Research Article |
Corresponding author: Vicki A. Funk ( funkv@si.edu ) Academic editor: Alexander Sennikov
© 2017 Vicki A. Funk, Gisela Sancho, Nádia Roque.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Funk VA, Sancho G, Roque N (2017) Nahuatlea: a new genus of compositae (Gochnatieae) from North America. PhytoKeys 91: 105-124. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.91.21340
|
In the course of a detailed molecular study of the tribe Gochnatieae (Compositae: Gochnatioideae) it became apparent that the genus Gochnatia (sensu Cabrera) was not monophyletic but composed of a number of morphologically, geographically, and molecularly distinct clades. All but one of these clades had previously been recognized at the generic or sectional level and therefore had a name that could be applied. However, one clade, whose members are from Mexico and adjacent parts of the United States, had never been recognized as a distinct taxon. The Mexican clade is the sister group of the Caribbean clade which seems to indicate a dispersal event from Southern South America to Mexico and from Mexico to the Caribbean. Here we provide the Mexican clade with a genus name, Nahuatlea, and make the necessary new combinations. The name is derived from Nahuatl, the major indigenous language that is spoken in the area where most of the collections were gathered. A genus description, key to species, images, and a short, species descriptions, are provided.
Asteraceae , Gochnatia , Gochnatioideae , Mexico, Texas, Arizona, South American-Mexican disjunct distribution
Cabrera recognized five species of Gochnatia from Mexico and adjacent USA: G. arborescens Brandegee, G. hypoleuca (DC.) A. Gray, G. magna M.C. Johnson ex Cabrera, G. purpusii Brandegee, and G. smithii Robins. & Greenm. Gochnatia obtusata S.F. Blake, although accepted by
The next comprehensive treatment of Gochnatia was by
In 2004 González-Medrano et al. described a new species of Gochnatia from Hidalgo, Mexico: G. hiriartiana Medrano, Villaseñor & Medina. It differs from all the other Mexican species because of its few, large heads, and greater number of disc flowers. The authors included a key to seven taxa: six species and the subspecies G. hypoleuca subsp. obtusata. The authors placed the new species in G. sect. Glomerata based on the key in
The recent molecular study of the tribe Gochnatieae (
All but one of the clades had previously been recognized at the generic or subgeneric level:
1) Gochnatia Kunth: Eight species from the Central Andes (more or less equal to G. sect. Gochnatia of
2) Pentaphorus D. Don: Southern Andean clade of two species that, at various times, had been recognized as a genus, subgenus, or section (resurrected by
3) Mexican Gochnatia: A group of seven species that had never been recognized as a separate genus nor had they been placed in a section by themselves was recovered as a monophyletic group.
4) Anastraphia: The 33 Caribbean species fell into one strongly supported clade that had previously been recognized as a genus and a section (re-established as a genus by Ventosa and Herrera 2011a;
5) Moquiniastrum: The 21 species that form this clade are mainly from central and southern Brazil and previously formed the majority of Gochnatia sect. Moquiniastrum (
6) Richterago Kuntze: A clade of 16 species, all endemic to the campos rupestres of Brazil (redefined by
7) Cnicothamnus Griseb.: A genus of two species found in Bolivia and northwestern Argentina: it has never been included in Gochnatia.
8) Cyclolepis Gilles ex D. Don: A monospecific genus that has never been included in Gochnatia: found from Paraguay to the northern Patagonia area of Argentina. This lineage was regarded as “incertae sedis” in
A key to the genera of Gochnatieae along with additional discussion on the tribe is contained in a upcoming paper (Funk et al. in prep).
In the Funk et al. biogeographic analysis (2014), it was hypothesized that the tribe had a southern South America origin (including the Central and Southern Andes, Argentina, and southern Brazil). Based on this, plus the fact that the Mexican clade is the sister group of the Caribbean clade (Anastraphia) suggests, or is best explained by, a dispersal event from Southern South America to Mexico and from Mexico to the Caribbean. We order the dispersal events in this direction because the Mexican Gochnatia are morphologically more similar to the Andean genus Gochnatia s.s. than the Caribbean species. This Mexican + Caribbean clade (MCC) is believed to have separated from the rest of the Gochnatieae between 11 and 23 mya at a time when there was a gradual climate warming (early Miocene; Petuch 2003, Zachos et al. 2001). MCC is the sister group of a large clade containing Richterago + Moquiniastrum (RM) which is mainly from Brazil and Southern South America. The sister groups to these two large clades (MCC + RM) are from the Andes (Gochnatia s.s., Pentaphorus, Cnicothamnus), so just where in southern South America the MCC clade originated is uncertain especially since some of the sister group relationships are not well supported, although all of the segregate genera are individually clearly monophyletic.
The Mexican members of Gochnatia clearly do not belong in the genus Gochnatia s.s., therefore, we are here describing the genus Nahuatlea for these seven species.
All types and other specimens deposited at LP and US were examined. The remaining types were viewed on line using the JSTOR-GP portal (http://plants.jstor.org; Fig.
Distributions are based on data derived from databasing and georeferencing the collections at US (available online http://collections.mnh.si.edu/search/botany/) with additional records from ARIZ (http://ag.arizona.edu/herbarium/home), MEXU (http://unibio.unam.mx/minero/index.jsp?accion=sc&colecciones=MEXU,Herbario), MO (http://www.tropicos.org/Home.aspx), TEX (http://orchid.biosci.utexas.edu/Texas_list.html), and NY (http://sciweb.nybg.org/science2/vii2.asp). When possible, records from GBIF (http://www.gbif.org/occurrence) were also added. Figures
Shrubs or trees, monoecious. Leaves sessile or with a short petiole of no more than 5 mm long, alternate, chartaceous or coriaceous, entire, margins revolute, usually discolorous (silvery or cinereous-tomentose beneath), clustered near the ends of the branches especially late in the flowering cycle. Heads arranged in clusters, rarely solitary, most branches with an apical cluster; sessile or short-pedunculate, peduncles commonly densely scaly-bracted resembling the lowermost involucral bracts, homogamous (flowers bisexual), discoid; involucre obconic (turbinate) or campanulate, shorter than the flowers; phyllaries imbricate, 4–10 seriate, graduate, coriaceous or subcoriaceous. Flowers with corollas homomorphic, white or yellow, actinomorphic, deeply 5-lobed, lobes equal or shorter than the tube, revolute; anthers calcarate, caudate, anther apical appendages apiculate, tails 1–3 mm long, entire or fimbrillate; styles rounded at apex, glabrous, style branches concave. Achenes 5-ribbed sericeous, cuneate-cylindrical, carpopodium conspicuous. Pappus of scabrid bristles, uni- or biseriate, graduated (varying in length) and equally wide throughout or rarely flattened at the tips, ca 1 cm long. [7 species]
Nahuatlea, with some exceptions, is characterized by a combination of characters: short leafy branchlets, entire and revolute blade margins, clusters of sessile or short-pedunculate heads at or near the tips of branches; densely scaly-bracted peduncles (when present); and a pappus that is biseriate, graduated, and equally wide throughout. Most of the exceptions are found in the recently described Gochnatia hiriartiana (Medrano, Villasenor & Medina, 2004) which has solitary heads, and a uniseriate pappus with bristles that are flattened at the tips. However, recently produced sequence data including those of G. hiriartiana support Nahuatlea as monophyletic (Funk, unpublished).
The genus name was selected to honor the indigenous people of eastern central Mexico by naming it after their language. The name is derived from Nahuatl, a language of the Nahuan branch of the Uto-Aztecan language family (known informally as Aztec). It is spoken by an estimated 1.5 million people, most of whom live in Central Mexico. Nahuatl has been spoken in Central Mexico since at least the 7th century AD and it was the language of the Aztecs who dominated what is now central Mexico during the Late Postclassic period of Mesoamerican history. Today the Nahuatl language is spoken in the Mexican states of Durango, Guerrero, Hidalgo, Mexico, Michoacan, Morelos, Oaxaca, Puebla, Tlaxcala, and Veracruz. The distribution of the new genus, Nahuatlea, in central Mexico has substantial overlap with the area so it is appropriate to use it for the name of the new genus (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nahuatl).
1 | Involucre campanulate or broadly obconic, bracts wooly tomentose or puberulous abaxially; corollas yellow | 2 |
– | Involucre narrowly cylindrical or narrowly obconic, bracts glabrous (may be ciliolate); corollas white or yellow (the latter only in N. arborescens) | 4 |
2 | Heads with 200–230 flowers; involucre 25–35(–40) mm in diameter; corolla 13–22 mm long | N. hiriartiana |
– | Heads with 12–50 flowers; involucre 5–12 mm in diameter; corolla 8–12 mm long | 3 |
3 | Leaves 5–10 × 4–6.5 cm; involucre 10–12 mm wide; heads with ca. 50 flowers; 3–5 heads per cluster; pappus 9 mm long, bristles uni-seriate ; shrub or small tree 2.5–4.5 meters | N. magna |
– | Leaves 1.8–3.0 × 0.5–1.4 cm; involucre 5–6 mm wide; heads with 12–18 flowers; 10–15 heads per cluster; pappus 7.5 mm long, bi-seriate; shrub (no size given) | N. purpusii |
4 | Leaves glabrescent abaxially; involucral bracts in 8–10 series; heads 6–8 mm wide; 13–20 flowers per head, corollas yellowish, 12 mm long; trees of 3–8 m, trunks 20–30 cm in diameter | N. arborescens |
– | Leaves tomentose abaxially; involucral bracts in 3–7 series (bracts on peduncle not included); heads ca. 3 mm wide; (3–)5–7 flowers per head, corollas white, 5–12 mm long; shrubs or small trees of 1–7 m, stems less than 10 cm in diameter | 5 |
5 | Leaves 4–8 mm × 3–5 mm, broadly ovate; leaves at the glomerule shorter than the heads; involucral bracts usually glabrous | N. obtusata |
– | Leaves 25–50 mm × 15–20 mm, oblong-lanceolate; leaves at the glomerule longer than the heads; involucral bracts ciliolate or ciliolate-tomentose on the margins | 6 |
6 | Involucral bracts in 5–7 series; corollas 8.5–9 mm long; anther tails entire; involucre 6–8 mm tall; shrub; blade oblong-lanceolate, apex acute, tomentose below | N. smithii |
– | Involucral bracts in 3–5 series; corollas 7–12 mm long; anther tails fimbrillate; involucre 4–7 mm tall; shrub to small tree; blade narrowly elliptic, apex rounded, mucronate, whitish-tomentose below | N. hypoleuca |
Gochnatia hiriartiana Medrano, Villasenor & Medina. Novon 14: 435–436. 2004.
Mexico. Hidalgo: Municipio Meztitlán, 3 km al E de Milpa Grande, barranca sobre el Río Amajac, 19 Sep 1996, F. González-Medrano, G.G. Hernández & G. Rodriguez 17920 (Holotype: MEXU 00316791; Isotypes, IEB 000177217, MO 3024215, TEX 00208274, XAL 0106702).
Shrub 1.0–1.5 m tall; leaves coriaceous, blades 1.0–3.5 × 1–2 cm, elliptic to slightly ovate, yellowish-tomentose below; heads sessile, solitary or in clusters of 2–3 at apex of branches, few clusters per plant; involucre campanulate, 15–20 mm tall × 25–35(–40) mm wide, bracts in 5–6 series, densely puberulous abaxially; flowers 200–230 per head; corollas light yellow, 13–22 mm long; anther base caudate, tails 2.0–2.5 mm long, entire; pappus ca. 1 cm long, bristles biseriate, broadening slightly at the apex.
Mexico: only known from two collections both in Hidalgo.
Gochnatia magna M.C. Johnson ex Cabrera, Revista Mus. La Plata, Secc. Bot., 12(66): 147–150. 1971.
Mexico. Tamaulipas: half a mile east of Nuevo Morelos, 25 Oct 1959, J. Graham & M.C. Johnston 4485 (Holotype: MEXU 01220108; Isotype: TEX 00374383).
Shrub or small tree 2.5– 4.5 m tall; leaves chartaceous, blades 5–10 × 4.1–6.2 cm, widely elliptic, glabrescent adaxially, wooly abaxially; heads short pedunculate in clusters of 3–5 at the apex of branches, surrounded by leaves, few clusters per plant; involucre campanulate (especially at early flowering), 13–15 mm tall × 10–12 mm wide, bracts in 5–7 series, woolly adaxially; flowers ca. 50 per head; corollas yellow, 12 mm long; anther base caudate, tails ca. 1 mm long, entire; pappus ca. 9 mm long, bristles uniseriate, broadening, flattened, and somewhat darker at the apex.
Mexico: Tamaulipas and San Luis Potosi.
Gochnatia purpusii T.S. Brandegee, Zöe 5(11): 240. 1906.
Mexico. Puebla: Tehuacan, 1800 m, June 1905, C.A. Purpus 1164 (Holotype: UC 91904; Isotypes: BM 000947904, F 0050268, GH 00008382, NY 00169558, RSA 0001214). [Specimens at P (P00703338 & P00703339) and E (E00413001) have the correct collecting number but incorrect dates and may or may not be type material;
Shrub of unknown size (one isotype has what appears to be “5–6 m” written on the label); leaves coriaceous, petiole minute (1–2 mm), blade 1.8–3.0 × 0.5–1.4 cm, elliptical or slightly lanceolate or oblanceolate, glabrescent adaxially, white flocculent-tomentose abaxially; heads sessile, in few clusters of 8–15, clusters all at apex of branches; involucre campanulate (especially at early flowering), ca. 10 mm tall × 5–6 mm wide, bracts in 5–6 series, densely wooly abaxially; flowers 12–18 per head; corollas yellowish, ca. 8 mm long; anther base caudate, tails ca. 1 mm long, fimbrillate; pappus ca. 7.5 mm long, bi-seriate with slender bristles.
Mexico: known only from four collections all from Puebla.
Gochnatia arborescens Brandegee, Zoë 5(9): 163. 1903.
Mexico. Baja California: Cañón de Santa María, El Juste, 1 Mar 1898, C.A. Purpus s.n. (Holotype: UC 91900; possible Isotypes: K 000502538; GH 00008379; US 00119526).
Determining what may or may not be type material is difficult; all proposed types are Purpus s.n. collections but there are different collection dates and locality information. The Holotype is one of two different collections mounted on the same sheet one of which is annotated as “n. sp.” and “type”. That specimen also has a hand-written note that says “The year doubtless 1901 RM” indicating that the date on the sheet January-March 1898 is not correct. The information found on the three possible isotypes is nearly identical (Lower California, San Felipe, Cape Region Lower California, Jan-Mar 1901) but the information is different from the locality information on the Holotype. All of the “type material” specimens are the same species so there is little doubt that this is the correct name for this entity but someone more familiar with the work of Purpus (who seems to have confusing dates and numbers) and Brandegee will need to investigate this further to determine if the three listed specimens are actually isotypes.
Tree 3–8 m tall, trunk 20–30 cm in diameter; leaves chartaceous, blades 3.5–6.5 cm × 2.5–4.5 cm, ovate to elliptic, cuneate or rounded at base, glabrescent on both faces; heads short-pedunculate, solitary or more usually in loose clusters of 2–20 at apex of branches, few clusters per plant; involucre cylindrical to narrowly obconic depending on age, 10–15(20) mm tall × 6–8 mm wide at anthesis, bracts in 8–10 series, glabrous; flowers 13–20 per head; corollas yellowish, 12 mm long; anther base caudate, tails ca. 3 mm long, entire; pappus ca. 11 mm long, bristles slender, biseriate.
Mexico: known only from Baja California Sur.
Gochnatia obtusata S.F. Blake, Contributions from the United States National Herbarium 22: 652. 1924.
Mexico. Puebla: dry limestone hills at Tehuacan, 20 Dec 1895, C.G. Pringle 6253 (Holotype: US 00119530 [254705]; Isotypes: A 00008380, BM 000947903, BR 0000005318124, CM 2403, E 00413002, JE 00000693, K 000502539, GH 00008381, MEXU 01220107, MO 1544305, NDG 63791, NY 00169557, P 00703351, P 00703352, PH 00025961, S 10-11705, TEX 00000454, US 01100608). [
Shrub 1.0–1.5(–2.6) m tall; leaves coriaceous, (4.5)5–8(20) × 3–5 mm, broadly elliptic, apex rounded to obtuse, rounded at base, glabrous adaxially, cinereous-tomentose abaxially; heads short-pedunculate (ca. 2 mm long), in clusters of 10–20 heads, at apices of branches; involucre narrowly obconic, 6–8 mm tall × 2.8–3.2 mm wide, bracts in ca. 5 series, glabrous; flowers 5–6 per head; corollas white, 6.5–7.5 mm long; anther base caudate, tails ca. 2 mm long, fimbrillate; pappus 6.0–7.5 mm long, bristles biseriate, broadening slightly at the tips.
Mexico: Puebla and Oaxaca.
Gochnatia obtusata was described by S. F.
Moquinia hypoleuca DC., Prodromus 7(1): 23. 1838.
Gochnatia hypoleuca (DC.) A. Gray, Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences 19: 57. 1883.
Mexico. Neuvo León: Monterrey, January 1828, Berlandier 1391 (Holotype: G 00223915; Isotypes: BM 000947902, GH 00010616, K 000502540, MO 100221306, NY 00230667, P 00703318, P 00703319, P 00703320, US 00119521). [There is a second specimen at NY that is a possible isotype NY 00230666; the specimen from HAL 0112991 may be an isotype but the dates don’t match and the number is listed at “1391 s.n.”]
Shrub or small tree, 2–5(–7) m tall; leaves coriaceous, 2–5 × 0.9–1.5 cm, narrowly elliptic, apex obtuse, mucronate, attenuate at base, glabrous adaxially, cinereous-tomentose abaxially; heads sessile or very short pedunculate, in clusters of 5–15 heads at apices and axils of branches, many clusters per plant; involucre narrowly obconic, 4–7 mm tall × ca. 3 mm wide, bracts in ca. 3–5 series, ciliolate-tomentose on the margins but otherwise glabrous; flowers 5–7 per head; corollas white, 10–12 mm long; anther base caudate, tails ca. 1 mm long, fimbrillate; pappus ca. 6.5–7.5 mm long, bristles biseriate, of various lengths and broadening slightly at the tips.
Mexico: Coahuila, Nuevo León, Tamaulipas, Durango, Zacatecas, San Luis Potosi, Queretaro, Hidalgo, and Michoacán. United States: Arizona, Texas.
According to the Texas A&M University website (http://aggie-horticulture.tamu.edu/ornamentals/nativeshrubs/gochnatiahypole.htm) the common names for this shrub in Texas are Chomonque and Ocote. The website goes on to say that it is an “attractive, little-known shrub native to extreme South Texas, Chomonque flowers in the winter and has striking bi-colored leaves, very dark green on top and white and feltish underneath. The white flowers that appear from November to February are weakly fragrant and attract bees and many species of butterflies. It grows on gravel and caliche in South Texas shrub lands, and is extremely drought and heat tolerant. A specimen at the San Antonio Botanical Gardens has proved cold hardy and evergreen, but its cold-hardiness farther north is untested.” The website lists the USDA hardiness zone 9.
Gochnatia smithii B.L. Robinson & Greenm., Proc. Amer. Acad. Arts 32: 50. 1896.
Mexico. Oaxaca: On the hills of Cuicatlan, April 1895, L.C. Smith 363 (Lectotype: K designated by Cabrera, 1971: 140; Isolectotypes: GH 00008383, MEXU 00525748).
Shrub of undetermined size; leaves clustered near the ends of the branches, sub-coriaceous, 3–5 × 0.8–1.8 cm, ovate, obtuse, cuneate at base, glabrescent adaxially, cinereous-tomentose abaxially; heads slender, short-pedunculate, in dense clusters at the ends of branches, sometimes several clusters in a dense panicle, many clusters per plant; involucre narrowly obconic, 6–8 mm tall × ca. 3 mm wide, bracts in 5–7 series, ciliolate on the margins otherwise glabrous; flowers (3–)5–7 per head; corollas white, 8.5–9.0 mm long; anther base caudate, tails ca. 1.5 mm long, entire; pappus ca. 6.5–7.5 mm long, bristles biseriate, not obviously broadened at tips.
According to
Mexico: known only from Oaxaca.
No study of this type can be completed without the help of many people. Here we attempt to thank them; we hope we have not missed someone. We thank Thomas F. Patterson (TEX) for making several trips to find N. hypoleuca in Texas and for collecting leaf material on silica and taking beautiful photos; Tom Wendt (TEX) for supplying information on both N. hypoleuca in Texas and on the isotype of N. hiriartiana; Robert Mcgill (MO) for locating three missing isotypes; G, K, UC and US for providing high resolution images of the type material; JSTOR-GP for the always useful images of types from around the world (http://plants.jstor.org); Revista del Museo de La Plata for permission to use the drawings from