Research Article
Print
Research Article
Several new combinations from previous Didymocarpus to Palmatiboea (Gesneriaceae)
expand article infoFang Wen§, Qiang Fan|
‡ Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region and Chinese Academy of Science, Guilin, China
§ Gesneriad Conservation Center of China (GCCC), Guilin, China
| Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, China
Open Access

Abstract

The recently published species, Didymocarpus pingyuanensis, is transferred here to the recently re-circumscribed genus, Palmatiboea. Two varieties, recently assigned to Palmatiboea, have been raised to the rank of species. Their Chinese vernacular names are also revised and provided here.

Key words

China, Didymocarpus, Didymocarpus pingyuanensis, Gesneriacese, nomenclature, Palmatiboea

Introduction

The genus, Didymocarpus Wall., which was established over 200 years ago (Wallich 1819), has become one of the most frequently revised genera within Gesneriaceae. Because of different taxonomic perspectives, morphological evidence has revealed significant macroscopic and even microscopic variation both within and between species of the genus, with highly diverse geographical distributions further complicating its classification. As a result, the genus has gained a reputation as a “repository” or “dumping ground” for morphologically disparate species. At the same time, it has also incorporated a considerable number of species that are highly similar in external morphology (Burtt and Wiehler 1995; Burtt 1997; Vitek et al. 2000; Weber et al. 2000; Liu et al. 2024).

A revision 27 years ago defined the narrow sense of Didymocarpus s. str., which includes two sections: Didymocarpus sect. Didymocarpus and Didymocarpus sect. Elati Ridl., distributed across Southwest China, the greater Himalayan region, and the Indochinese Peninsula (Weber and Burtt 1997). However, the Chinese species of this genus were divided into two sections: stemmed herbaceous plants (Didymocarpus sect. Didymocarpus) and stemless herbaceous plants (Didymocarpus sect. Heteroboea W.T.Wang) (Wang et al. 1990, 1998; Li and Wang 2005). Sect. Heteroboea was originally defined based on morphological characteristics, but recent systematic studies and morphological comparisons have reassigned five species to the genus Petrocodon Hance. These species are: P. bonii (Pellegr.) A.Weber & Mich.Möller, distributed along the northern edge of the Indochina Peninsula; P. mollifolius (W.T.Wang) A.Weber & Mich.Möller, P. subpalmatinervis (W.T.Wang) F.Wen & Z.L.Li, and P. niveolanosus (D.Fang & W.T.Wang) A.Weber & Mich.Möller, found in Southwest China; and P. hancei (Hemsl.) Mich.Möller & A.Weber, distributed in South China (Guangxi and Guangdong) and Central China (Hunan) (Weber et al. 2011; Li et al. 2023).

After the publication of Flora Reipublicae Popularis Sinicae (Vol. 69) (Wang et al. 1990), four new taxa were discovered and described within sect. Heteroboea: Didymocarpus dissectus F.Wen, Y.L.Qiu, Jie Huang & Y.G.Wei (Wen et al. 2013), found in Fujian Province; D. heucherifolius Hand.-Mazz var. yinzhengii J.M.Li & S.J.Li (Li and Li 2014), found in Hunan Province; D. heucherifolius Hand.-Mazz var. gamosepalus Xin Hong & F.Wen (Xu et al. 2019), found in Guangdong Province; and D. lobulatus F.Wen, Xin Hong & W.Y.Xie (Xie et al. 2020), found in Zhejiang Province.

After multiple revisions, the number of species included in the genus Didymocarpus has decreased from over 180 species at its peak to approximately 110 species. However, some unresolved taxonomic issues remain. Recently, the study by Liu et al. (2024) addressed the longstanding taxonomic status of sect. Heteroboea, which is endemic to China and has been a subject of debate within Didymocarpus s. str.

Liu et al. (2024) conducted phylogenetic analyses with comprehensive sampling across Didymocarpus and related genera, utilizing four nuclear ribosomal DNA markers and five chloroplast DNA regions. The results revealed that Didymocarpus is not monophyletic. Based on a combination of molecular phylogenetic and morphological data, the circumscription of Didymocarpus s. str. was redefined. A new genus, Palmatiboea F.P.Liu & Yin Z.Wang, is established to accommodate those species previously assigned to Didymocarpus sect. Heteroboea. Palmatiboea is clearly differentiated from Didymocarpus s. str., not only in molecular and morphological characteristics but also in its distinct geographic distribution, as it is restricted to Southeast and South China. Table 1 shows the species originally classified under Didymocarpus that have been revised and reassigned to the genus Palmatiboea by Liu et al. (2024).

Table 1.

The species originally from Didymocarpus that have been reassigned to Palmatiboea in Liu et al. 2024.

No. The original scientific names of species in Didymocarpus The original Chinese name The revised species scientific names in Palmatiboea The revised Chinese name
1 Didymocarpus cortusifolius (Hance) Lévl. 温州长蒴苣苔 Palmatiboea cortusifolia (Hance) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang* 温州掌脉苣苔
2 Didymocarpus dissectus F.Wen, Y.L.Qiu, Jie Huang & Y.G.Wei 深裂长蒴苣苔 Palmatiboea dissecta (F.Wen, Y.L.Qiu, Jie Huang & Y.G.Wei) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang* 深裂掌脉苣苔
3 Didymocarpus heucherifolius Hand.-Mazz. 闽赣长蒴苣苔 Palmatiboea heucherifolia (Hand.-Mazz.) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang* 闽赣掌脉苣苔
4 Didymocarpus heucherifolius var. gamosepalus Xin Hong & F.Wen 合萼长蒴苣苔 Palmatiboea heucherifolia var. gamosepala (Xin Hong & F.Wen) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang* 合萼掌脉苣苔
5 Didymocarpus heucherifolius var. yinzhengii J.M.Li & S.J.Li 印政长蒴苣苔 Palmatiboea heucherifolia var. yinzhengii (J.M.Li & S.J.Li) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang* 印政掌脉苣苔
6 Didymocarpus lobulatus F.Wen, Xin Hong & W.Y.Xie 浙东长蒴苣苔 Palmatiboea lobulata (F.Wen, Xin Hong & W.Y.Xie) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang* 浙东掌脉苣苔
7 Didymocarpus sinoprimulinus W.T.Wang 报春长蒴苣苔 Palmatiboea sinoprimulia (W.T.Wang) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang* 报春掌脉苣苔
8 Didymocarpus reniformis W.T.Wang 肾叶长蒴苣苔 Palmatiboea reniformis (W.T.Wang) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang* 肾叶掌脉苣苔
9 Didymocarpus salviiflorus Chun 迭裂长蒴苣苔 Palmatiboea salviiflora (Chun) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang* 迭裂苣苔(应更正为迭裂掌脉苣苔) Should be changed as 迭裂掌脉苣苔
10 Didymocarpus yuenlingensis W.T.Wang 沅陵长蒴苣苔 Palmatiboea yuenlingensis (W.T.Wang) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang* 沅陵掌脉苣苔

However, Liu et al. (2024) did not elevate the two infraspecific taxa (varieties) listed in Table 1 to species rank. In a nearly concurrent study on Didymocarpus sect. Heteroboea distributed in southern to southeastern China, two varieties mentioned in Table 1 have already been elevated to the species level: Didymocarpus heucherifolius var. gamosepalus Xin Hong & F.Wen was revised to D. gamosepalus (Xin Hong & F.Wen) Ling H.Yang, Q.Fan & F.Wen, and D. heucherifolius var. yinzhengii J.M.Li & S.J.Li was revised to D. yinzhengii (J.M.Li & S.J.Li) Ling H.Yang, Q.Fan & F.Wen (Yang et al. 2024). The two research teams focused on different taxonomic levels—one at the genus level and the other at the species level—leading to slight discrepancies in their conclusions on the same taxonomic issues.

In the study by Yang et al. (2024), a new species, Didymocarpus pingyuanensis Ling H.Yang, Q.Fan & F.Wen, from northeastern Guangdong, China, was described and compared with D. heucherifolius var. gamosepalus and D. salviiflorus, two species that have since been transferred to the genus Palmatiboea as P. heucherifolius var. gamosepalus and P. salviiflora. Based on the morphological characteristics of this new species, Didymocarpus pingyuanensis aligns closely with the concept of Palmatiboea, suggesting that it should be transferred to the new genus.

Nomenclature

Palmatiboea pingyuanensis (Ling H.Yang, Q.Fan & F.Wen) F.Wen & Q.Fan, comb. nov.

Didymocarpus pingyuanensis Ling H.Yang, Q.Fan & F.Wen in Yang et al., Phytokeys 224: 218 (2024).

Type

China • Guangdong Province: Meizhou City, Pingyuan Town, 24°32'N, 115°50'E, 491 m a.s.l., 1 April 2023 (fl.), Qiang Fan, Xing-yue Zhang, Li-Juan Liao, Jie-Hao Jin, Ling-Han Yang DNPC 3352 (holotype: SYS!; isotypes: IBK! IBSC! SYS!)

The Chinese vernacular name

平远掌脉苣苔 (Píng Yuǎn Zhǎng Mài Jù Tái).

Palmatiboea yinzhengii (J.M.Li & S.J.Li.) F.Wen & Q.Fan, comb. nov.

Didymocarpus heucherifolius var. yinzhengii J.M.Li & S.J.Li, in Phytotaxa 156 (3): 187. 2014.

Palmatiboea heucherifolia var. yinzhengii (J.M.Li & S.J.Li) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang, in Journal of Systematic and Evolution doi: 10.1111/jse.13124:13.2024.

Type

China • Hunan: near Yongxing County. alt. 300 m, 26°17'10"N, 113°11'25"E, 6 May 2011, Jia-Mei Li 1105062 (holotype: HEAC!); ibid. Jia-Mei Li 11501 (paratype: IBK!).

Palmatiboea gamosepalus (Xin Hong & F.Wen) F.Wen & Q.Fan, comb. nov.

Didymocarpus heucherifolius var. gamosepalus Xin Hong & F.Wen, in Phyto­Keys 128: 34. 2019.

Palmatiboea heucherifolia var. gamosepala (Xin Hong & F.Wen) F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang, in Journal of Systematic and Evolution doi: 10.1111/jse.13124: 13. 2024.

Type

China • Guangxi Province, cultivated in the nursery of Gesneriad Conservation Center of China (GCCC), introduced from north of Guangdong Province: Pingyuan County, Meizhou City, growing in rocky crevices at the foot of a calcareous sedimentary rocky hill. 22 February 2019, flowering, WF20190222-05 (holotype: IBK!; isotype: AHU!)

Notes

We have noticed that several newly revised species and genera names use the name abbreviation of the corresponding author Yin-Zheng Wang as “Y.Z.Wang,” such as the names of the two new genera, Palmatiboea F.P.Liu & Y.Z.Wang and Hequnia Y.Z.Wang & F.P.Liu in Liu et al. (2024). However, the name abbreviation “Y.Z.Wang” originates from Prof. Wang Yun-Zhang, a renowned Chinese mycologist and plant pathologist, whose name abbreviation first appeared in the 1980s when he described 15 new species of Rust Fungi (Wang et al. 1980). Prof. Wang Yin-Zheng, on the other hand, first published a new taxon in the mid-1990s, Whytockia purpurascens Yin Z.Wang and W. hekouensis Yin Z.Wang (Wang 1995). When W. purpurascens and W. hekouensis were published, the author’s name abbreviation was mistakenly written as “Y.Z.Wang.” However, the abbreviation “Y.Z.Wang” for Prof. Wang Yun-Zhang appeared 15 years earlier than that of Prof. Wang Yin-Zheng when describing new taxa (IPNI 2024); therefore, for the aforementioned nomenclature, including the new genera Palmatiboea and Hequnia and their respective species. Additionally, there are quite a few revised species of Gesneriaceae that incorrectly use “Y.Z.Wang” to refer to Prof. Wang Yin-Zheng. For example, Petrocosmea shilinensis Y.M.Shui & H.T.Zhao var. changhuensis T.F.Lü & Y.Z.Wang should be changed as P. shilinensis var. changhuensis T.F.Lü & Yin Z.Wang (Li et al. 2020), and so on. In summary, the correct name abbreviation should be “Yin Z.Wang,” not “Y.Z.Wang” among the many revised species epithets of Gesneriaceae mentioned above.

Acknowledgements

We like to thank Robert Mill for critical comments on the manuscript. We also thank anonymous reviewers for their comments on an earlier draft of this paper.

Additional information

Conflict of interest

The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

Ethical statement

No ethical statement was reported.

Funding

This study was financially supported by the Guangxi Natural Science Foundation (2024GXNSFAA010462), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (32260782, 32460422), the Guangdong Provincial Special Research Grant for the Creation of National Parks (2021GJGY034).

Author contributions

All authors have contributed equally.

Author ORCIDs

Fang Wen https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3889-8835

Qiang Fan https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4254-6936

Data availability

All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text.

References

  • Burtt B (1997) Taxonomic history of Didymocarpus and Henckelia (Gesneriaceae). Beitrage zur Biologie der Pflanzen 70: 365–375.
  • Burtt B, Wiehler H (1995) Classification of the family Gesneriaceae. Gesneriana 11: 1–4.
  • IPNI (2024) [continuously updated] International Plant Names Index. The Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, the Harvard University Herbaria and the Australian National Herbarium. https://www.ipni.org/ [Accessed 1st November 2024]
  • Li ZY, Wang YZ (2005) Plants of Gesneriaceae in China. Henan Science and Technology Publishing House, Zhengzhou, 283–299.
  • Li CQ, Lü TF, Han MQ, Dong Y, Li PW, Liu Y, Wang YZ (2020) Reversal versus specialization in floral morphological evolution in Petrocosmea (Gesneriaceae). Journal of Systematics and Evolution 58(2): 145–158. https://doi.org/10.1111/jse.12541
  • Liu FP, Han MQ, Li PW, Wang YZ (2024) Phylogenetic Reconstruction of Didymocarpus and Related Genera in Gesneriaceae with Establishment of Two New Genera. Journal of Systematics and Evolution, jse.13124. https://doi.org/10.1111/jse.13124
  • Vitek E, Weber A, Burtt B (2000) Names, types and current placement of the species hitherto referred to Didymocarpus, Loxocarpus, Codonoboea, Platyadenia and Henckelia (Gesneriaceae). Annalen des Naturhistorischen Museums in Wien. Serie B, Fur Botanik und Zoologie 102B: 477–530.
  • Wallich N (1819) Dr Wallach on the progress of botany in Bengal. Edinburgh Philosophical Journal 1: 378.
  • Wang YZ (1995) Two new species of Whytockia (Gesneriaceae) from Yunnan. Acta Phytotaxonomica Sinica 33(3): 297–301. [in Chinese]
  • Wang YZ, Han SJ, Wei SX, Guo L, Chen MM (1980) New Rust Fungi from Western China. Acta Microbiologica Sinica 20(1): 16–28.
  • Wang WT, Pan KY, Zhang ZY, Li ZY, Tao DD, Yin WC (1990) Gesneriaceae. In: Wang WT (Ed.) Flora Reipublicae Popularis Sinicae. Vol. 69. Science Press, Beijing, 419–451.
  • Wang WT, Pan KY, Li ZY, Weitzman AL, Skog LE (1998) Gesneriaceae. In: Wu ZY, Raven PH (Eds) Flora of China Vol. 18. Science Press, Beijing, and Missouri Botanical Garden Press, St. Louis, 322–333.
  • Weber A, Burtt B (1997) Remodelling of Didymocarpus and associated genera (Gesneriaceae). Beitrage zur Biologie der Pflanzen 70: 293–364.
  • Weber A, Burtt B, Vitek E (2000) Materials for a revision of Didymocarpus (Gesneriaceae). Annalen des Naturhistorischen Museums in Wien. Serie B, Fur Botanik und Zoologie 102B: 441–475.
  • Yang LH, Dai JM, Wen F, Liu JH, Lan XZ, Fan Q (2024) Didymocarpus pingyuanensis (Gesneriaceae), a new species endemic to Danxia landscape from Guangdong Province, China, and two new combinations in Didymocarpus. PhytoKeys 244: 213–224. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.244.126137
login to comment