Research Article |
Corresponding author: Adam P. Karremans ( akarremans@gmail.com ) Academic editor: João Farminhão
© 2025 Adam P. Karremans, Franco Pupulin, John Gange, Diego Bogarín.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Karremans AP, Pupulin F, Gange J, Bogarín D (2025) Three new species of Pleurothallis (Orchidaceae) from Costa Rica and Panama, with a note on asexual reproduction by prolification in Pleurothallidinae. PhytoKeys 256: 197-220. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.256.140316
|
Three new species of Pleurothallis, each exhibiting prolific vegetative growth, are described from Costa Rica and western Panama. Prolification refers to the development of a vegetative bud from the axil of a bract within the floral meristem, a frequent condition in the Pleurothallidinae, where it manifests as a new ramicaul developed from the apex of a previous ramicaul. Prolification can be either constitutive or facultative, the latter occurring mostly under stress-induced, non-optimal growing conditions. The three new species are found at high elevations, between 1400 and 2550 m, in humid, dense, mossy conditions on the Talamanca range, where they naturally produce prolific growths on the ramicaul apex that sever from the plant with time. Pleurothallis matrisilvae sp. nov. superficially resembles P. bothros, but may be distinguished by the prolific habit, thin ramicauls, typically bearing 1–2 open flowers, the longer flower segments, the lanceolate petals, and the black flecks on the pedicel, ovary, and external surface of the sepals. Pleurothallis pridgeoniana sp. nov. is similar to P. vinealis but distinguished by the significantly shorter plants and ramicauls, the much smaller yellow flowers with a rose to purple suffusion, and the triangular-ovate lip with glandular margins and lacking a central sulcus. Pleurothallis winkeliana sp. nov., closely resembles P. longipetala, but differs by the occasionally prolific plant that produces clumps of ramicauls, the comparatively broader, cordate leaves with overlapping basal lobes, the smaller flower, and the pendent lip, perpendicular to the column.
Costa Rica, epiphytic orchids, Panama, prolific ramicaul, Talamanca range, vegetative growth
Pleurothallis R.Br. (
Vegetative morphology in Pleurothallis is somewhat uniform, members of this genus usually form caespitose plants with ramicauls emerging from the rhizome. But the three species treated here stand out for exhibiting a prolific growth habit. Prolification refers to the phenomenon in certain plants where the floral meristem develops a vegetative bud from the axil of a bract (
Prolific ramicauls in species across Pleurothallidinae A Zootrophion machaqwayi (JBL-4585) B Z. vulturiceps (Pupulin 3960) C Z. gracilentus (Pupulin 5220) D Lepanthopsis prolifera (JBL-458091) E Karma chaetoglossa (JBL-45847) F Karma sp. (Álvarez 1444) G Myoxanthus scandens (Rojas-Alvarado 1621) H Dresslerella pilosissima (Pupulin 8070) I Trichosalpinx sp. (Bogarín 11972) J Trichosalpinx blaisdellii (Fernández 123) K Andinia sp. (CIOA-001590) L Restrepia trichoglossa (Pupulin 7889) M Lepanthes sp. (Álvarez 1466) N Echinosepala uncinata (Chinchilla 1026) O E. longipedunculata (Rojas-Alvarado 570). Photographs and digital composition by FP.
Prolific ramicauls in species of Pleurothallis. Macrophyllae-fasciculate group A P. matrisilvae (Pupulin 8951) B P. phyllocardioides (Chinchilla 4380) C P. homalantha (Pupulin 9040) D Pleurothallis sp. (Fernández 250) E P. winkeliana (Chinchilla 3408) F P. palliolata (Bogarín 9101) G, H P. pridgeoniana (Chinchilla 2865). Macrophyllae-racemosae group. Ancipitae group I P. eumecocaulon (Rojas-Alvarado 1556) I P. crocodiliceps (Pupulin 5783). Pleurothallis group J P. ruscifolia (Pupulin 7013) K Pleurothallis cf. ruscifolia (Smith 261) L Pleurothallis sp. (Bogarín 5304) M P. rowleei (Pupulin 4352). Photographs and digital composition by FP and APK (G, H).
While preparing a monograph of the genus Pleurothallis for Costa Rica, we found three unidentified taxa with a prolific habit growing at high-elevations in the Talamanca mountain range. These novelties belong to Pleurothallis subsect. Macrophyllae-Fasciculatae [= Acronia sect. Macrophyllae-Fasciculatae (Lindl.) Luer] as defined by Luer (
Plant collection and documentation followed the methods described by
Standard characters states in Pleurothallis, such as green leaves, glabrous perianth parts, or regular and straight margins, are not mentioned expressly in the description. Terminology for the description of the inflorescences follows
Costa Rica. • Cartago: El Guarco, San Isidro, Madreselva, Tres de Junio, Carretera Interamericana Sur, 9°40'31"N, 83°53'33"W, 2530 m, bosque pluvial montano, en bosque secundario de robles a orillas de la carretera, 5 March 2022, fl. in cult. 8 March 2022, A.P. Karremans & J. Gange 9036 (holotype: JBL-spirit, M0058!; Fig.
Pleurothallis matrisilvae Karremans, J.Gange & Pupulin A habit, showing some ramicauls bearing flowers and others bearing new growths B single leaf with flower C flower D dissected perianth (dorsal sepal, two lateral petals, lateral sepals fused into a synsepal and two views of the lip) E column and lip, lateral view F column and ovary, lateral and ventral views G two views of the anther cap and pollinarium. LCDP prepared by APK based on Karremans 9036.
The flower is superficially similar to that of Pleurothallis bothros, however the new species may be distinguished by the prolific habit (vs. non-prolific), ramicauls linear, very thin throughout (vs. ramicauls subclavate, notably thickened apically), bearing 1–4 open flowers (vs. many, usually +10, simultaneous flowers), the longer flower segments (dorsal sepal 7.4–7.6 vs. 6.5–6.6 mm, lateral sepals 6.6 vs. 6.0 mm, petals 5.6–5.7 vs. 3.8–4.0 mm, lip 4.1–4.3 vs. 3.1–3.5 mm), the lanceolate petals (vs. oblong) and the black flecks on the pedicel, ovary, and external surface of the sepals (vs. no flecks).
Epiphytic, caespitose, constitutively prolific, suberect to erect herbs, up to 30 cm tall. Roots flexuous, thin, ca. 1 mm in diameter, densely spaced, appearing fasciculate. Ramicauls erect to suberect, slender, up to 28 cm long, covered by tubular sheaths close to the base, tightly adpressed, up to 5 cm long. Leaves spreading, glossy, dark green, coriaceous, sessile, ovate-cordate with downturned margins, acuminate, blades of the primary ramicaul 4.0–7.5 × 2.0–3.8 cm. Inflorescences persistent, forming few to several successive multi-flowered coflorescences, each producing a single open flower, up to 4 different coflorescences bearing simultaneous single flowers, typically 1 or 2, subtended by a nearly prostrate or suberect spathe which appears deeply torn during and after anthesis, ca. 1 cm long; pedicels terete, pale gray-yellow, with irregular black flecks. Ovary clavate, 4.5–4.7 mm long, gray-green and suffused with yellow, similarly marked with black. Flowers spreading, yellow. Dorsal sepal elliptic-ovate, slightly concave, obtuse, 3-veined, with irregular black flecks on its adaxial surface, 7.4–7.6 × 4.5 mm, apiculate. Lateral sepals connate in an oblong, slightly concave synsepal, obtuse, 4-veined, 6.6 × 5.8–5.9 mm. Petals linear-lanceolate, oblique, acute, 1-veined, 5.6–5.7 × 1.0–1.1 mm. Lip triangular-ovate, resting on the synsepal, 4.1–4.3 × 2.7–2.8, margins raised, apex slightly recurved, acute, glenion a deep cavity between the raised lateral margins. Column straight, transversely subrectangular, 1.7–1.9 mm long, apically 2.1 mm wide, with a ca. 1 mm column foot, the anther and stigma apical. Anther cap ovate, cucullate, obtuse at the base, bilobed apically, 2-celled. Pollinarium composed of 2, narrowly ovate-pyriform pollinia, connected to a liquid, drop-like viscidium. Fruits and seeds unknown. This description is based on A.P. Karremans & J. Gange 9036, D.E. Mora s.n., and D. Bogarín et al. 13652.
Costa Rica. • Cartago: Cordillera de Talamanca, alt. 2400 m, D.E. Mora s.n. (USJ!). Cartago: El Guarco, Cañón, Bajo Gloria, Centro Ecoturístico Los Robles, inicio del sendero Danta, 9°42'14.97"N, 83°54'55.96"W, 2332 m, epífitas en árboles alrededor de los senderos, bosque muy húmedo montano bajo, 12 February 2022, fl. in cult. 19 April 2022, D. Bogarín 13652, S. Bogarín, M. Bonilla & O.A. Pérez-Escobar (JBL-Spirit, E1544!; Fig.
Pleurothallis matrisilvae Karremans, J.Gange & Pupulin composite A the florally similar P. bothros (JBL-sn) B bearing a single open flower and several developing buds (Bogarín 13652) C epiphytic plant in its natural habitat in Madreselva on the central Talamanca range, showing the prolific growth and asexual production of new units. Photographs by APK.
From the Latin “matrisilva”, mother-forest, honoring the locality Madreselva, where the type specimen was collected.
Flowering has been recorded at least from November to April, which approximately corresponds to the end of the rainy season and the first months of the dry season in Costa Rica.
Currently known only from central Costa Rica, where the species is found growing either epiphytically, mainly on oaks, or terrestrially, on the leaf mulch rich ground, in montane or cloud forests at high elevations around 2300–2550 m (Fig.
Contrary to the other species described here, Pleurothallis matrisilvae is typically prolific when growing as an epiphyte, while it is mostly non-prolific when found growing on top of organic matter on the ground. The new species is morphologically similar to P. bothros and its relatives. It, however, grows at higher elevations and is distinguished by the often-prolific habit, the thin ramicauls and especially by having mainly one or two flowers open at once, which is unlike all other species in the P. bothros group (
Costa Rica. Puntarenas: Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, camino a Cerros Utyum, 9°18'04.93"N, 83°12'51.59"W, 2157 m, bosque pluvial montano bajo, epífitas en bosque secundario, 16 January 2017, fl. in cult. 20 December 2017, A.P. Karremans, D. Bogarín, M. Cedeño, I. Chinchilla, M. Díaz, E. Kaes, P. Lehmann & O. Zúñiga 7600 (holotype: JBL-spirit, E1514!; isotype, USJ!; Fig.
Pleurothallis pridgeoniana Karremans, Bogarín & Pupulin A habit showing the typical prolific vegetative growth B prolific growth featuring a single flower on a secondary ramicaul C flower D dissected perianth (dorsal sepal, two lateral petals, two lateral sepals fused into a synsepal and a view of the lip) E lip F column and lip, lateral view G column, lip and ovary, lateral view H anther cap and pollinarium. LCDP prepared by APK based on Karremans 7600 (A, C–H) and Bogarin 8632 (B).
Vegetatively similar to P. vinealis, but distinguished by the significantly shorter plants, up to 30 cm long (vs. exceeding 1 m), the shorter ramicauls 7.5–26.0 cm (vs. up to 40 cm long), the significantly smaller dorsal sepal (6.8–7.0 × 3.3–3.4 mm vs. 11–14 × 4.5–5.5 mm), synsepal (5.5–6.5 × 4.1–4.2 mm vs. 11–14 × 4.5–5.5 mm), and lip (2.4–2.6 × 1.6–1.7 mm vs. 5.5–6.5 × 3 mm). The flowers are transparent yellow, with a rose to purple suffusion (vs. brown), the lip is triangular-ovate (vs. oblong) the margins being shortly glandular (vs. denticulate), slightly raised but lacking a central sulcus (vs. prominently sulcate).
Epiphytic, caespitose, strictly prolific, erect to suberect herb, up to 30 cm long. Roots flexuous, thin, ca. 1 mm in diameter, densely spaced, appearing fasciculate. Primary ramicauls erect to suberect, slender, 7.5–26.0 cm long, with 2 basal tubular, tightly adpressed, papyraceous sheaths, up to 2.0–6.0 cm long. Secondary ramicauls 1.5–8.0 cm long, produced profusely from the floral meristem on the apex of prior ramicauls, being able to produce clumps and chains of multiple ramicauls before severing naturally. Leaves spreading to pendent, coriaceous, sessile, narrowly ovate to cordate, acute, blades of primary ramicauls 4.0–7.7 × 1.8–5.0 cm, blades on secondary ramicauls 2.5–5.2 × 1.0–2.5 cm. Inflorescence persistent, forming successive multi-flowered coflorescences with a single open flower, subtended by a nearly prostrate or suberect spathe which appears deeply torn over time, ca. 1 cm long; pedicels cylindrical. Ovary slightly clavate, ca. 3 mm long, green, with a few black dots and occasional crystals. Flowers spreading, transparent yellow, with a rose to purple suffusion of varying intensity, especially observed on the petals, lip, column, and anther cap. Dorsal sepal narrowly ovate to elliptic, acute, 3-veined, 6.8–7.0 × 3.3–3.4 mm. Lateral sepals connate in an ovate synsepal, acute, 4-veined, 5.5–6.5 × 4.1–4.2 mm. Petals naturally drooping, linear-lanceolate, oblique, acute, 1-veined, 5.1–5.4 × 0.6–0.7 mm, glandular, with the margins erose. Lip triangular-ovate, resting on the synsepal, 2.4–2.6 × 1.6–1.7 mm, blade glandular-papillose, margins minutely glandular, slightly raised, acute, shortly apiculate, with a pair of shoulder-like basal lobes. Glenion a shallow, oblong cavity between raised lateral margins. Column straight, transversely suboblong, ca. 1.5 mm long, with a short column foot, the anther and stigma apical. Anther cap ovate, cucullate, obtuse, 2-celled. Pollinarium composed of 2 narrowly ovate-pyriform pollinia connected to a liquid, drop-like viscidium. Fruits and seeds unknown. This description is based on A.P. Karremans et al. 7600, A.P. Karremans et al. 9135, D. Bogarín et al. 8632, D. Bogarín et al. 12131 and I. Chinchilla et al. 2865.
Costa Rica-Panama. • Puntarenas-Chiriquí: Coto Brus-Renacimiento, línea fronteriza entre Cerro Quijada del Diablo y Cerro Pando, entre mojones N.336–338, 8°54'51.9"N, 82°43'59.13"W, 2205 m, bosque muy húmedo premontano, epífita en bosque primario, “in itinere per limitem Costa Rica et Panama inter montis Quijada del Diablo et montis Pando”, 19 April 2011, fl. in cult. 14 March 2022, D. Bogarín, D. Jiménez & A.P. Karremans 8632 (JBL-spirit, E1542!, Fig.
Floral variation in Pleurothallis pridgeoniana A Fernández 385 B Bogarin 7742 C Karremans s.n. D Bogarín 7743 E Bogarín 7718 F Bogarín 9806 G Fernández 382 H Bogarin 7718 I Karremans 2829 J Pupulin 7893 K Pupulin 7910 L Fernández 382 M Karremans 5685 N Bogarin 7718 O Bogarin 9806 P Karremans s.n. Q Pupulin 7887 R Chinchilla 5865 S, T Diaz 305. Photographs by the authors.
Honoring the English botanist Alec M. Pridgeon, renowned worldwide for his seminal research on orchid anatomy and phylogenetics, including Pleurothallidinae. A founding editor of the journal Lindleyana and main editor of the monumental series of books Genera Orchidacearum, which laid the foundation for the contemporary understanding of orchid relationships.
Plants in cultivation have been recorded in flower virtually year-round, with flowering peaks in November and February, coinciding in Costa Rica with the end of the rainy season and the beginning of the dry season.
Currently known only from southern Costa Rica and western Panama, where plants grow either epiphytically or terrestrially on organic matter in oak forests at high elevations, around 1800–2550 m. Pleurothallis pridgeoniana is locally abundant at high elevations on the Cordillera de Talamanca, in the Puntarenas (Costa Rica) and Chiriquí (Panama) provinces respectively. This notoriously prolific species is often found forming large pending mats or clumps in primary and mature forests.
Pleurothallis pridgeoniana is easily recognized by the large bushy habit derived from constitutive prolification, in which each ramicaul eventually produces vegetative growths apically, thus originating chains of multiple ramicauls (Fig.
Pleurothallis pridgeoniana Karremans, Bogarín & Pupulin in its natural habitat in Valle del Silencio on the southern Talamanca range in Costa Rica, close to the border with Panama A general overview of the prolific growth habit and asexual production of new units B detail of a flowering plant. Photographs by APK.
Florally, the non-prolific Pleurothallis applanata Luer & Dalström and P. undulata Poepp. & Endl. (following
Costa Rica. • Puntarenas: Coto Brus, Sabalito, Zona Protectora Las Tablas, 13 km al noreste de Lucha, Sitio Coto Brus, entre Río Surá y Quebrada Sutú, Finca de Miguel Sandí, 8°56'46.1"N, 82°44'30.9"W, 1778 m, bosque pluvial montano bajo, epífita en potreros arbolados, 20 April 2012, fl. in cult. 25 June 2012, A.P. Karremans & J. Geml 5403 (holotype: JBL-spirit, E0966!; Figs
Pleurothallis winkeliana Karremans, Bogarín & Pupulin A habit showing some prolific vegetative growths B flower C dissected perianth (dorsal sepal, two lateral petals, two lateral sepals fused into a synsepal and a view of the lip) D two views of the lip E column and lip, lateral view F column and ovary, ventral, dorsal and lateral views G anther cap and two views of the pollinarium. LCDP prepared by FP based on Karremans 5403.
Morphologically closely resembling P. longipetala Bogarín & Belfort, but distinguished by the occasionally prolific plant that produces clumps of ramicauls (vs. non-prolific), the proportionally broader (ratio length:width = 2:1 vs 3:1) leaves, cordate in shape (vs. narrowly ovate-lanceolate) with overlapping basal lobes (vs. basal lobes non-overlapping), the smaller flower (<1.5 vs > 2 .0 cm), the shorter and narrower petals (5.4–5.7 × 0.7–0.8 vs. 7.9–8.6 × 1.6–1.7 mm) and by the lip, which is pendent and perpendicular to the column (vs erect, parallel to the column), and obscurely glandular (vs. thickly verrucose).
Epiphytic, caespitose, occasionally prolific, erect to suberect herb, up to 25 cm tall. Roots flexuous, thin, ca. 1 mm in diameter, densely spaced, appearing fasciculate. Primary ramicauls erect to suberect, slender, up to 9.0–23.0 cm long, with 2 tubular, tightly adpressed, papyraceous sheaths, up to 2.5–4.3 cm long, one close to the base, and another reaching the middle of the ramicaul. Secondary ramicauls 1.0–3.5 cm long, produced profusely from the floral meristem on the apex of primary ramicaul, being able to produce clumps of multiple ramicauls before severing naturally. Leaves horizontal to suberect, coriaceous, sessile, cordate, acute, with the basal lobes confluent to overlapping. Blades of primary ramicauls 4.0–9.6 × 1.5–4.0 cm, blades on secondary ramicauls 1.5–5.4 × 0.6–1.7 cm. Inflorescences persistent, forming successive multi-flowered coflorescences with a single open flower, subtended by a nearly prostrate or suberect spathe which appears deeply torn over time, ca. 1 cm long; pedicels terete, pale gray-yellow, with irregular black flecks. Ovary slightly clavate, bent, 3.0–3.2 mm long, green, with occasional black dots. Flowers spreading, transparent purple, with dark purple petals and lip, a whitish column, suffused with pink, and a yellowish anther cap. Dorsal sepal elliptic, acute, 3-veined, 8.5 × 4.0–4.2 mm. Lateral sepals connate in a narrowly ovate synsepal, acute, 4-veined, 7.3–7.8 × 4.7–4.8 mm. Petals linear, oblique, acute, 1-veined, 5.4–5.7 × 0.7–0.8 mm, with glandular margins. Lip triangular-ovate, resting on the synsepal, 2.6–2.8 × 2.3 mm, blade glandular, margins glandular-erose, acute, shortly apiculate, glenion a deep, oblong basal cavity. Column straight, transversely subrectangular, ca. 1.5 mm long, with a very short, glandular column foot, the anther and stigma apical. Anther cap ovate, cucullate, obtuse, 2-celled. Pollinarium composed of 2, narrowly ovate-pyriform pollinia, connected to a liquid, drop-like viscidium. Fruits and seeds unknown. This description is based on A.P. Karremans & J. Geml 5403.
Costa Rica. • Limón: Talamanca, Telire. Cordillera de Talamanca, Parque Internacional La Amistad (ACLA-C), sendero de la transtalamanca, bajando de la Fila Bugú hacia el Río Tapari, 09°26'48.00"N, 83°11'12.00"W, 1380 m, bosque pluvial premontano, bosque primario, epífita, a media luz, collected 27 April 2017, I. Chinchilla 3408, A.P. Karremans, G. Rojas-Alvarado, M. Cedeño, E. Kaes & O. Zúñiga [JBL-spirit, J0784! (prepared 14 May 2018), A0366! (prepared 2 May 2019)]. • Puntarenas: Buenos Aires, Potrero Grande, Altamira, Parque Internacional La Amistad, Sector Altamira, sendero al Valle del Silencio, cerca Cerro Hoffman, 9°04'56.2"N, 82°58'36.4"W, 2347 m, bosque pluvial montano, 30 August 2011, D. Bogarín 9138 & A.P. Karremans (Fig.
Honoring Dutch botanist Gab van Winkel (1955–2023), late editor of Orchideeën, journal of the Dutch Orchid Society (Nederlandse Orchideeën Vereniging), and director of the official website of the European Orchid Council (EOC). Gab has been recognized for devoting his life to the study of orchids (
Flowering of P. winkeliana has been recorded from November to July, mostly corresponding to the dry season in Costa Rica.
Currently known only from the southern Cordillera de Talamanca in Costa Rica, where plants grow epiphytically in primary forests at around 1400–2300 m of elevation. Pleurothallis winkeliana appears to be rare but is found on both watersheds of the Cordillera de Talamanca in southern Costa Rica, close to the Panamanian border, where it has been recorded in the neighboring Limón and Puntarenas provinces.
Pleurothallis winkeliana belongs to the P. phyllocardia assemblage (sensu
Despite occurring across the Pleurothallidinae (Figs
Recent studies indicate that the highest rates of orchid speciation in the Neotropics occur in the humid and seasonal forests of Costa Rica and Panama (
The description of the three new Pleurothallis brings the total for the genus in Costa Rica to 67 species and four natural hybrids. In Costa Rica, Pleurothallis includes several species complexes that represent local radiations for which multiple species still require recognition, despite recent efforts. Novelties are often found on the highly diverse and largely unexplored Talamanca range in central and southern Costa Rica (Fig.
To date, detailed analyses of species distributions have not been conducted, partly due to unresolved taxonomic issues and the lack of accuracy in species identification within many diverse or understudied genera of Pleurothallidinae, such as Lepanthes, Pleurothallis, and Stelis. Nevertheless, data available on Pleurothallis suggest distinct distribution patterns among Costa Rica’s mountain ranges. For instance, P. chavezii Luer is found only in the Cordillera de Guanacaste, while P. adventurae Karremans & Bogarín, P. anthurioides, and P. maduroi Luer are exclusive to the Cordillera de Talamanca. In contrast, other species, such as Pleurothallis tonduzii Schltr., have a broader distribution across all mountain ranges. Meanwhile, P. angusta Ames & C.Schweinf., and P. phyllocardia Rchb.f. are widespread in the Cordillera de Talamanca and Cordillera Central but do not extend to the Cordillera de Tilarán or Guanacaste (
A comprehensive study comparing the diversity of orchids across Costa Rica’s mountain ranges has not yet been conducted. By completing the ongoing taxonomic work on these complex and diverse groups within Pleurothallis, integrating new distribution data from recently described species, we can establish a stronger foundation for more accurate biogeographical analyses.
We are very thankful to an anonymous reviewer, Dr. Mark Wilson, and especially the editor João Farminhão for their comments, as they made us rethink and strengthen our arguments. We are grateful to Grettel Salguero for assistance with the documentation of these plants. We are thankful to the Costa Rican Ministry of Environment and Energy (MINAE) and its National System of Conservation Areas (SINAC) for the scientific permit R-SINAC-SE-DT-PI-005-2024. This research is in part possible through the project C1057: “Flora Costaricensis: taxonomía y filogenia de la subtribu Pleurothallidinae (Orchidaceae): el grupo Macrophyllae-Fasciculatae de Pleurothallis en Costa Rica”, supported by the Vice-Presidency of Research of the University of Costa Rica.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
This work was supported by the Vice-Presidency of Research of the University of Costa Rica.
APK, FP & DB conceptualization, research, fieldwork, photography, writting and editing. JG fieldwork and photography.
Adam P. Karremans https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5987-7710
Franco Pupulin https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6780-8395
John Gange https://orcid.org/0009-0008-2868-9248
Diego Bogarín https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8408-8841
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text.