Research Article |
Corresponding author: Robberson Bernal Setubal ( rbsetubal@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Petra De Block
© 2024 Robberson Bernal Setubal, Lena Struwe, Jefferson Prado, Rafaela Campostrini Forzza.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Setubal RB, Struwe L, Prado J, Forzza RC (2024) Clarifying the nomenclature of Strychnos bredemeyeri and Lasiostoma (Loganiaceae). PhytoKeys 243: 137-148. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.243.123921
|
Strychnos (Loganiaceae, Gentianales) is a large and pantropical genus of woody plants, ethnobotanically important as a source of many toxic alkaloids, including strychnine. Unfortunately, the status of numerous names at various ranks of Strychnos remains unresolved, including that of many specific or infraspecific taxa in the Neotropics. In this study, we address Strychnos bredemeyeri (basionym Lasiostoma bredemeyeri), a species described in 1827 based on type material collected in Venezuela during the poorly documented Austrian Märter expedition (1783–1788). Strychnos bredemeyeri is an unarmed liana with solitary tendrils and axillary inflorescences that occurs in Neotropical rainforests and savannas in Brazil, Guyana, Trinidad and Tobago, and Venezuela. We clarify here the nomenclatural status of Lasiostoma Schreb., an illegitimate and superfluous genus currently in synonymy under Strychnos, and its former species Lasiostoma bredemeyeri [= Strychnos bredemeyeri]. Also, we lectotypify S. pedunculata and S. trinitensis, both taxa currently synonyms of S. bredemeyeri.
Classification, Gentianales, Neotropics, nomenclature, Strychneae, systematics
Strychnos L. is a pantropical genus of lianas, shrubs, or trees with ca. 200 spp., making it the largest genus in Loganiaceae (Gentianales;
Rouhamon was published by the French pharmacist and botanist Jean Baptiste C. F. Aublet based only on the type species R. guianensis Aubl. (
Lasiostoma bredemeyeri was published based on material collected by Franz Bredemeyer, a gardener who traveled from Austria to Martinique, Puerto Rico, and Venezuela on the poorly documented Franz Joseph Märter expedition during 1783–1788 (
After the publication of Lasiostoma bredemeyeri,
Rouhamon pedunculatum A.DC. [= S. pedunculata] was published in
No further information about the correct nomenclatural status of the genus Lasiostoma Schreb., the basionym of S. bredemeyeri, and the location of Bredemeyer’s specimen at B was published by Krukoff in his subsequent publications (
We examined herbarium material from 13 herbaria; seen in-person at F, GH, NY, and US; or seen online as digital images from B, BM, G, GOET, K, P, TCD, TRIN, and W (acronyms according to Thiers, updated continuously). All nomenclatural actions follow the Shenzhen Code (
We found two specimens of the type material of Lasiostoma bredemeyeri, the lectotype designated by
Type specimens of Lasiostoma bredemeyeri Schult. & Schult.f A lectotype conserved in the Jacquin herbarium at W (Bredemeyer s.n.; W barcode W0078191) B, C isolectotype conserved in the Willdenow herbarium at B (Bredemeyer s.n.; B barcodes BW02865000 and BW02865010, respectively).
Krukoff never mentioned Bredemeyer’s specimen at B (BW02865000, BW02865010) in any of his subsequent works (
A–C sheet deposited in the type photograph collection of the New York Botanical Garden (Negative No. 1163; sheet without barcode or access number and not available online) containing a photograph of the isolectotype of Lasiostoma bredemeyeri Schult. & Schult.f. conserved in the Willdenow herbarium at B (Bredemeyer s.n.; Fig.
Despite the illegitimacy of Lasiostoma Schreb. and considering that a validating description need not be diagnostic of the new taxon (
The type material of Rouhamon pedunculatum was collected during the brothers Robert (R.H. Schomburgk) and Richard Schomburgk’s (M.R. Schomburgk) expedition to Guyana in 1840–1844. While the protologue of the species mentions the type locality as “In Guyana brit. ad Roraima”, the route indicated on the map and the respective text in
Three specimens without original labels but bearing written indications of “Schomburgk” and “Br. Guiana” have the alternative collector number “792” (photograph of specimen at F, Catalog No. 620082; not available online – not to be confused with F barcode V0044336F; see further) or “792.B” (K barcodes K000573484 and K000573485; Fig.
Comparison of labels on four specimens of Rouhamon pedunculatum A.DC A lectotype showing original label “Schomburgk 482” (G barcode G00132188) B–D specimens of R. pedunculatum without original labels and containing alternative numbers B specimen with the alternative number “792” (F Catalog No. 620082; not available online; image from R. B. Setubal) C, D specimens with the numbers “482” and “792.B” written juxtaposed (K barcodes K000573484 and K000573485, respectively).
The two K specimens (Fig.
We also examined two additional specimens labeled M.R. Schomburgk s.n. (BR barcode BR0000005859795; GH, sheet without barcode or access number and not available online) without date, locality or collection number, and with label and handwriting that clearly differs from all other specimens. This material was cited as additional material examined and not type collection by
The protologue of S. trinitensis notes “Trinidad, Crueger at Caura”, indicating that the type material was collected by Herman Crueger (past director of the Trinidad Botanical Garden) at the Caura or Tacarigua River, a tributary of the Caroni River in the Northern Range of Trinidad Island. All the type material examined has the information “Caura, Sept. 1849”, and the name “Crueger” written with different legibility (Fig.
Comparison of labels on four type specimens of Strychnos trinitensis Griseb A lectotype (H. Crueger s.n., GOET barcode GOET005464) B–D isolectotypes B K barcode K000573430 C TRIN Catalog No. 258 D TRIN Catalog No. 1529.
Strychnos bredemeyeri (Schult. & Schult.f.) Sprague & Sandwith, Bull. Misc. Inform. Kew 3: 128 . 1927. Type: Venezuela. Caracas, [1786–1788] (fl.), F. Bredemeyer s.n. Lectotype (designated by Krukoff & Barneby [1969b: 181]): W [W0078191] ; isolectotype: B [BW02865000 , BW02865010] .
≡ Lasiostoma bredemeyeri Schult. & Schult.f., Mant. 3: 64. 1827.
≡ Rouhamon bredemeyeri (Schult. & Schult.f.) DC. in A.P. De Candolle, Prodr. 9: 18. 1845.
≡ Lasiostoma glabrum Willd. ex DC. in A.P. De Candolle, Prodr. 9: 18. 1845. nom. nud.
= Rouhamon pedunculatum A.DC. in A.P. De Candolle Prodr. 9: 561. 1845. Type: British Guiana [Brazil]. [Roraima]: ad Roraima, [Oct] 1842 (fl.), R.H. Schomburgk 482. Lectotype (designated here): G [G00132188]; isolectotypes: BM [BM000952958], F [V0062158F, V0062159F], G [G00368309, G00368310], GH [GH00076757], NY [NY00297387], P [P00647601, P00647602], TCD [TCD0000695], US [US00112974], W [W0078192, W0196054]).
≡ Strychnos schomburgkiana Klotzsch, Reis. Br.-Guiana [Ri. Schomburgk] 3: 1144. 1848. nom. nud.
≡ Strychnos pedunculata (A.DC.) Benth., J. Proc. Linn. Soc., Bot., 1: 105. 1857.
= Strychnos trinitensis Griseb., Fl. Brit. W.I.: 407. 1861. Type: Trinidad and Tobago. Caura, Sep 1849 (fl.), H. Crueger s.n. Lectotype (designated here): GOET [GOET005464]; isolectotypes: K [K000573430], NY [NY00297487], TRIN [Catalog Nos. 258, 1529], US [US01100481, US00112982]).
We are thankful to the curators and the staff of the F, GH, NY, and US herbaria for permission and assistance to consult their collections. Andreas Berger from W and Fred Stauffer from G provided personal information about type materials, databases, and online images. The staff from the Scientific Library of the Instituto de Pesquisas Ambientais of São Paulo Botanical Garden is acknowledged for access to and information about historical references. Benjamin M. Torke mentored the internship of RBS at NYBG in the research project Floristic Inventory of the Tapajos National Forest and Amazonia National Park. Additionally, we thank the reviewer and the editor for their contributions to improving this paper.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico, Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior, Fundação Carlos Chagas Filho de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, Support For National Science Foundation Graduate Fellows. RBS’s research at NYBG was funded by a grant from the NFS – National Science Foundation (DEB1456232, P.I. BMT), and work in Brazil was funded by CAPES – Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior grant (Code 001), and IAPT – International Association for Plant Taxonomy Research Grants Program in Plant Systematics. RCF thanks the research grants awarded by FAPERJ – Fundação Carlos Chagas Filho de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado do Rio de Janeiro (E‐26/200.967/2022) and the CNPq – Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (303059/2020-6).
Conceptualization: RCF, RBS, JP, LS. Data curation: JP, RCF, RBS, LS. Formal analysis: RBS, JP, RCF, LS. Funding acquisition: RBS, LS, RCF. Investigation: JP, LS, RCF, RBS. Methodology: RCF, JP, RBS. Project administration: RBS, RCF. Resources: RBS, LS, RCF. Supervision: RCF. Validation: JP, LS, RCF. Writing - original draft: RBS. Writing - review and editing: LS, RBS, RCF, JP.
Robberson Bernal Setubal https://orcid.org/0009-0006-1677-9137
Lena Struwe https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6074-5758
Jefferson Prado https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4783-3125
Rafaela Campostrini Forzza https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7035-9313
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text.