Research Article |
Corresponding author: Ruth Kiew ( ruth@frim.gov.my ) Academic editor: Jan Wieringa
© 2018 Joanne Pei-Chih Tan, Sheh May Tam, Ruth Kiew.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Tan JP-C, Tam SM, Kiew R (2018) Begonia yenyeniae (Begoniaceae), a new species from Endau Rompin National Park, Johor, Malaysia. PhytoKeys 110: 23-37. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.110.25846
|
Begonia yenyeniae is a new species of horticultural value known only from the Endau Rompin National Park, Peninsular Malaysia. It is similar to Begonia rajah with which it had previously been confused in the number of tepals and leaf characters. The new species is compared with three similar species, B. foxworthyi, B. rajah and B. reginula and photographs of all four species and descriptions of B. yenyeniae and B. rajah are provided. Molecular analysis using the ndhF-rpl132 chloroplast marker confirms the four species as distinct. Amongst native species, the three variegated species, B. yenyeniae, B. rajah and B. reginula, are some of the most popular Malaysian begonias in cultivation. Based on its restricted distribution, Begonia yenyeniae, under the IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria, is assessed as Critically Endangered.
new species, Begonia yenyeniae , Begonia rajah , Begonia reginula , ornamental, conservation
Asian begonias are prized for the eye-catching variety of colours and patterns of their variegated leaves and so are targets for horticultural interest as a genetic source for new hybrid cultivar development. However, a vast array of begonias is of conservation importance either because they have restricted distributions, being known from very few localities or they are confined to a specific habitat niche. For example, of the 54 native taxa in Peninsular Malaysia, 57% are threatened with 24 taxa assessed as Critically Endangered and 21 species are known from a single locality (
As pristine forest diminishes in the face of extraction of timber or land clearance for the planting of oil palm and other crops and for infrastructure development, forests are becoming valued for the ecological services they provide and as a source of medicinal and ornamental plants or minor forest products, as well as for tourism and recreation. However, the commercial value of native species is often realised outside the country of origin so minimal benefit is generated locally. In Malaysia, the introduction of wild native species into horticulture has been haphazard. In recognising this, the Forest Research Institute Malaysia (
This new species was one of the candidates of this project. It was discovered in 2002 by Dr Sam Yen-Yen in the Endau-Rompin National Park in the southern state of Johor. It proved to be amenable to cultivation and, unlike many native begonias that need constant high humidity, it does not need to be grown in a covered terrarium. So the species was ‘bulked up’ and offered to the horticulture trade to test its potential. Unfortunately, the local horticultural market was reluctant to invest in the marketing of this species on a commercial scale but, based on information available on social media and websites, it spread widely amongst specialist growers. Individual plants from the original Johor collection continued to be grown for further studies in the Kepong Herbarium (KEP) nursery. The Johor plants have been identified as Begonia rajah Ridl. because they have the same habit, number of tepals (four in the male flower and three in the female) and similar attractive leaf colour and surface (
Begonia rajah is one of the most decorative Malaysian begonias due to its striking and uniquely contrasting bronzy-green leaf colour. It was discovered in 1892 and gained fame in 1894 when it was sent to England and won a First Class Certificate from the Royal Horticultural Society (
With recent publications of higher level (sectional) molecular phylogenies of Begonia (
The description and measurements of the new species are based on herbarium specimens deposited in the Kepong Herbarium, Forest Research Institute Malaysia (KEP) and Singapore Botanic Gardens Herbarium (
Interspecific relationships amongst the proposed new species (B. yenyeniae), B. foxworthyi, B. rajah and B. reginula were inferred from our current, on-going phylogenetic study that focuses on Begonia species from Peninsular Malaysia. DNA sequences for the chloroplast ndhF-rpl32 intergenic spacer region were generated for 48 taxa of Begonia which included species mostly from Peninsular Malaysia (Suppl. material
DNA of Begonia species was extracted from living material or silica gel dried material using the NucleoSpin Plant II kit following the manufacturer’s protocols (Macherey Nagel, Germany). Amplification of the chloroplast ndhF-rpl32 intergenic spacer was done using the forward and reverse primers ndhFBeg-F and trnLBeg-R, respectively, designed by
The final alignment file, comprising of 126 taxa and 1244 characters, was subjected to Bayesian analysis performed using MrBayes 3.2.6 on XSEDE via the CIPRES portal (https://www.phylo.org/). Following
Results of our on-going study from Bayesian analysis of 47 taxa of Begonia from Peninsular Malaysia, which included accessions of B. rajah, B. reginula and the new species B. yenyeniae, together with 79 other Asian species using the ndhF-rpl32 chloroplast marker, showed that all three species resolved together in a strongly supported polytomous clade (Bayesian posterior probability (BPP) support = 1) where B. yenyeniae clearly separated in its own subclade (BPP support = 0.98) with accessions of B. foxworthyi and B. nurii. The tree shows that the B. yenyeniae accession resolved in a relatively long branch which lends support to its separation as a proposed new species. Part of the tree highlighting relationships amongst B. rajah, B. reginula, B. foxworthyi and B. yenyeniae are presented in Figure
The ndhF-rpl32 DNA sequences of B. yenyeniae, B. rajah and B. reginula have been deposited to GenBank (accession numbers MH454102, MH454103 and MH454104, respectively). Thus, molecular data support the close relationships of these species and the genetic distinction of B. yenyeniae. It is noted that the phylogenetic tree shows that a single chloroplast marker has limited power to resolve interspecific relationships in this group and, clearly, additional molecular markers are required as certain accessions of the same species did not resolve in clearly differentiated clades.
Jackia M.Hughes
Similar to Begonia rajah Ridl. (1894:213) in its handsome leaves, striking brownish-pink to brownish-red with greenish-yellow veins in young leaves becoming bronzy variegation at maturity; in its creeping growth habit, number of tepals in male (4 tepals) and female flowers (3), palmate leaf venation and many-flowered cymes, but several notable characters distinguish the new species, including its orbicular-reniform leaf blades (vs. subrotund with an abruptly acute apex in B. rajah), smaller stipules, 9–12 × 3–4 mm, three times longer than wide (vs. 15–20 × 10–12 mm, less than twice as long as wide), smaller ovate or obovate bracts 2–3 × 1.5–2 mm (vs. bracts bowl-shaped, wide ovate, 5–8 × 7.5–8 mm), margin shallowly crenate (vs. margin angular), bullate leaf surface (vs. conspicuously pronounced bullate). Furthermore, the leaf colour of cultivated B. rajah is more vivid and, in contrast, its tepals, stipules and bracts are also a deeper shade of pink, compared to those of B. yenyeniae.
It is also similar to B. reginula
Although molecular data indicate a close relationship to B. foxworthyi ((1925: 311), the latter species is morphologically distinct in its conspicuously oblique leaf with an acute to acuminate apex (vs. orbicular-reniform with a rounded apex), its entire margin (vs. crenate) and plain green, non-bullate leaf surface (vs. purplish-green to brownish-purple and bullate) and its male flowers with 2 tepals (vs. 4 tepals). In addition, it usually grows on limestone substrates (vs. confined to granite substrates.
Peninsular Malaysia. Johor, Mersing, Endau-Rompin National Park, Sungai Selai, 14 April 2018, Kiew FRI 81950 (holotype E!; iso-: K!, SAR!,
Lithophytic herb with rhizomatous stem. Indumentum of soft hairs, usually cream- coloured, sparse on stipules (mostly on the keel and 0.5–1.5 mm long), petioles more densely hairy towards blade (2–3 mm), leaf margin (hairs ca. 1 mm) and veins beneath (ca. 1 mm) but sparse (ca. 0.5 mm) or absent on ventral surface of outer tepals and on peduncle hairs hardly visible to the naked eye. Stems creeping, apex usually slightly erect, branched, 5–9 mm thick, light yellowish-green; stipules 3 per node, two triangular, abruptly narrowed to an attenuate apex terminating in a hair, keeled from base to apex, margin entire and translucent, 9–12 × 3–4 mm, pale yellowish-green, one narrowly lanceolate, ca. 3 mm long, persistent. Leaves tufted, alternate, 2–3 mm apart; petioles terete, 2.5–3.5 mm across, up to 12.5 cm long, pale brownish-pink to darker pink towards blade; blades thinly succulent, glabrous, orbicular-reniform, asymmetric, 8–11.5 × 9.5–13.5 cm, scarcely angular, margin somewhat crenate with acute teeth bent abruptly downwards between teeth, ciliate, basal lobes cordate, overlapping when mature, moderately raised between veins, light purplish-green to dull brownish-purple, young blades brownish-pink to brownish-red, paler beneath; veins palmate, slightly prominent towards the base but impressed where branched towards the margin, prominent beneath, lateral veins ca. 2–3 pairs, greenish-yellow when young and whitish-green when mature. Inflorescences axillary, more or less erect, 10–23 cm long, brownish-red, peduncles 8–18.5 cm long, two main branches 2–3 cm long, pedicels 6–9 mm; bracts in pairs at node of peduncle, glabrous, elliptic-ovate or obovate, margin towards apex laciniate, 2–3 × 1.5–2 mm, light yellowish-green sometimes with a faint tinge of pink, persistent. Male flowers with 4 tepals, margin entire, 1–1.2 × 1.1–1.4 cm; outer 2 tepals rotund, concave at centre, 5–7 × 6 mm, pale greenish-white or light pink or pale pinkish-white, inner 2 tepals obovate, apex rounded or sometimes retuse and impressed along centre, ca. 5 × 3 mm, white; stamens numerous, torus ca. 1 mm long, stamen mass globose, symmetric, ca. 2.5 mm across; anthers obovoid-oblong, tip emarginate, ca. 0.5 mm long, dehiscing through 2 longitudinal slits. Female flowers with a light yellowish-green ovary sometimes with faint light pink tinge, ca. 5.5 × 9 mm, locules 3, wings 3 equal, placentation axile, 1 placenta per locule, each placenta usually with 2 minute branches at the base; usually tepals 3, outer 2 tepals, rotund, concave at centre, ca. 4 × 4.5 mm, white with faint green tinge; styles and stigmas 3, 1.5–2 mm, style light greenish-yellow, stigma pale yellow, papillose, spiral band. Capsules ca. 6 ×12 mm, locules 3, splitting longitudinally between locules, wing 3 equal, ca. 4 mm wide, surface glabrous, styles and stigmas persisting after tepals have fallen, dangling on a fine, thread-like pedicel ca. 5.5 mm long. Seeds numerous, barrel-shaped, 0.3–0.34 × 0.2–0.22 mm, collar cells slightly more than half the seed length, surface sculptured.
Endemic in Peninsular Malaysia, Johor, Mersing District, Endau-Rompin National Park, Sungai Selai. It is apparently a rare species as it is known only from the type locality in Endau Rompin National Park.
Named after Dr Sam Yen-Yen, Malaysian botanist, specialist in Zingiberaceae who first discovered the species and recognised its potential as an ornamental plant.
Critically Endangered CR B2ab(iii, v), D1. Although the type locality is within a Totally Protected Area, it is known from only one population about 1.5 km2 and its habitat is threatened by ecotourism activity and illegal collecting. The area of observed population covers about 1.5 km2 (P.T. Ong pers. comm.).
In primary lowland mixed dipterocarp forest, growing on moss-covered rocks, rarely epiphytic, near a waterfall in deep shade.
The ovary of species in section Jackia have three locules, each with an unbranched placenta, but in this species two vestigial branches are present near the base of the placenta (Figure
Begonia yenyeniae J.P.C.Tan, sp. nov. A Side and front view female flower B Back and front view of male flower C Stamen mass D Anthers E Habitat: moss-covered rocky slope by waterfall F Young fruit with stigma still attached G Transverse section of fruit H Seeds I Mature leaf J Upper leaf surface (moderately bullate) K Veins completely prominent on lower leaf surface L Petiole M Young blade N Stipules O–Q Upper, lower and side view of leaf margin R A pair of bracts and bracteole at peduncle and rachis; hairs scarcely on ventral surface of outer tepals. (Photographs by E Y.Y. Sam, D P.T. Ong)
Peninsular Malaysia. Johor: Mersing, Endau-Rompin National Park, Sungai Selai, 15 Aug 2002, Sam et al. FRI 47082 (KEP!), 24 July 2012, Hairul et al. FRI 78570 (KEP!,
Gardeners’ Chronicle XVI (1894) 213, nom. nud.; Rolfe, Bulletin of Miscellaneous Information (1914) 327; Irmscher, Mitteilungen aus dem Institut für allgemeine Botanik in Hamburg 8 (1929) 96; Tebbitt, Begonias: Cultivation, Identification, and Natural History (2005) 198; Kiew, Begonias of Peninsular Malaysia (2005) 216, pro parte.
Jackia M.Hughes
Peninsular Malaysia. Terengganu, 1892, Native collector s.n. (holotype
Endemic in Peninsular Malaysia, Terengganu (without specific locality). Apparently restricted in its distribution because, despite continuous botanical collecting in Terengganu and elsewhere in Peninsular Malaysia, it has not been re-found since it was first collected in 1892 (Kiew, 2005).
Part of the Bayesian 50% majority rule consensus tree from the analysis of chloroplast ndhF-rpl32 region depicting relationships amongst B. foxworthyi, B. rajah, B. reginula and B. yenyeniae. The locality is indicated at the end of the species name for species with multiple samples. Numbers on the branches indicate Bayesian posterior probability (BPP) support values.
Character | Begonia rajah | Begonia yenyeniae sp. nov. | Begonia reginula | Begonia foxworthyi |
---|---|---|---|---|
Leaf: texture | thickly succulent polished shining prominent bullate | thinly succulent | thinly succulent slightly raised in between veins | thinly succulent |
Surface | moderately raised in between veins | glossy, veins slightly impressed | ||
Leaf shape | subrotund | orbicular-reniform | broadly ovate | almost rotund apex short- pointed |
apex abruptly acute | apex rounded | apex abruptly attenuate angular | not angular | |
angular | scarcely angular | |||
Tepal no. in male flower | 4 | 4 | 2 | 2 |
Tepal no. in female flower | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 |
Outer tepal size (mm) | 6–8 × 5–8 | 5–7 × 6 | 6–10 × 9–11 | 4–6 × 4–6 |
Outer tepal: shape | widely ovate or cordate | rotund | widely ovate or rotund | broadly ovate to rotund rounded |
apex | obtuse | rounded | rounded or acute subcordate | subcordate |
base | subcordate | rounded | ||
Stipule: shape | lanceolate-oblong or triangular | narrowly triangular, | narrowly triangular, | narrowly triangular |
size (mm) | 15–20 × 10–12 | 9–12 × 3–4 | 5–7 × 2–3 | 7–12 × 2–5 |
colour | Brownish-pink to scarlet | light yellowish-green sometimes with a faint pink tinge | pale greenish yellow or reddish yellow | red |
Keel on stipules | from base to apex | from base to apex | absent | from base to apex |
Bract: shape | broadly ovate, bowl-shaped | elliptic-ovate or obovate, curved or flat | obovate, curved or flat | obovate, flat |
size (mm) | 5–8 × 7.5–8 | 2–3 × 1.5–2 | 3–4 × 1–3 | 4–6 × 2–4 |
Hair density: | ||||
petioles | hairy | sparsely hairy, more hairy near leaf base | sparsely hairy | densely hairy |
stipules | densely hairy | sparsely hairy | hairy | densely hairy |
peduncles | hairy | sparsely covered, hairs inconspicuous | without hairs | sparsely hairy |
Ovary colour | pink or pale pink | light yellowish-green | light yellowish-green | reddish or dark pink |
From a Sanskrit word raja = king, presumably referring to it as the most beautiful begonia species.
Extinct in the Wild (EW). However, it survives in cultivation since its first introduction into cultivation in 1894 (
Its natural habitat is not known but judging from its growth requirements in cultivation, it probably grew in cool and shaded conditions. Other specimens examined. Peninsular Malaysia. Herbarium specimens made from cultivated plants in Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew Anonymous s.n. 1903 (K!); Sander F. et al., s.n. 1913 (K!); Anonymous s.n. August 1913 (K!).
This study was funded by the Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation, Malaysia (MOSTI) under the ‘Flora of Peninsular Malaysia project’ (01-04-01-000 Khas) and ‘Documentation & Inventory Flora of Malaysia project’ based at Forest Research Institute Malaysia. We are grateful to our colleagues of the Kepong Herbarium and Nursery, Y.Y. Sam, P.T. Ong, M. Hairul, M. Aidil for making collections and maintaining the living collection in the nursery; to C.M. Chen (Dr. Cecilia Koo Botanic Conservation Center) for advice on the cultivation of begonias in KEP nursery condition; to Y.Y. Sam and P.T. Ong for permission to use their photographs and to the Curators of the Kew and Singapore Herbaria for permission to examine specimens in their care.
List of taxa with accession and location information for the 48 samples of Begonia included in the Bayesian analysis using ndhF-rpl32 intergenic spacer sequences