Research Article |
Corresponding author: Norbert Kilian ( n.kilian@bgbm.org ) Academic editor: Alexander Sukhorukov
© 2023 Jian-Wen Zhang, Norbert Kilian, Jiang-Hua Huang, Hang Sun.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Zhang J-W, Kilian N, Huang J-H, Sun H (2023) Ixeridium sagittarioides (Asteraceae-Cichorieae) revisited: range extension and molecular evidence for its systematic position in the Lactuca alliance. PhytoKeys 230: 115-130. https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.230.107733
|
Our first record of the rare and scatteredly distributed Ixeridium sagittarioides for Guizhou, China, triggered a study to assess its systematic position. The species was placed in four different genera in the course of its taxonomic history and was recently treated with doubts as a member of Ixeridium in the Flora of China. Comparative morphological investigation and phylogenetic analyses based on the nuclear ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacer (nrITS) and five non-coding plastid DNA regions (petD region, psbA-trnH, trnL-trnF, rpl32-trnL (UAG) and 5´rps16-trnQ (UUG) spacers) provided evidence that the species is not a member of Ixeridium and the Crepidinae but has evolved by ancient hybridisation of members of the Lactuca alliance (Lactucinae). It is reinstated as Lactuca sagittarioides and a comprehensive morphological description is provided, based on material from its entire range of distribution.
Asteraceae, Cichorieae, Crepidinae, Lactucinae, Lactuca sagittarioides, reticulate evolution, systematic position, taxonomy
A perennial herb with very conspicuous, usually long-petiolate sagittiform rosette leaves and a scattered distribution along the Himalayan mountain chain from N Pakistan and NW India across Nepal, Bhutan, N Myanmar and N Thailand to Yunnan (China), was originally described as Lactuca sagittarioides C.B.Clarke (
The study was based on the gathering of herbarium and tissue material for DNA isolation of Ixeridium sagittarioides from Guizhou, deposited in KUN, additional herbarium samples of this species from the herbaria of E, IMDY, K, KUN and PE, and further herbarium material of other species for morphological comparison from the herbaria of B, KUN, M and MSB (herbarium codes according to Index Herbariorum, http://sweetgum.nybg.org/science/ih/). In addition, digital images of specimens at BM and L were consulted through GBIF (https://www.gbif.org/species/3100771). To avoid wrong conclusions due to misidentification, occurrence records not substantiated by physical or digital specimens were not taken into account.
Extraction of DNA and amplification of markers for the accession of Ixeridium sagittarioides followed the protocols by
INSDC (International Nucleotide Sequence Database Collaboration) accession numbers of newly generated nrITS and plastid DNA sequences with specimen data of the sample used.
Sample | Specimen | Locality | Date | Marker: accession no. |
---|---|---|---|---|
Lactuca sagittarioides_ ZJW1091 | J. W. Zhang 1091 (KUN) | China, Guizhou, Wangmo, 25.18°N, 106.12°E, 700 m | 13 Apr 2018 | nrITS: OR196839; petD: OR221191; psbA-trnH: OR221192; trnL-trnF: OR221190; rpl32-trnL (UAG): OR221193; 5‘rps16-trnQ (UUG): OR221194. |
The Ixeridium sagittarioides sequences were initially included in the separate nrITS and plastid DNA matrices built by
Phylogenetic relationships were inferred using maximum parsimony (MP), maximum likelihood (ML) and Bayesian inference (BI). The last two were run on the high-performance computing system of the Freie Universität Berlin (
The aligned nrITS region of 76 samples had a length of 687 characters; together with the coded indels the matrix included a total of 778 characters, of which 298 were parsimony-informative. The MP analysis resulted in 1532 most parsimonious trees (L = 1391, CI = 0.479, RI = 0.674, RC = 0.323, HI = 0.521), largely congruent in topology with the trees of the BI and ML analyses. Fig.
The final aligned concatenated plastid DNA markers of 74 samples had a length of 5827 characters; together with the coded indels the matrix included a total of 6207 characters, of which 504 were parsimony-informative. The MP analysis resulted in 1720 most parsimonious trees (L = 1627, CI = 0.770, RI = 0.814, RC = 0.627, HI = 0.230), largely congruent in topology with the trees of the BI and ML analyses. Fig.
Ixeridium sagittarioides is deeply nested in the subtribe Lactucinae both in the nrITS (Fig.
For the comparison of Lactuca sagittarioides with Ixeridium on the one hand and its sister clades in the subtribe Lactucinae inferred from the molecular phylogenetic analyses of the nrITS and the plastid DNA matrices on the other hand, diagnostic morphological characters, in particular of the achenes (Fig.
Diagnostic morphological features of Lactuca sagittarioides in comparison with the genus Ixeridium and the related Lactucinae members inferred from the molecular phylogenetic analyses of the nrITS and the plastid DNA matrices, respectively.
Diagnostic features | Lactuca sagittarioides | Ixeridium | Lactuca racemosa-L. macrophylla clade | Paraprenanthes |
---|---|---|---|---|
Capitula | moderately narrowly cylindrical | moderately narrowly cylindrical | moderately narrowly to broadly cylindrical | narrowly cylindrical |
Corolla, colour | yellow | yellow | cyanic | cyanic |
Achenes, ribbing pattern | 5 main ribs each accompanied by 2 secondary ribs; lateral ribs not enlarged | 10 equal ribs, none winged | usually 4 main ribs each accompanied by 2 secondary ribs, lateral ribs winglike enlarged | 5 main ribs each accompanied by 2 secondary ribs; lateral ribs not enlarged |
Achenes, ornamentation | muricate | ± smooth | faintly muricate | muricate |
Achenes, carpopodium | callose, uninterrupted annular | ± callose, uninterrupted tubular | callose, uninterrupted annular | callose, uninterrupted annular |
Pappus, composition | one series of bristles | one series of bristles | one series of bristles and outer row of minute hairs | one series of bristles |
Pappus, colour | white | yellowish or straw-coloured | white | white |
Achenes A Lactuca sagittarioides; specimen: China, Yunnan, Forrest 29519 (E 00489230) B Paraprenanthes triflora; specimen: Nepal, Pokahara region, between Tikhedhunga and Ghorepani. 19 Sep 2008, A. Suchorukow N-15 (B) C Lactuca macrophylla; specimen: Turkey Artvin, Şavşat, Pınarlı Köyü, Balıkgölü girişi, kalıntı bitkiler arası, 2035 m, 13 Sep 2014, Coşkunçelebi & Güzel 339 (KTUB). Scale bars: 0.5 mm (A, B); 1 mm (C); photographs by Murat Güzel.
Molecular phylogenetics
Our molecular phylogenetic analyses resolved Ixeridium sagittarioides unanimously as a member of subtribe Lactucinae and therefore deprive the basis for the placement in Ixeridium and the Crepidinae. Otherwise, the analyses revealed a surprising cytonuclear discordance (
The achenes of Lactuca sagittarioides (Fig.
Within the Lactucinae, the weakly supported sister group relationship with the Lactuca racemosa-L. macrophylla clade in the nrITS phylogeny does not agree well with achene morphology (Fig.
The sister group relationship with Paraprenanthes alatipes of the Notoseris-Paraprenanthes clade revealed in the plastid DNA marker phylogeny, in contrast, shows a better agreement with achene morphology: shape, ribbing pattern, surface ornamentation and also pappus structure of L. sagittarioides and Paraprenanthes principally match (Fig.
Lactuca sagittarioides is distributed along the lower escarpments of the Himalaya belt and extends into the mountain ranges adjacent to the east in Yunnan and Guizhou. The new record from central northern Guizhou makes its presence also in the province of Sichuan rather likely. The Lactuca lineage (in the sense of
The context of the subtribe lends further support to such a scenario when we consider the numerous reticulation events at various depths of the species tree to be concluded from previous studies (
Taxa supposed to have evolved from ancient intergeneric reticulation events would, for consistency, be treated in a phylogeny-based classification as nothogenera. The relationships of the Lactucinae lineages tentatively classified at generic rank (
We treat the taxon in accordance with the findings of the nuclear ribosomal ITS phylogeny as a member of Lactuca.
≡ Ixeris sagittarioides (C.B.Clarke) Stebbins in J. Bot. 75: 51. 1937.
≡ Ixeridium sagittarioides (C.B.Clarke) Pak & Kawano in Mem. Fac. Sci. Kyoto Univ., Ser. Biol. 15: 48. 1992.
≡ Mycelis sagittarioides (C.B.Clarke) Sennikov in Bot. Zhurn. 82(5): 112. 1997.
“Himalaya boreali-occidentali”, 6000’, T. Thomson (K); [India, Uttarakhand, Kumaon Hills] “Nynee Tal” [= Nainital], T. Thomson (K); [India, Himachal Pradesh, Punjab] “Dhurmsala” [= Dharamshala], C.B. Clarke (K); Nepal, 3.1821, Wallich Cat. 3270 (K001118954, digit. image!; BM 000035537, digit. image!); Burma, ad Moyen, 1200’, J. Anderson (K).
Perennial rosette herb, (15–)20–65 cm tall; caudex small, often branched and plant with a two or a few rosettes. Taproot cylindric to narrowly turniplike, to c. 1 cm in diam.; lateral roots perhaps also shoot-bearing. Stem usually one per rosette, erect, branched from basal half or higher up, leafless or with few leaves in proximal portion, sparsely hairy. Rosette leaves conspicuously sagittiform and usually long-petiolate; petiole 2–22 cm, narrowly winged, margin entire or distantly sinuate-dentate; lamina triangular in outline, 2–8 × 1.5–10 cm, usually with a basal pair of acute to acuminate triangular lateral lobes and an acute triangular terminal lobe; the lateral lobes narrow or broad, sometimes much reduced to missing, directed downwards, outwards or upwards; sometimes lamina with an additional rudimentary pair of lobes above the basal one and then pentagonal; margin shallowly sinuate-dentate and often also denticulate. Stem leaves few, the lower ones similar to basal leaves but smaller and less lobed, upper leaves lanceolate to linear-lanceolate, entire, narrowed into short petiolate portion. Synflorescence paniculiform-corymbiform, with some to many capitula. Capitula with c. 12–25 florets; peduncle wiry, mostly 1–2 cm long. Involucre narrowly cylindric, 7–8 mm at anthesis to 8–10 mm at fruiting; outer phyllaries narrowly ovate to lanceolate, apex acute, outermost c. 2 mm, innermost up to 2/3 of the length of the inner (rarely longer); inner phyllaries c. 8(–10), linear-lanceolate, acute. Florets with [orange-, according to collector] yellow corolla, c. 12–14 mm; ligulae c. 6–8 mm; anther tube yellow, fertile portion c. 2.2 mm, apical appendages 0.2 mm, basal appendages 0.4–0.5 mm; style yellow. Achenes 4–4.5 mm long, slightly compressed, subfusiform with largest diameter in middle third, apically attenuate into a beak, basally less strongly attenuate into an annular carpophore; corpus with 5 main ribs, each with ±2 secondary ribs; scabrid of antrorse triangular apical projections of achene epidermis cells, brown to purplish brown; beak 0.6–1.2(–2) mm, pale. Pappus 4–6 mm, persistent, of scabrid, white bristles.
Although the leaves are always distinctly sagittiform, their shape and size underlie considerable variation. The shape variation given in the description is believed to circumscribe its full extent, but we are uncertain whether the size variation is fully covered in the description. A sterile specimen from NW Himalaya (Chamba state, Kuntha Forest, Aug 1898, J.H. Lace 14C (E00360966) only including a leaf rosette may belong to Lactuca sagittarioides; its leaves approach 40 cm in length, with a petiole of up to 30 cm, and a lamina of up to 10 × 20 cm. The beak length of the achenes usually ranges between 0.6–1.2 mm, but Gamble 23483 from NWP has a beak of c. 2 mm; its innermost outer phyllaries are unusually long, approaching the inner in length.
India. Uttarakhand: Kumaon, Lohba, 5500’ Apr 1848, R. Strachey & J.B. Winterbottom (K); Kumaon, Gungoli, 5300’, R. Stratchey & J.S. Winterbottom (BM 011024277, digit. image). – Uttar Pradesh, [“North western Province, Jannsar[?] District, 3000’, May 1892, J.S. Gamble (K).
Bhutan. Khine Lhakang, 6000’, 15 Apr 1949, F. Ludlow et al. 20135 (BM 000035434, digit. image)
Burma. Shan hills Matean[?] near Wankou[?], 5000’, Mar 1888, H. Collett 471 (K); Mundat, 4800’, 29 Apr 1956, F. Kingdon-Ward 22171 (BM 11024278, digit. image).
Thailand. Chiengmai, Doi Sutep, open Quercus forest, 1250 m, 18 Apr 1958, T. Sørensen et al. 2876 (C, digit. image)
China. Yunnan: Salween valley, 25°6'N, 98°50'E, slopes, dry grassy banks, Apr 1931 G. Forrest 29519 (E 00489230, PE); Jengyueh, 25°N, 98°36'E, 5000–7000’, hills, dry clay pasture, Aug 1924, G. Forrest 24794 (E00489233); Jengyueh, 25°N, 98°36'E, 5000–7000’, hills, open pasture, Mar 1924 G. Forrest 24004 (E00489232); Jengyueh, 25°N, 98°36'E, 7000’, hills, open stony clay pasture, Apr 1925, G. Forrest 26308 (E 00489231; K, PE); [...], S.W. grass mts, 5000’, A. Henry 12998 (K); Jingdong, San Cha Ho, 24°36'56"N, 100°42'35"E, 1600 m, 13 Mar 1940, M.G. Li 1884 (KUN); Shuangjiang, 23°28'24.6"N, 99°49'39.72"E, 1068 m, Apr 1936, C.W. Wang 72957 (KUN, PE); Xingping, Pingdian, 24°01'21"N, 101°52'20"E, 1326 m, 1 Jun 2012, Xingping survey team 5304270356 (IMDY); Menghai, Meng’e, 22°13'30"N, 100°17'49"E, 1195 m, Menghai survey team 5328220572 (IMDY); Jinghong, Caiyang River, 22°09'23.51"N, 101°11'59.28"E, 1250 m, Jinghong survey team 5328010664 (IMDY). – Guizhou: Wangmo, 25.18°N, 106.12°E, 700 m, 13 Apr 2018, J.W. Zhang 1091 (KUN).
Lactuca sagittarioides is distributed along the Himalayan chain from N Pakistan across NW India, Nepal, Bhutan, N Myanmar and N Thailand to SW China (for references see
We thank the herbaria in Beijing (PE), Copenhagen (C), Edinburgh (E), Jinghong (IMDY), Kew (K) and Munich (M and MSB) for the loan of specimens. We are indebted to Dr. Hong-Liang Chen (Kunming) for assisting in lab work and Murat E. Güzel (Trabzon/Berlin) for providing the achenes photos of Fig.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
This study was supported by grants-in-aid from the Yunnan Ten-Thousand Talents Plan Young & Elite Talent Project (YNWR-QNBJ-2019-154), the National Key R&D Program of China (2017YFC0505200 to H.S.), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC, 31000101, 31370004 and 31570213 to J.-W. Zhang).
Jianwen Zhang and Norbert Kilian conceptualised the paper and worte the draft of the manuscript, and did, together with Jiang-Hua Huang and Hang Sun, the investigation. All authors reviewed and revised the manuscript.
Jian-Wen Zhang https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4735-168X
Norbert Kilian https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0890-4373
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text.