L. Johnson & Rogler, Amer. J. Bot. 30: 55, f. 10, 14, 28–33. 1943 ≡ ×Achnella caduca (Beal) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 15. 1993. Type: USA, Montana, Belt Mts., Sixteen Mile Cr., 11 Jul 1883, F.L. Scribner s.n. (holotype: US-745838!).
×Eriosella caduca is thought to be a hybrid between Eriocoma hymenoides and Nassella viridula. It can be separated from E. hymenoides in having shorter hairs on the lemma and panicles with ascending branches (not divergent), and from N. viridula in having longer lemma hairs, paleas 2/3–3/4 as long as the lemma, and readily deciduous lemmatal awns (
Achnatherum sect. Neotrinia Tzvelev, Novosti Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 9: 55. 1972.
Neotrinia splendens (Trin.) M. Nobis, P. Gudkova & A. Nowak (≡ Stipa splendens Trin.).
Plants perennial, cespitose, robust, not rhizomatous with intravaginal branching. Culms 40–250 cm tall, 2–5 mm thick below with 3–7 nodes, glabrous, smooth. Leaf sheaths glabrous, becoming fibrous below, margins ciliate, striate; collars glabrous; ligules membranous, glabrous; basal ligules 1–2.5 mm long, apex truncate to obtuse; upper ligules 2.5–12 mm long, apex acute; blades 20–60 cm long, 2–7 (–10) mm wide, flat or involute, deeply grooved, glabrous, abaxial surface smooth, adaxial surface scabrous. Panicles 15–50 cm long, (4–) 8–35 cm wide, ovate; ascending branches up to 15 cm long, crowded or loosely spreading, whorled at most nodes. Spikelets 4–7 (–8.5) mm long, lanceolate, subterete with one fertile floret without rachilla extension; disarticulation above the glumes; glumes 2.5–6.5 mm long, subequal, membranous, (1–) 3–5-veined, without keels; lower glumes 2.5–4.4 mm long, shorter than the upper, 1 (–3)-veined, margins hyaline; upper glumes 4–6.5 mm long, 3–5-veined, apex acute; florets 4.2–7.2 mm long; calluses 0.3–0.5 mm long, elliptic, bearded; lemmas 4.2–7.2 mm long, evenly hairy, the hairs up to 1.5 mm long, apex 2-lobed, the lobes 0.5–1.3 mm long; lemma epidermal pattern saw-like; fundamental cells of variable length with lobate sidewalls 3–10 times longer than silica cells, irregularly alternating; silica bodies round, paired with crescent-shaped cork cells; lemmatal awns 5–12 mm long, straight or indistinctly 1-geniculate, slightly twisted and flexuous; paleas about as long or slightly shorter than the lemmas, 2-veined, hairy; stamens 3, anthers 3.5–4.5 mm long, penicillate, yellow; lodicules 3; stigmas 2; ovary glabrous. Caryopses 2–4 mm long, fusiform, pericarp adherent, hilum linear. Chromosome number 2n = 42, 46, 48 (
Stipa splendens
Trin., Neue Entdeck. Pflanzenk. 2: 54. 1821 [Basionym] ≡ Agrostis longiaristata Herb. in Ross. ex Kunth, Enum. Pl. 1: 178. 1833, nom. illeg. ≡ Lasiagrostis splendens (Trin.) Kunth, Révis. Gramin. 1: 58. 1829 ≡ Achnatherum splendens (Trin.) Nevski, Trudy Bot. Inst. Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R., Ser. 1, Fl. Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 4: 224. 1937. Type: Russia, Transbaicalia, Siberia, Fischer et Steven s.n. (holotype: LE-TRIN1444.1!). Fig.
The single species, Neotrinia splendens, is native to Asia in Afghanistan, India, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, China, Mongolia, Pakistan, Russia, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan (
Psammochloa villosa (Trin.) Bor is sister to Neotrinia splendens in our earlier molecular phylogeny (BS = 100, PP = 1.00) and both species share the following morphological features: basal fibrous sheaths, panicles with whorled primary branches arising from the rachis, (1–) 3–5-veined glumes with hyaline margins, short, obtuse to elliptic calluses, and evenly hairy lemmas with flexuous cauducous awns that arise between the apical teeth (
As noted by
Oloptum miliaceum (L.) Röser & H.R. Hamasha (≡ Agrostis miliacea L.).
Plants perennial, loosely cespitose, not rhizomatous with extravaginal branching. Culms 50‒150 cm tall, erect or geniculate ascending, glabrous, often branching at lower cauline nodes. Leaf sheaths glabrous, persistent, margins hyaline above, smooth; ligules membranous; basal ligules 0.5‒1.5 mm long, apex truncate; upper ligules 1.5‒4 mm long, apex obtuse to acute; blades (5‒) 10‒30 cm long, 2‒10 mm wide, flat, glabrous, smooth or scaberulous, margins scaberulous, apex attenuate. Panicles 10‒40 cm long, 3‒15 (‒18) cm wide, ovate, open; lower branches 3‒8 cm long, ascending and spreading, whorled, 3‒8 at a node or with 15‒30 or more at the lowest node, these often with sterile spikelets. Spikelets 2.5‒3.5 mm long, elliptic, dorsally compressed with one fertile floret without rachilla extension; disarticulation above the glumes; glumes subequal, longer than the florets, 3-veined without transverse veinlets, membranous, apices acuminate; florets 2‒2.5 mm long, chartaceous; calluses about 0.3 mm long, with non-grooved circular disarticulation scar, glabrous; lemmas with narrow open borders, central vein not grooved, apex awned, the awns 3‒5 mm long, flexuous, cauducous; lemma epidermal pattern maize-like; fundamental cells elongated with straight thin sidewalls 3–7 times longer than silica cells, irregularly alternating; silica bodies round; cork cells crescent-shaped scarce to absent; paleas about as long as the lemma, coriaceous, 2-veined; stamens 3, anthers 2‒2.5 mm long, penicillate; lodicules 3; stigmas 2; ovary glabrous. Caryopses 1.5‒1.7 mm long, fusiform, pericarp adherent, hilum linear about ½ as long as the caryopsis. Chromosome number 2n = 24 (
Agrostis mileacea
L., Sp. Pl. 1: 61. 1753 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum miliaceum (L.) P. Beauv., Ess. Agrostogr. 20, 146, 148. 1812 ≡ Urachne miliacea (L.) K. Koch, Linnaea 21(4): 439. 1848 ≡ Piptatherum miliaceum (L.) Coss., Notes Pl. Crit. 129. 1851 ≡ Oryzopsis miliacea (L.) Benth. & Hook. ex Asch. & Schweinf., Mém. Inst. Égypte 2: 169. 1887 ≡ Stipa miliacea (L.) Hoover, Leafl. W. Bot. 10(16): 340. 1966. Type: Sweden, Uppsala, Anon. s.n. (lectotype: LINN-HL84-2 [image!] designated by R.D. Meikle, Fl. Cyprus 2: 1794. 1985). Fig.
Oloptum miliaceum is native to Europe, particularly the whole Mediterranean region, from northern Africa, Sinai to Western Asia (Arabian Peninsula, Cyprus, Egypt, Iraq, Iran, Israel, Jordan, Lebanon, Palestinian territories, Syria, and Turkey) [
The unique morphological features of this taxon (glabrous lemma with a central vein not grooved, 3-veined glumes without transverse veinlets, and a callus with a circular disarticulation scar) were first recognized by
Traditionally, two subspecies have been recognized. Oloptum miliaceum subsp. thomasii (Duby) Boiss. differs from the typical form in having densely verticillate panicles with 15‒30 or more often sterile branches on the lowest whorl (
Pseudoeriocoma eminens (Cav.) Romasch. (≡ Stipa eminens Cav.)
Pseudoeriocoma differs from Eriocoma Nutt. in having bamboo-like culms commonly with up to 13 nodes, 3–6 mm thick below, with ramified branching at the middle and upper nodes.
Plants perennial, cespitose, usually short rhizomatous from a knotty base. Culms 30–230 (often over 100) cm tall, erect or ascending, often geniculate, 3–6 mm thick and often woody and bamboo-like below with ramified and branching at the middle and upper nodes, with (2) 3–13 nodes, internodes glabrous or hairy. Leaf sheaths shorter than the internodes above to shorter or longer below, glabrous, pubescent or hirsute, sometimes ciliate on the margins and summit; collars glabrous or with a tuft of hairs; ligules 0.5–8 mm long, hyaline to membranous, apex truncate to acute or obtuse, often lacerate; blades (1.5–) 5–40 cm long, 1–4 mm wide, flat to tightly involute or convolute, glabrous or pubescent, usually scabrous. Panicles 8–45 (–55) cm long, usually rather narrow and less than 8.5 cm wide, loosely or densely flowered, branches ascending to spreading and naked near base; pedicles longer than the spikelets. Spikelets 8–15 mm long, lanceolate with one fertile floret without rachilla extension; disarticulation above the glumes; glumes (4–) 6–15 mm long, longer than the florets, subequal or unequal, hyaline to membranous, 1–7-veined, glabrous, acuminate; florets 4–7 mm long, usually fusiform; calluses 0.2–2 long, sharp, hairy; lemmas 4–7 mm long, fusiform, coriaceous, evenly hairy, the hairs 0.4–2 mm long, margins enveloping most of the palea, apex entire and awned; lemma epidermal pattern maize-like; fundamental cells squared, longitudinally compressed with straight thin sidewalls subequal to silica cells (silica bodies) or shorter, regularly alternating; cork cells absent; lemmatal awns 20–80 mm long, 2-geniculate, flexuous, the segments scabrous or pubescent; paleas 1–4.6 mm long, 1/3 to ¾ as long as the lemmas, 2-veined, veins not prolonged, hairy; anthers 2.5–4 mm long, penicillate or not, 3 in number, lodicules 2 or 3; stigmas 2. Caryopses 3–4 mm long, fusiform, pericarp adherent, hilum linear.
There are six species of Pseudoeriocoma occurring in southwestern North America (Mexico and USA). These species generally occur on steep rock outcrops in xerophytic vegetation; pinyon, pine, pine-oak woodlands, and spruce-fir forests; 600–3000 m (
Within our preliminary molecular analyses of Pseudoeriocoma there are two clades each of P. constricta, P. eminens, and P. multinodis that require further study, and at least three species currently placed in Jarava from South America that align within Pseudoeriocoma (
Stipa acuta Swallen, J. Wash. Acad. Sci. 30(5): 212. 1940 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum acutum (Swallen) Valdés-Reyna & Barkworth, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 48: 15. 2003. Type: Mexico, Coahuila, on rocky soil on Carneras Pass, 21 mi S of Saltillo, 1 Sep 1938, F. Shreve 8545 (holotype: US-1760238!; isotype: ARIZ-BOT-0004856 [image!]).
Stipa constricta Hitchc., Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 24(7): 244, t. 51, f. 28–29. 1925 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum constrictum (Hitchc.) Valdés-Reyna & Barkworth, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 48: 15. 2003. Type: Mexico, Hidalgo, Pachuca, collected on a rocky hill at 2400 m alt., 7 Sep 1910, A.S. Hitchcock 6742 (holotype: US-993345!; isotype: NY-00431580 [image!]).
Stipa editorum E. Fourn., Mexic. Pl. 2: 75. 1886 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum editorum (E. Fourn.) Valdés-Reyna & Barkworth, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 48: 16. 2003. Type: Mexico, in valle edita inter La Noria del Viejo et La Miquiguana, W.F. von Karwinski 1009c (holotype: P; isotypes: KFTA-0002846 [image!], US-866119A! fragm. ex P).
Stipa eminens Cav., Icon. 5: 42, t. 467, f. 1. 1799 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum eminens (Cav.) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 7. 1993. Type: Mexico, Chalma, L. Née s.n. (holotype: MA-656523: isotype: US-866118!).
= Stipa erecta E. Fourn., Mexic. Pl. 2: 75. 1886, nom. illeg. hom., non Stipa erecta Trin. ≡ Stipa erecta E. Fourn., Biol. Cent.-Amer., Bot. 3: 536. 1885. nom. nud. Type: Mexico, Tehuacán, Dec, F.M. Liebmann 654 (holotype: C-10017241 [image!]; isotype: US-866117! fragm. ex C).
= Stipa flexuosa Vasey, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 15: 49. 1888. Type: USA, western Texas, Chenate Mountains, 1887, G.C. Nealley s.n. (holotype: US-556913!; isotypes: NY-00431557 [image!], W-19160022725 [image!]). Fig.
Stipa hirticulmis S.L. Hatch, Valdés-Reyna & Morden, Syst. Bot. 11(1): 186–188, f. 1. 1986 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum hirticulme (S.L. Hatch, Valdés-Reyna & Morden) Valdés-Reyna & Barkworth, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 48: 16. 2003. Type: Mexico, Nuevo León, 8 mi E of San Roberto Jct. along Hwy. 58 on the road to Galeana, 24°40'N, 100°14'W, 1890 m, 22 Aug 1983, S. Hatch & J. Valdés Reyna 5007 (holotype: TAES; isotypes: ANSM-028729 [image!], CHAPA-0000220 [image!], ENCB-003270 [image!], MEXU-00415572 [image!], MO-123113 [image!], NY-00431581 [image!], TEX-00370148 [image!], US-3037668!).
Stipa multinodis Scribn. ex Beal, Grass. N. Amer. 2: 222. 1896 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum multinode (Scribn. ex Beal) Valdés-Reyna & Barkworth, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 48: 17. 2003. Type: Mexico, Chihuahua, Santa Eulalia Mountains, 14 Aug 1885, C.G. Pringle 385 (holotype: MSC-0092939 [image!]; isotypes: AC-00320221 [image!], BM-000938477 [image!], BR-0000006884895 [image!], JE-00001162 [image!], G-00168339 [image!], G-00168541 [image!], G-00168542 [image!], G-00168543 [image!], GH-00024478 [image!], K-000433421 [image!], KFTA-0000585 [image!], MO-123114 [image!], MO-123115 [image!], MO-5114652, NY-00431585 [image!], NY-00431586 [image!], NY-00431587 [image!], US-90985!, US-155154!, US-825176!, W-19160026109 [image!]).
Ptilagrostiella kingii (Bol.) Romasch. (≡ Stipa kingii Bol.).
Ptilagrostiella differs from Piptatheropsis Romasch., P.M. Peterson & Soreng in having glumes without veins with obtuse apices, a sharp callus, and laterally compressed florets with lemma margins overlapping most of the palea at maturity; and differs from Ptilagrostis Griseb. in having a sharp-pointed callus and lemmatal awns with very short hairs.
Plants perennial, cespitose, not rhizomatous with intravaginal branching. Culms 15–40 cm tall, 0.4–0.8 mm in diameter, erect, glabrous, not branching above. Leaf sheaths open, glabrous to scaberulous; ligules 1–2.5 mm long, membranous, apex obtuse to acute; blades 3–15 cm long, 0.3–0.5 mm wide, convolute, filiform, flexuous. Panicles 4–10 cm long, loosely contracted; branches ascending and usually appressed. Spikelets 3–4.5 mm long, lanceolate with one fertile floret without rachilla extension; disarticulation above the glumes; glumes 3–4.5 mm long, usually longer than the florets, hyaline, without veins, apex obtuse; florets 2.8–4.2 mm long, laterally compressed; calluses 0.3–0.7 mm long, sharp, hairy; lemmas 2.8–4.2 mm long, membranous to chartaceous, evenly pubescent throughout, the hairs 0.3–0.5 mm long, margins overlapping most of the palea at maturity, apex 2-lobed, the lobes 0.1–0.4 mm long, awned; lemma epidermal pattern saw-like; fundamental cells of variable length with sinuous sidewalls 2–8 times longer than silica cells irregularly alternating; silica bodies elongated-rectangular, sometimes paired with square-shaped cork cells; lemmatal awns 10–14 mm long, strigillose in lower part; 1- or 2-geniculate, persistent; paleas 2.6–3.2 mm long, shorter to about as long as the lemma, chartaceous, 2-veined; stamens 3, anthers 0.5–1.5 mm long, penicillate; lodicules 3, membranous; stigmas 2; ovary glabrous. Caryopses 1.5–2.3 mm long, fusiform, pericarp adherent. Chromosome number 2n = 22 (
Stipa kingii
Bol., Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci. 4: 170. 1872 [Basionym] ≡ Oryzopsis kingii (Bol.) Beal, Grass. N. Amer. 2: 229. 1896 ≡ Ptilagrostis kingii (Bol.) Barkworth, Syst. Bot. 8(4): 417. 1983. Type: USA, California, Tuolumne Co., Mt. Dana and Toulumne Meadows, 7000–12000 ft, Sep 1866, H.N. Bolander 6097 (lectotype: CAS-0005666 [image!] designated by M.E. Barkworth, Syst. Bot. 8: 417. 1983; isolectotypes: BM-001042147 [image!], F-0047023F [image!], G-00176575 [image!], G-00176576 [image!], G-00176577 [image!], GH-00361770 [image!, NY-01785914 [image!], US-81910!, YU-000920 [image!], YU-244788 [image!], W-18890217500 [image!]). Fig.
Ptilagrostiella kingii is endemic to California known only in the Sierra Nevada (Fresno, Inyo, Madera, Mariposa, Mono, Tulare, and Tuolomne counties) and is associated with lodgepole and subalpine forests (
In our earlier molecular analysis, Ptilagrostiella kingii is sister to a well-supported clade of Piptatheropsis (
Thorneochloa diegoensis (Swallen) Romasch. ≡ (Stipa diegoensis Swallen).
Thorneochloa differs from Pseudoeriocoma Romasch., P.M. Peterson & Soreng in having dense pubescence 3–9 mm below the lower nodes, the hairs retrorse, non ramified branching on the middle and upper culms, and pedicels usually shorter than the spikelets.
Plants perennial, cespitose, not rhizomatous. Culms 70–140 cm tall, erect or ascending, often geniculate, 2–4 mm thick never bamboo-like or ramified above with (2) 3 nodes that are densely pubescent 3–9 mm below the lower nodes, the hairs retrorse, internodes usually pubescent. Leaf sheaths longer than the internodes below and shorter than the internodes above, glabrous or pubescent, ciliate on the margins and summit; collars with a tuft of hairs, the hairs 1.5–2 mm long; ligules 1–3 mm long, membranous and pubescent, apex truncate to obtuse; blades 15–40 cm long, 1–3.5 mm wide, flat to involute, scabrous below and pubescent above. Panicles 15–30 cm long, (2–) 4–8 cm wide, narrow, densely flowered, branches ascending appressed; pedicles usually shorter than the spikelets. Spikelets 8–11.5 mm long, lanceolate with one fertile floret without rachilla extension; disarticulation above the glumes; glumes 8–11.5 mm long, longer than the florets, subequal, hyaline, 3–5-veined, glabrous, acuminate; florets 5.5–7.5 mm long, usually fusiform; calluses 0.25–1.2 mm long, sharp, hairy; lemmas 5.5–7.5 mm long, fusiform, coriaceous, evenly hairy, the hairs 0.5–2 mm long, margins enveloping most of the palea, apex awned with minute apical lobes 0.2–0.4 mm long; lemma epidermal pattern maize-like; fundamental cells squared, longitudinally compressed with straight thin sidewalls subequal to silica cells (silica bodies) or shorter, regularly alternating; cork cells absent; lemmatal awns 20–50 mm long, 2-geniculate, flexuous, the segments scabrous, terminal segment straight; paleas 2.6–4 mm long, 1/2 to ¾ as long as the lemmas, 2-veined, veins not prolonged, hairy; anthers 2.5–4 mm long, not penicillate, 3 in number; lodicules 2 or 3; stigmas 2. Caryopses 3.8–4 mm long, fusiform, pericarp adherent, hilum linear, embryo ¼ the length.
The generic name honors Robert Folgers Thorne (1920–2015), an American taxonomist who specialized in the evolution and classification of vascular plants, known as the Thorne system.
Stipa diegoensis
Swallen, J. Wash. Acad. Sci. 30(5): 212, f. 2. 1940 [Basionym] ≡ Achnatherum diegoense (Swallen) Barkworth, Phytologia 74(1): 7. 1993. Type: USA, California, San Diego Co., Proctor Valley near Jamul, along vernal stream in chaparral, 23 May 1938, F. F. Gander 5778 (holotype: US-1761177!; isotypes: AHUC-30095 [image!], CAS-0005662 [image!], DAO-000465418 [image!], F-0044439F [image!], SD-00000072 [image!]). Fig.
Thorneochloa diegoensis is found in Channel Islands (Santa Barbara County), San Diego, and Ventura Counties and Baja California, Mexico in rocky soil along vernal streams and canyons in chaparral and coastal sage-scrub vegetation; usually below 500 m (
Molecular sequence analysis reveals multiple origins of this taxon. In our preliminary ITS-derived phylogenetic tree Thorneochloa diegoensis aligns within Nassella whereas in the combined plastid-derived tree it aligns within Pseudoeriocoma (
1 | Spikelets with 2–6 florets; cultivated as ornamental, a Mediterranean species escaped in California | Ampelodesmos Link* (tribe Ampelodesmeae) |
– | Spikelets with 1 floret (tribe Stipeae); plants native or not | 2 |
2 | Paleas sulcate, longer than the lemmas; lemma margins involute, fitting into the paleal grove; lemma apices not lobed | Piptochaetium |
– | Paleas flat, from shorter than to longer than the lemmas; lemma margins convolute or not overlapping; lemma apices often lobed or bifid | 3 |
3 | Prophylls exceeding the leaf sheaths; lemmas with 2 prominent lobes at apex (0.9–2 mm long); plants cultivated as ornamentals, not escaped | 4 |
– | Prophylls concealed by the leaf sheaths; lemmas with mostly shorter lobed or unlobed apices; plants native, introduced from Mediterranean region, sometimes cultivated as ornamentals | 5 |
4 | Panicles contracted; lemma awns once-geniculate, first segment plumose; style 1 | Macrochloa * |
– | Panicles open; lemma awns twice-geniculate, segments glabrous; styles 2 | Celtica * |
5 | Plants with multiple stiff branches from the upper nodes; pedicels sometimes plumose; Australian species cultivated as ornamentals in the Flora region | Austrostipa* |
– | Plants not branching at the upper nodes, or with a few, flexible branches (Pseudoeriocoma); pedicels never plumose; species native, established introductions, or cultivated as ornamentals | 6 |
6 | Apices of the leaf blade sharp and stiff; caryopses obovoid, often with 3 smooth ribs at maturity; cleistogenes usually present in sheaths; plants adventive in California, native from Mexico southward | Amelichloa |
– | Apices of the leaf blades acute to acuminate, never both sharp and stiff; caryopses fusiform, ovoid or obovoid, without ribs; cleistogenes sometimes present in sheaths | 7 |
7 | Lemma margins strongly overlapping over their whole length at maturity, lemma bodies usually rough throughout, apices with a membranous or indurate crown and not lobed; paleas ¼–½ the length of the lemmas, without veins, glabrous; plants native to North America and southward, South American species sometimes cultivated as ornamentals and escaped | Nassella |
– | Lemma margins usually not or only slightly overlapping for some or all of their length at maturity, strongly overlapping in some species with smooth lemmas, lemma bodies usually smooth on the lower portion, apices often 1–2-lobed and never with a membranous or indurate crown; paleas from 1/3 as long as to equaling or slightly exceeding the lemmas, 2-veined at least on the lower portion, usually with hairs or both lemmas and paleas glabrous | 8 |
8 | Calluses 1.5–6 mm long, sharply pointed; plants perennial or annual, if perennial, awns 65–500 mm long, if annual, awns 50–100 mm long; panicle branches straight | 9 |
– | Calluses 0.1–2 mm long, blunt to sharply pointed; plants perennial; awns 1–70 mm; panicle branches straight or flexuous | 12 |
9 | Lower ligules densely hairy, upper ligules less densely hairy or glabrous; awns plumose in lower segment, glabrous above, unigeniculate; plants perennial | Pappostipa |
– | Ligules glabrous or inconspicuously pubescent, lower and upper ligules alike in vestiture; awns glabrous or pilose throughout or in lower segment; plants perennial or annual | 10 |
10 | Plants perennial; florets 7–25 mm long; awns scabrous or pilose on the first 2 segments, the terminal segment scabrous, or if pilose, the hairs 1–3 mm long | Hesperostipa |
– | Plants annual or perennial, if perennial, the florets 18–27 mm long and the awns plumose on the terminal segment, the hairs 5–6 mm long | 11 |
11 | Plants annual; glumes 12–20 mm long; florets 4–7 mm long; awn sparsely short hairy in basal segment only; plants adventive from Mediterranean, noxious weeds in Southern California | Stipelulla* |
– | Plants perennial (sometimes short-lived); glumes 60–90 cm long; florets 18–27 mm long; the awns plumose on the terminal segment, the hairs 5–6 mm long; plants cultivated ornamentals from Eurasia, not escaped | Stipa* |
12 | Panicles to 60 cm long, delicate, nodding, branches capillary, loosely spreading to spreading in distant whorls; lemmas 2 mm long, coarsely scabrous distally, margins meeting or slightly gapped; callus with a brief ring of hairs; awns caducous, to 8 mm long, slender, scabrous, curved; anther 1, 0.8–1.4 mm long, apically thickened, not penicilliate; plants cultivated ornamentals from New Zealand, not escaped | Anemanthele* |
– | Panicles of various lengths, and shapes (similar in Oloptum, but lemma surfaces smooth, margins widely gapped in middle and fused at base, callus glabrous); lemmas usually longer; awns various; anthers 3, not apically thickened, penicillate or not; plants sometimes cultivated | 13 |
13 | Florets usually dorsally compressed at maturity, sometimes terete; paleas as long as or longer than the lemmas and similar in texture and pubescence; lemma margins separate for their whole length at maturity | 14 |
– | Florets terete or laterally compressed at maturity; paleas often shorter than the lemmas, sometimes less pubescent, sometimes as long as the lemmas and similar in texture and pubescence; lemma margins often overlapping for part or all of their length at maturity | 17 |
14 | Callus barbed with a dense ring of flexuous hairs, hairs 1.0–1.5 mm long; style 1; lodicules 2; elongated leaf blades concentrated basally (above initial cataphylls), upper cauline leaves much reduced, only 0.8–1.8 cm long; lemma epidermal pattern saw-like | Oryzopsis |
– | Callus glabrous or with short straight hairs forming a sparse ring, hairs 0.1–0.5 mm long; styles 2; lodicules 2 or 3; awn central; cauline leaves well developed, similar to basal leaves, or somewhat shorter but not strongly reduced; lemma epidermal pattern saw-like or maize-like | 15 |
15 | Glumes 5–9-veined, with faint or prominent transverse veinlets; basal leaf blades absent (leaves cataphyllous) then up to 2 cm long; mid- and upper cauline leaves several, up to 35 cm long and 2 cm wide | Patis |
– | Glumes 1–3-veined, transverse veinlets absent (rarely present, never prominent); basal leaf blades well developed or not (leaves cataphyllous or not), mostly 2–90 cm long or reduced; cauline leaves similar to basal leaves, or sometimes shorter or rudimentary | 16 |
16 | Plants with well-developed basal tufts leaves, blades slender; central vein of the lemma not prominent; lower panicle branches never whorled; anther apices glabrous; lemma epidermal pattern Saw-like; awns caducous and straight and basally slightly twisted, or persistent and geniculate with a strongly twisted first segment; plants native | Piptatheropsis |
– | Plants without basal tufts of leaves, blades 2–10 mm wide; central vein of the lemma prominent; lower panicle branches whorled with 3‒30 or more per node; anther apices minutely bearded; lemma epidermal pattern Maize-like; awns persistent or caducous, straight, never twisted; plants adventive from Eurasia | Oloptum* |
17 | Glumes without evident venation, glume apices rounded to acute; plants subalpine to alpine, sometimes growing in bogs | 18 |
– | Glumes with 1–3(5) evident veins or the glume apices attenuate; plants growing from near sea level to subalpine or alpine habitats, not growing in bogs | 19 |
18 | Awns strigillose in lower part; lemma lobes inconspicuous (0.1–0.4 mm); callus sharp; panicles narrow to loosely contracted; anthers penicillate, 0.5–1.5 mm long | Ptilagrostiella |
– | Awns hairy throughout, lemma lobes prominent (up to 0.8 mm); callus blunt; the hairs on the lowest segment 1–2 mm long; panicles open with spreading branches these sometimes loosely contracted; anthers glabrous, 1.2–3 mm long | Ptilagrostis |
19 | Paleas with prolonged veins almost reaching the tip of the lemma lobes, the veins 1–3 mm long; lemma apices 2-lobed, narrow, the lobes 1–3 mm long | Barkworthia |
– | Paleas without prolonged veins or if prolonged never more than 0.3 mm long; lemma apices unlobed or if lobed, the lobes usually obtuse and never more than 2.1 mm long | 20 |
20 | Lemma bodies with hairs to 0.15 mm long over most of their length, and a tuft of pappus-like hairs at the apex to 3–4 mm long; awns glabrous; ligules with lateral tufts of hairs to 2 mm long; anthers 0.8 mm long; plants native from Mexico southward, infrequently cultivated as an ornamental | Jarava |
– | Lemma bodies with evenly distributed hairs of similar length or completely glabrous, sometimes with longer hairs around the base of the awn; basal segment of the awns sometimes with hairs up to 2 mm long; ligules without lateral tufts of hairs; anthers mostly longer; plants of Mexico and northward, infrequently cultivated as an ornamentals | 21 |
21 | Basal leaf sheaths becoming fibrous with age; panicle branches whorled below; apical lemma hairs 1–1.5 mm long; awns readily deciduous; upper culm ligules to 12 mm long; plants cultivated ornamentals from Asia, uncommon, not known to have escaped | Neotrinia* |
– | Basal leaf sheaths never fibrous, occasionally ribbon-like; panicle branches rarely whorled below; lemmas usually without apical lemmas hairs longer than those present on the body; upper culm ligules usually less than 5 mm long; plants native and widespread | 22 |
22 | Plants with woody, sometimes scandent bamboo-like culms, 3–6 mm thick below with ramified branching (usually, but sometimes absent in immature specimens of P. hirticulmis) at the middle and upper nodes, with (2) 3 to 13 nodes | Pseudoeriocoma |
– | Plants with neither woody nor scandent bamboo-like culms, usually less than 2 mm thick below and never with ramified branching at the middle and upper nodes, with 2 to 3 or up to 5 nodes in a few species | 23 |
23 | Lower culm internodes densely pubescent for 3–9 mm below the nodes, the hairs retrorse with shorter hairs and less densely pubescent elsewhere; known only from southern California and Baja California | Thorneochloa |
– | Lower culm internodes glabrous or if pubescent then only to 5 mm below the nodes, usually glabrous elsewhere or if hairy the hairs usually not retrorse; widely distributed in western North America | Eriocoma |
The description of Stipa virlettii (Type: Virlet 1376 from San Luis de Potosí, Mexico) appears to be a mixture of Stipa mucronata Kunth [= Nassella mucronata] awns and Bromus laciniatus Beal (= Bromus carinatus Hook & Arn.) as determined by A.S. Hitchcock (isotype: US-A866077 fragm. ex P-Fourn-163!). Notes by A.S. Hitchcock on the US sheet with two fragment packets indicate that there are two species of Bromus on the herb. Fournier sheet: A is B. richardsonii Link; B is B. carinatus, also annotated by ASH.
We thank the Smithsonian Institution’s Restricted Endowment Fund, the Scholarly Studies Program, Research Opportunities, Atherton Seidell Foundation, Biodiversity Surveys and Inventories Program, Small Grants; the National Geographic Society for Research and Exploration (Grant No. 8848-10, 8087-06); Annaliese Miller, Hana Pazdírková, Cindy T. Roché, and Alice R. Tangerini for preparing the illustrations; Utah State University for permission to use illustrations that appeared in the Flora of North America, Volume 24; and Jeffery M. Saarela and one anonymous reviewer for suggesting improvements to the manuscript.