Corresponding author: Margaret Sporck-Koehler ( firstname.lastname@example.org )
Academic editor: Vicki Funk
© 2015 Margaret Sporck-Koehler, Tobias Koehler, Sebastian Marquez, Mashuri Waite, Adam Williams.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0) which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation: Sporck-Koehler MJ, Koehler TB, Marquez SN, Waite M, Williams AM (2015) A new species of Cyanea (Campanulaceae, Lobelioideae), from the Ko‘olau Mountains of O‘ahu, Hawaiian Islands. PhytoKeys 46: 45-60. doi: 10.3897/phytokeys.46.8694
Cyanea konahuanuiensis Sporck-Koehler, M. Waite, A.M. Williams, sp. nov., a recently documented, narrowly endemic species from the Hawaiian Island of O‘ahu, is described and illustrated with photographs from the field. The closest likely relatives to the species, current conservation needs, and management future are discussed. It is currently known from 20 mature plants from two subpopulations and is restricted to a drainage below the Kōnāhua-nui summit (K1), the highest summit of the Ko‘olau Mountains, located on Windward O‘ahu. It differs from all other Cyanea species by its combination of densely pubescent leaves, petioles, and flowers; sparsely pubescent to glabrous stems, long calyx lobes, and staminal column being adnate to the corolla.
Campanulaceae, conservation, Cyanea, endemic, Hawai‘i, Hawaiian Islands, IUCN Red List, Kōnāhua-nui, Ko‘olau Mountains, Lobeliads, Lobelioideae, O‘ahu, rare plants, Rollandia
The Campanulaceae is a large, diverse, and cosmopolitan plant family with representatives inhabiting a wide range of ecosystems including tropical, subtropical, temperate, and even frigid zones with exceptional diversification in South Africa and Hawai‘i (
In September 2012, the Kōnāhua-nui summit area of the Ko‘olau Mountains on the island of O‘ahu was surveyed (Figure
Distribution map of Cyanea konahuanuiensis showing site of population on South East O‘ahu in the Ko‘olau Mountain Range.
Preliminary research in the following weeks consisted of examining the plants using photos and the one fallen, partially decayed leaf collected from the field. After reviewing the current treatments of Cyanea, sharing the photos with local experts, and looking at specimens at the Bishop Museum, it was concluded that the species in question was most likely undescribed. To be certain, fertile specimen was required.
Thereafter, trips to the remote population were made every two to three months. These subsequent expeditions surveyed the surrounding area and revealed the presence of additional individuals. In June 2013, an automated game camera was installed connected to cellular phone service that transmitted a photo of one of the plants three times per 24 hour period (Figure
Cyanea konahuanuiensis. Game camera time lapse series illustrating flower and early fruit development over a nearly two month time frame. Panels A–D each illustrate a different stage of development. Red arrows point to developing flower and fruit features.
In addition, type specimens of all of the Hawaiian Lobeliads were examined in the Herbarium Pacificum of the Bernice Pauahi Bishop Museum (BISH) collection, with special attention given to Clermontia, Cyanea, Delissea, and the formerly recognized generic group, Rollandia Gaudich. None of the Hawaiian Campanulaceae was a match to the Cyanea under study.
There are several species that share some characteristics with C. konahuanuiensis including: Cyanea crispa Gaudich., Cyanea calycina Gaudich., Cyanea humboldtiana Gaudich., and Cyanea pilosa A. Gray (Table
Selected traits for Cyanea konahuanuiensis compared to four Cyanea taxa sharing some similar morphological characteristics. Abbreviations: O = O‘ahu, H = Hawai‘i Island.
|Species||Plant height (m)||Leaf length (cm)||Leaf width (cm)||Leaf shape||Adaxial leaf surface char.||Abaxial leaf surface char.||Peduncle Length (mm)||Number of flowers in inflorescence||Calyx lobe shape||Calyx lobe length (mm)||Hypanthium length (mm)||Flower Color||Corolla surface char.||Island found on|
|C. konahuanuiensis||0.57–0.69||20–33||10–16||elliptic–oblong||densely hirsute, juveniles subtlety muricate||densely hirsute, juveniles subtlety muricate||50–122||3–12||linear to linear-oblong||16–18||10–15||dark magenta/ purple w/ some lighter streaking as flowers age||densely pubescent||O|
|C. calycina||1–3||15–60||5.5–14||elliptic–oblanceolate||glabrous, juveniles muricate||densely pubescent w/branched & clustered hairs||20–100||4–16||oblong- ovate||4–10||6–12||pale–dark magenta, rarely pale greenish w/ lighter or darker longitudinal stripes||pubescent||O|
|C. crispa||0.3–1.3||30–75||9–16||broadly obovate||glabrous||glabrous or pubescent||20–30||3–8||ovate–oblong||6–12||8–12||pale magenta w/ darker longitudinal stripes||pubescent||O|
|C. humboldtiana||1–2||18–45||7–16||obovate–broadly elliptic||glabrous||pubescent||80–250||5–12||oblong||4–10||8–12||dark magenta, rarely white||pubescent||O|
|C. pilosa||0.8–2||15–42||8–15||broadly elliptic–broadly obovate||pubescent||whitish green, densely pubescent||15–110||6–28||narrowly triangular||2–5||4–6||white||pubescent||H|
The Hawai‘i Island endemic C. pilosa shares a comparable leaf shape and is similarly pubescent (though dissection scope inspection revealed that hair structure differs) to C. konahuanuiensis, but the latter lacks hairy stems and has more abundant hair on both leaf surfaces. Also, flower color and calyx lobe length differ radically, C. pilosa usually having white flowers and much shorter calyx lobes (2–5 mm long) and C. konahuanuiensis having brilliant purple flowers. Lastly, unlike C. konahuanuiensis, the staminal column of C. pilosa is not adnate to the corolla tube (Figures
Cyanea konahuanuiensis. A habit, photo with Adam M. Williams crouched down next to plant for scale B Seedlings growing in test tube in micropropagation lab C juvenile plant in the field D flowering stem with pendent inflorescence captured (photos by Margaret J. Sporck-Koehler ).
Cyanea konahuanuiensis. A detail of corolla tube in profile. Dense pubescence and long calyx lobes apparent B close up view of buds C view of plant habit depicting single-stalked individual D view of plant habit depicting multi-stalked individual (photos by Tobias B. Koehler).
Cyanea konahuanuiensis. Inflorescence/flowers illustrating pendant inflorescence, dense pubescence of flowers, and long calyx lobes. Pubescent petioles and hairless stems are also apparent (photo by Tobias B. Koehler).
Cyanea konahuanuiensis. Inflorescence/flowers illustrating dense pubescence of flowers, long calyx lobes. Pubescent leaves also apparent (photo by Chris A. Johns).
Cyanea konahuanuiensis. Solitary stem illustrating typical leaf arrangement clustered distally near the stem terminus (photo by Chris A. Johns).
Cyanea konahuanuiensis. Photo of leaf illustrating dense pubescence on both adaxial and abaxial leaf surfaces (photo by Tobias B. Koehler).
Because so few individuals of C. konahuanuiensis are known, collections were limited to two fertile vouchers, each including one inflorescence and two leaves. Flowers were also collected from three individual plants and preserved in alcohol for precise floral analysis (see Specimens Examined section). In order to ensure limited damage to the population and to further conserve the species, detailed measurements were taken of five, reproductively mature and flowering, live plants in the wild for most of the descriptive information in this paper. For corolla tube lobe length and width, surface characteristics, and anther length and surface characteristic data from the preserved flowers were utilized. Seed data are taken from living material deposited at the University of Hawai‘i Harold L. Lyon Arboretum micropropagation facility. Selected measurements from the dried holotype specimen are included parenthetically in the description.
Species believed to be allied to Cyanea humboldtiana (Gaudich.) Lammers, Givnish & Sytsma, but primarily differs in its longer calyx lobes (16–18 mm long); and its more densely pubescent leaves, petioles, flowers, and differing flowering period. C. humboldtiana has leaves, petioles, and flowers that are more sparsely pubescent with shorter trichomes; leaf margins are callose-crenulate, floral bracts have acute apices, and its calyx lobes are ovate, acuminate and considerably shorter (4–10 mm long). The two species are reproductively isolated from each other due to lack of overlapping flowering periods (C. konahuanuiensis flowers from June–August and C. humboldtiana from October–December), and they are not known to intergrade.
Unarmed shrubs 57–69 cm high, with 1–6 stems originating at the base; stems light green and darkening to a light brownish gray closer to the base, erect to decumbent, 58–119 cm in length, some branches partially resting on the ground, occasionally rooting when in contact with the soil or moss producing aerial roots, leaf scars subcircular, 9.5–12 × 6.5–11.8 mm, upper end of leaf scar depressed, basal portion slightly raised; leaf scar with a protuberance; latex white. Leaves clustered distally near end of stems, petiolate; petioles 2–4.2 cm long, pubescent; blades elliptic to oblong, in adult plants 20–33 × 10–16 cm, base cuneate to rounded, occasionally slightly truncate, apex acute to sub-obtuse, margins serrate to serrate-dentate, dull grayish-green on adaxial surface and dull greenish white on abaxial surface, stiff, slightly fleshy, both surfaces densely hirsute and minutely muricate; in juvenile plants leaves are less stiff, margins dentate, and hairs softer. Inflorescences axillary just above the leaf, up to 4 per stem, young inflorescences roughly perpendicular to stem, larger and more developed inflorescences pendant, 3–12 flowered, peduncles 5–12.2 cm long (dried specimen 7.7 cm long), pubescent. Flowers on pedicels 7–14 mm long (5–10 mm when dried), pubescent, subtended by linear bracts 7–18 × 2–6 mm, apex obtuse, margins entire, densely pubescent; hypanthium 10–15 mm (9–14 mm when dried) × 7–10 mm (5–7 mm when dried), obovoid to cylindrical, pubescent; calyx lobes linear to linear-oblong,16–18 × 5–7 mm (13–17 × 3–5 mm when dried), apex acute to subobtuse, retained on immature (green) fruits (no mature fruit seen); corolla dark purple with some lighter streaks developing with age, tubular, laterally compressed, curved, 86–99 mm long (80–95 mm when dried) × 12–13 mm wide medially (9–12 mm when dried), externally densely pubescent, internally glabrous, the lobes linear-subulate, 10–16 mm long × 5 mm wide at the base, reflexed, c. 1/4–1/3 as long as the tube; staminal column glabrous, adnate to corolla for half its length, anthers 9–10 mm long, scantily pubescent, the lower two with apical tufts of white hairs 2–3 mm long. Fruits berries (mature fruits not seen), immature fruits densely pubescent, with calyx lobes persistent. Seeds from immature fruits numerous, embedded in green pulp, obovoid, 0.74–0.84 × 0.58–0.64 mm, testa medium to dark brown, shiny and smooth.
Known only from the Kōnāhua-nui summit area in the Ko‘olau Mountains of O‘ahu, Hawaiian Islands. The population is on land owned by the State of Hawai‘i, Department of Land and Natural Resources (DLNR), and is part of the Honolulu Watershed Forest Reserve (Figure
Cyanea konahuanuiensis occurs in wet forest sites at elevations from 884 to 932 m. The associated native Hawaiian plant species include Broussaisia arguta Gaudich., Cheirodendron platyphylla (Hook & Arn.) Seem., Dubautia laxa (Hook. & Arn.) Machaerina angustifolia (Gaudich.) T. Koyama, Metrosideros rugosa A. Gray, Perrotettia sandwicensis A. Gray, Phyllostegia grandiflora (Gaudich.) Benth., Polyscias gymnocarpa (Hillebr.) Lowry & G. M. Plunkett, Sadleria pallida Hook. & Arn., Scaevola mollis Hook. & Arn., and species of Cibotium Kaulf., Kadua Cham. & Schltdl., Labordia Gaud., Melicope J.R. Forst. & G. Forst., and Wikstroemia Endl. Introduced naturalized plant species include: Ageratina adenophora (Spreng.) R.M. King & H. Rob., Clidemia hirta (L.) D. Don, Hedychium gardnerianum Sheppard ex Ker Gawl., Rubus rosifolius Sm., and Setaria palmifolia (J. König) Stapf. Bryophyte species are prevalent and include Distichophyllum freycinetii (Schwägr.) Mitt., Plagiochila diflexa Mont. & Gottsche, and species of Bazzania S. Gray. The native arthropod, Megalagrion oahuense Blackburn (a Hawaiian endemic damselfly) has been observed on C. konahuanuiensis. Soil is of basaltic origin and typical of wet forest sites on O‘ahu and the average annual rainfall is approximately 2600 mm (
Cyanea konahuanuiensis has been observed flowering from June–August with fruit developing from August–October. All observed fruits have aborted, been eaten, or decomposed before maturity. The lifespan and time to maturity of the species is unknown. Immature, nearly aborted fruits have been collected when all others had aborted. Fruits have been submitted to the Lyon Arboretum Micropropagation lab where some of the seeds have germinated and it is interesting to note that the seedlings have densely pubescent leaves (Figure
The specific name pays homage to the twin-peaked (946 m and 960 m) Kōnāhua-nui Pu‘u (summit), the tallest peaks in the Ko‘olau Mountain range on windward (east) O‘ahu. Lit. Large fat innards (
Cyanea konahuanuiensis is a critically imperiled species (see Conservation status below) due to its low population numbers and exceptionally narrow endemism. Some of the conservation obstacles to overcome include probable loss of most, if not all, of its native avian pollinators and dispersers, and suspected herbivory by introduced taxa such as rats, terrestrial gastropod mollusks (slugs), and feral pigs (Sus scrofa). Invasive plant species are becoming increasingly common even in relatively hard to access sites along and near mountain summits in Hawai‘i. Species such as Ageratina adenophora, Clidemia hirta, Erigeron karvinskianus, Hedychium gardnerianum, Rubus rosifolius and Setaria palmifolia are competing with C. konahuanuiensis and other native species for space and resources. It is conceivable that stochastic events such as landslides, hurricanes, and flash-flooding could obliterate the majority or all of the currently known plants with a single event. Approximately 20 mature plants and several immature plants have been observed in total. Plants that were observed ranged from seedlings to reproductively mature individuals. Seedlings are scarce, however, which suggests that the population may be declining.
The Hawai‘i DLNR, Division of Forestry and Wildlife (DOFAW) has largely funded this research by providing staff time to further investigate this species. The Hawai‘i Plant Extinction Prevention (PEP) Program focuses on conserving and restoring plants with less than 50 known wild individuals. Because C. konahuanuiensis falls within that threshold, O‘ahu PEP is working closely with DOFAW staff to protect this critically rare taxon. The first goal of the PEP Program is to secure seeds or propagules from each individual mature plant for ex situ germplasm banking. The long-term goal for the PEP Program and DOFAW will be to collaborate in the effort to grow and out-plant nursery stock into appropriate restoration sites. Currently there are no protected (fenced) areas in similar habitat with comparable elevation, rainfall, humidity, and species composition on O‘ahu. Our recommendation is that additional fenced out-planting sites be established in appropriate areas of the Ko‘olau Mountains in order to establish multiple populations of this species. The authors emphasize the importance of prioritizing staff time to carry out further vegetation surveys in areas that have not been explored in recent history as this exciting new find shows that even seemingly well botanized areas in Hawai‘i may yet yield new discoveries.
In October 2013, immature fruits from two plants were collected and have since germinated at the UH Harold L. Lyon Arboretum after being directly sown on an agar medium. This is valuable information since at this time all observed fruits seem to be aborting prior to maturity. We recommend collecting immature fruit (or mature fruit if possible) from all reproductive individuals during future fruiting seasons in order to secure genetic representation from all reproductively mature individuals in ex situ collections.
The use of cellular phone-connected game cameras is recommended for monitoring of rare plants in remote locations. This novel use of game camera technology saved time and resources, optimizing the timing of visits and increasing the likelihood of making successful and representative observations required for the species description and fruit collections. This rapidly improving technology could have many positive impacts on monitoring rare plants for flower development, fruit development, herbivory impacts, and the effects of various seasonal events.
USA. Hawaiian Islands O‘ahu [East O‘ahu]: Paratypes: dried herbarium specimen BISH 1049144; and spirit collections: BISH 1059013, BISH 1059014, and BISH 1059015.
For over a century the taxa that currently comprise the genus Cyanea were recognized as two separate genera, Cyanea and Rollandia. The genus Rollandia was distinguished from Cyanea based on the single character of staminal column adnation to corolla in the former (
There is currently no published taxonomic key for Cyanea that includes the merger of the Rollandia clade. The following couplets can be inserted into the most recent revision of Rollandia (
|2(1)||Inflorescence pendent, peduncles 50–250 mm long||2’|
|2’(2)||Upper leaf surface glabrous, calyx lobes 4–10 mm long||C. humboldtiana|
|2’||Upper leaf surface densely pubescent, calyx lobes 16–18 mm long||C. konahuanuiensis|
Using the IUCN Red List criteria (
The authors extend our appreciation to the Department of Land and Natural Resources, Division of Forestry and Wildlife (DLNR/DOFAW) for access to the Honolulu Watershed Forest Reserve (FR) and use of staff time for this project. We thank Randall W. Kennedy, Ryan K. Peralta, David G. Smith, and Marigold S. Zoll from DLNR/DOFAW for encouraging us to write this species description and for technical support with accessing the FR. Sincere thanks go to Keahi M. Bustamente, Marian M. Chau, William P. Haines, Susan Ching Harbin, J. Christopher Havran, Clyde T. Imada, Matthew J. Keir, Timothy I. Kroessig, Joel Q. C. Lau, Clifford W. Morden, Kīhei Nahale-a, Kaua Neumann, Douglas O. Okamoto, Hank L. Oppenheimer, Richard J. Pender, Tom A. Ranker, Lara S. Reynolds, and Lauren A. Weisenberger for botanical expertise, assistance, encouragement, and thought-provoking discussions. Thank you to Yoshiko Akashi for making the species distribution map and thanks to Chris A. Johns for making a special trip to take descriptive photos. We thank Barbara H. Kennedy, the collection manager of the Bernice P. Bishop Museum herbarium (BISH) for access to specimens and assistance with preparing the Type specimens for this study and we thank the Lyon Arboretum for assistance with managing propagules that were obtained during the course of this study. This manuscript was greatly improved by suggestions from David H. Lorence (PTBG) who also provided encouragement and mentorship throughout the process from investigating the plants to writing the paper. Vicki A. Funk and Warren L. Wagner (US) are thanked for valuable suggestions on the manuscript.